Fox’s Kilmeade Asks If He’s Watching ‘Univision’ While Talking Spanish Speaking Dems

“Fox and Friends” co-host Brian Kilmeade delivered one of his usual quips Thursday morning, when he questioned whether he was watching Univision while asking Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) about the effectiveness of Democrats’ use of Spanish during the debates on Wednesday evening.

Continue reading “Fox’s Kilmeade Asks If He’s Watching ‘Univision’ While Talking Spanish Speaking Dems” →

Beto ‘Sure Did’ Feel A Bit Targeted By Other Dems, But ‘That’s Part Of Politics’

Democratic presidential candidate Beto O’Rourke acknowledged that he was specifically targeted during the first round of Democratic debates, but laughed off the notion that it might hurt his standing.

Continue reading “Beto ‘Sure Did’ Feel A Bit Targeted By Other Dems, But ‘That’s Part Of Politics’” →

Castro Uses Morning TV Spot For Some Mild Gloating: ‘Clearly I Had A Great Night’