Two Months on the Front Lines of Mass Deportation

TPM has spent the past two months documenting the front lines of mass deportation in New York City. In courthouses, in churches, outside community gatherings and through an extensive digital network, we started to get a feel for and gain access to what we’re calling the “Undocumented Underground“: a volunteer army helping immigrants to stay in the country, even in the face of the Trump administration’s onslaught and some of its uniquely New York features, such as violent arrests in the halls of immigration court.

We published our first two installments in the series last week. The third — on legal clinics for immigrants facing deportation — is up this morning. Lou, a self-described “ex-finance guy” who is now “deeply involved” with one of these organizations says he started volunteering because of the hardships faced by migrants he’s met. 

“They literally have nothing,” Lou tells reporter Hunter Walker. “All they have is their character and their story.” 

Read Hunter’s latest here, and keep an eye out for several more installments this week.

series intro | first piece | second piece | third piece

Underground Legal Clinics Offer a Lifeline to Migrants Facing Mass Deportation 

At his clinic, John Sirabella is a hard man to talk to. 

On a recent evening, in the back of a cavernous church basement, he led a training for over two dozen people gathered on folding chairs. Translators and volunteers sat at rows of tables. The session was dedicated to helping immigrants navigate the intense scenes in the Manhattan courthouses where masked Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents have taken to snatching people who show up for scheduled hearings and routine appointments.

After Sirabella ran through his presentation and encouraged people to sign up to help with multiple programs, one volunteer asked, “Where is your need greatest?”

Sirabella explained that his top priority is assembling a team of multilingual volunteers who can reach out to immigrants they have encountered on their days acting as observers and escorts in court.

“My goal, my vision is that everyone we’ve met in court since March is notified; they know we’re here, we’re open, and we’re ready to support them,” Sirabella explained. “Whether they choose to go to us is up to them.”

Continue reading “Underground Legal Clinics Offer a Lifeline to Migrants Facing Mass Deportation “

Trump Finds Out Bullying Doesn’t Work in Indiana

Hello it’s the weekend. This is The Weekender ☕️

Despite weeks of threats and mounting pressure from President Trump, Indiana Republican senators defied Donald Trump’s redistricting pressure campaign in Indiana this week. It was a stunning loss for Trump’s ongoing gerrymandering blitz as he pressures red states across the nation to redraw their maps to try to ensure Republicans hold the U.S. House in the midterms. 

In a 31-19 vote on Thursday, Indiana state senators rejected a gerrymandered map proposal that would have redrawn district lines to favor Republicans, and one that would have effectively kicked Indiana Democrats out of representation in the U.S. House.  

Several Indiana lawmakers have been outspoken about the reasons for why they did not cave to Trump’s bully tactics. The decision to buck Trump comes at a time when utter capitulation to the Trump administration has become mainstream. Several said they defied the Trump administration because they didn’t like the pressure Trump was placing on state level lawmakers. Others said it was a personal choice, rooted in disagreements and dislike for the president’s character. 

During an Indiana state Senate Elections Committee hearing on the proposed maps this week, Republican state Sen. Greg Walker, announced that he refused “to be intimidated” by the Trump administration. 

“I made a choice. I will not let Indiana or any state become subject to the threat of political violence in order to influence legislative product,” he added. 

GOP Indiana state Sen. Michael Bohacek said, ahead of Thursday’s vote, that he would vote against redistricting after the president used a slur to describe Minnesota’s Democratic Gov. Tim Walz.

“This is not the first time our president has used these insulting and derogatory references and his choices of words have consequences,” Bohacek wrote on Facebook in a post explaining that his daughter has Down Syndrome.

And Republican state Sen. Greg Goode similarly spoke out against redistricting shortly before Thursday’s vote. 

“Indiana did this just four years ago, the map produced was celebrated by legislative leadership, and Indiana served as a national model for getting things right through Hoosier common sense,” he said. 

— Khaya Himmelman

‘You Only Have One Tool’: A Divided, Dataless Fed Cuts Rates As the Economy Moves in Two Different Directions

Ahead of the first meeting of the Federal Reserve Board following an unprecedented federal economic data blackout, Fed watchers predicted a potentially historic outcome. Axios mulled the idea that, if the Fed opted not to cut rates, three of the seven-member governors board could dissent, a split not seen since 1963. Markets waffled over a period of mere weeks, from a low 20% expectation of a quarter-percent rate cut before surging to 87% likelihood.

On Wednesday, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell announced the board’s expected decision to cut rates by a quarter of a percent. Only one of the seven board members dissented. It was, you guessed it, Trump’s most recent appointee, Stephan Miran who always seems to want the higher rate cut the president is asking for. Among the larger voting members — 12 in all — three dissented, with two wanting no cut at all. This marked the fourth consecutive split Fed vote, the longest stretch of divided decisions since 2019, CNN reported. The 9-3 split was also the first since 2019, but hardly as notable as what could’ve gone down.

Fueling the uncertainty was leftover anxiety about major data gaps caused by the six-week government shutdown. Governors didn’t get information about October inflation, there was no October jobs report, and the November inflation report that should’ve been published Wednesday morning had been pushed to late next week. Here’s what members could see: the jobs market is at best stagnant and at worst in decline, while inflation chugs ahead buoyed by Trump’s tariff policy, indicators moving in opposite directions. “You have one tool,” Powell said Wednesday, addressing the dueling economic narratives. “You can’t do two things at once.”

— Layla A. Jones

It’s Not Just Dems: GOPers Pressure Leadership to Do Something About Looming Rise in Health Care Costs

Up on Capitol Hill, GOP leadership is under pressure to address the looming health care cost crisis from their respective caucuses.

The Senate GOP voted Thursday — largely for show — on two competing plans to address the expiring Affordable Care Act subsidies. Both failed to meet the 60 vote threshold, making it even more likely that millions will be hit with skyrocketing health care costs at the end of the year. But, it’s worth noting, the Democratic plan to extend the subsidies for three years had a handful of Republican senators cross the aisle and break with their own caucus to send a clear message to leadership.

“I hope the message is, ‘We need to do something here,’” said Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO), one of the GOP senators who voted for the Democratic bill, on Thursday. “We’re all under pressure.”

On the House side, seemingly fed up with House Speaker Mike Johnson’s (R-LA) inaction, Republican members have filed and are supporting discharge petitions to vote on extending the enhanced subsidies.

Under pressure from their caucus, House GOP leadership is working on a health care overhaul ahead of a planned vote next week to address the Obamacare subsidies. The plan is not expected to extend the ACA subsidies, though.

— Emine Yücel

One Week Away from Even More Epstein

House Democrats trickled out more Epstein info on Friday in the form of a cache of photos showing the hobnobbing convicted sex offender’s relationship with powerful figures that include President Trump, former President Bill Clinton, and other luminaries like Larry Summers, Steve Bannon, Bill Gates, and Woody Allen.

The photos further document what we already knew: Epstein and these guys really got along! If photos of Epstein yukking it up with Woody Allen, Bannon, Trump, and others aren’t enough to make you gag, the cache includes more: Dems on the House Oversight Committee also included photos of various sex toys, as well as an eerie ribbed black glove.

And it’s not the end of the Epstein revelations. A Manhattan federal judge ordered a bevy of grand jury records from the Manhattan federal criminal investigation released next Friday, Dec. 19. That’s expected to pale in comparison to what the DOJ is now required by law to release, though with notable exceptions: the government can withhold information subject to ongoing criminal investigations, like the ones that Trump ordered the DOJ to open last month.

— Josh Kovensky

Towards a Deeper Understanding of Our Age of Monsters and Predators

I got a fascinating array of responses to my Tuesday post about the 21st century nabobs, striding over politics and society with their unheard of wealth and indifference to the rules we once imagined bound us. One of the big questions was, What happened to the original nabobs? Were they brought to heel? And several of you asked, Okay, so what are we going to do about this? I wanted to discuss these and other topics.

Continue reading “Towards a Deeper Understanding of Our Age of Monsters and Predators”

BREAKING: Judge Blocks ICE From Re-Detaining Abrego Garcia

Sua Sponte and Nunc Pro Tunc

In a dramatic series of overnight developments, the Trump administration took extraordinary steps to try to re-detain Kilmar Abrego Garcia within hours of his court-ordered release, but a federal judge stepped in and blocked the move.

U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis of Maryland issued a temporary restraining order at 7 a.m. ET today barring the Trump administration from taking Abrego Garcia back into custody after she ordered his release yesterday. Her emergency order came after ICE directed Abrego Garcia to report to its Baltimore field office at 8 a.m. ET today. Fearing that Abrego Garcia would be re-detained when he showed up at ICE offices, his lawyers filed an emergency motion overnight imploring Xinis to intervene.

All of this unfolded only hours after Abrego Garcia was released from ICE custody on order from Xinis.

The highly unusual series of late-breaking events was punctuated by a remarkably cynical move by a Baltimore immigration judge, an executive branch official.

But first some context: The basis of Xinis’ order to release Abrego Garcia was that ICE had never issued an order of removal against him — itself an extraordinary development because his wrongful deportation in March to El Salvador and his subsequent detention since he was returned to the United States were entirely predicated on the supposed issuance of an order of removal in 2019.

After Xinis ruled Thursday morning that no such order of removal existed, Philip P. Taylor, the acting regional deputy chief immigration judge in Baltimore, rushed out a new order around 7 p.m. ET that purported to fix the “scrivener’s error” in ICE’s records on Abrego Garcia and retroactively create an order of removal. Taylor’s order was comically subtitled: “Immigration Court’s Sua Sponte Order Correcting Scrivener’s Error.”

Taylor’s sudden intervention is procedurally flawed in myriad ways, but that didn’t stop him from purporting to make a number of “corrections” to the record in Abrego Garcia’s 2019 case, waving it all away with a breezy: “These corrections are hereby issued nunc pro tunc to the Immigration Court’s written decision and order of October 10, 2019.”

In her emergency order this morning, Judge Xinis gave all of this such an aggressively arched eyebrow that she might have pulled a muscle:

The ICE Order of Supervision also states that Abrego Garcia was “ordered removed” on October 10, 2019, despite no such order having issued on that date. Instead, the ICE Order of Supervision seems to rely on an “order” issued last night from Immigration Judge Phillip Taylor. The Court does not opine on this newest “order” here. But the Court does note that this “order” was issued nunc pro tunc, effective October 10, 2019.

It was clear months ago that Abrego Garcia is being punished by the Trump administration for having the temerity to challenge his wrongful deportation to El Salvador in violation of a separate immigration judge’s order. Abrego Garcia’s unlawful incarceration in El Salvador, his return to the United States under a ginned-up criminal indictment, and his subsequent ICE detention have been among the most egregious rule-of-law violations of the Trump II presidency.

On top of that, the Trump administration has repeatedly defied Xinis’ orders in the Abrego Garcia cases, a fact not lost on Xinis herself, who writes in her emergency order:

[T]he public retains keen interest in ensuring that government agencies comply with court orders, especially those necessary to protect individual liberties. … For the public to have any faith in the orderly administration of justice, the Court’s narrowly crafted remedy cannot be so quickly and easily upended without further briefing and consideration.

The matrix of orders that Xinis now has in place should in theory protect Abrego Garcia from immediate detention and deportation — but so far the Trump administration has exhibited a sadistic willingness to do anything to torment him, including violating Xinis’ orders.

The Retribution: Letitia James Edition

Last Thursday, the Trump DOJ failed to re-indict New York Attorney General Letitia James on bogus mortgage fraud charges when a federal grand jury in Norfolk, Virginia returned a no-true bill. So yesterday, they brought the case to a new grand jury in Alexandria, Virginia — and got the same result. With each effort, the vindictive prosecution claim James has grows stronger.

Fake Pardon Alert

President Trump purported to pardon former Mesa County (Colorado) clerk Tina Peters, who is currently jailed for her state conviction for tampering with voting machines to try to prove the 2020 Big Lie. Peters has never been charged federally, and her state conviction is beyond the reach of a presidential pardon. I could pardon Peters on the state charges and have the same effect.

2026 Ephemera

MyPillow Founder Mike Lindell — a Big Lie devotee — launches a 2026 bid for governor of Minnesota.

Indiana Rebuffs Trump Redistricting Scheme

Enough GOP state senators in Indiana resisted White House entreaties to block the GOP-friendly mid-decade redistricting plan that would have added a couple of more House seats to the Republican column.

Great Read

Nobel peace laureate Maria Corina Machado greets supporters from the balcony of the Grand Hotel in Oslo, Norway, early on December 11, 2025. Machado arrived in Oslo hours after the Venezuelan opposition leader’s award was collected on her behalf by her daughter. (Photo by Odd ANDERSEN / AFP via Getty Images)

The WSJ has a riveting account of opposition leader María Corina Machado’s escape from Venezuela this week to receive the Nobel Peace Prize in Norway. At one point, she was lost and adrift at night in the Gulf of Venezuela before being found by an extraction team in a mission dubbed Operation Golden Dynamite. If you know, you know.

Hot tips? Juicy scuttlebutt? Keen insights? Let me know. For sensitive information, use the encrypted methods here.

The Undocumented Underground Is Fighting Back Inside New York’s Notorious Immigration Court

One day last month, a Peruvian mother and her daughter went into Manhattan. They were both dressed in their best. The girl, who could not have been more than 10 years old, had a pink backpack shaped like a cat and matching bows in her hair. It was an important day: they were due at the immigration court at 26 Federal Plaza for a hearing related to their effort to obtain lawful residency. 

But while these courthouses are theoretically the gateway to American justice and citizenship, in recent months they have played host to horrifying scenes where many of those who hope to experience the best of this nation are instead forcefully rounded up in the halls by federal agents. 

Since President Donald Trump retook the White House in January, he has sought to bring his vision for “mass deportation” to life by expanding the budget for the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency, instituting drastic removal quotas, expanding detention facilities with little concern for alleged human rights abuses, and staging dramatic raids with heavily armed officers from multiple federal agencies. In New York City, the masked footsoldiers of Trump’s deportation machine have set up shop in three immigration courts where they regularly detain people who show up for hearings and mandatory check-ins. 

When these agents pull immigrants from the halls of these Manhattan courthouses, they are also ripping them from their shot at citizenship. Often those who are being dragged away have further court dates and appeals. Traditional due process is being snatched from them. Even for those who are not taken, the daily spectacle has left them with a profound fear. Each person who comes to these courts knows they could be next.

Continue reading “The Undocumented Underground Is Fighting Back Inside New York’s Notorious Immigration Court”

Indiana Guv Vows to Help Trump Challenge His Own State’s GOPers Who Rejected Gerrymander

Just moments after 21 Republican members of Indiana’s state Senate voted with Democrats to reject President Trump’s aggressive attempt to force the state to draw a new congressional map, one that would have dramatically reduced Indiana Democrats’ chances of holding seats in the U.S. House next year, Gov. Mike Braun went on Twitter to demonstrate his support for … Trump.

Continue reading “Indiana Guv Vows to Help Trump Challenge His Own State’s GOPers Who Rejected Gerrymander”

Indiana Senate Republicans Defy Trump Admin and Reject Gerrymandered Maps

Despite months of mounting and concerted pressure from the Trump administration, the Indiana Senate rejected a proposal for a new gerrymandered congressional map ahead of the 2026 midterm elections. 

Continue reading “Indiana Senate Republicans Defy Trump Admin and Reject Gerrymandered Maps”

Both Dem and GOP Messaging Bills on Expiring ACA Subsidies Fail in Senate As Expected

The Senate voted on two competing health care plans to address the expiring Affordable Care Act (ACA) subsidies on Thursday. Both were largely messaging votes that gave both parties something to point to when constituents are hit with skyrocketing health care costs after the subsidies expire at the end of the year. 

Both failed to meet the 60 vote threshold on the Senate floor.

Continue reading “Both Dem and GOP Messaging Bills on Expiring ACA Subsidies Fail in Senate As Expected”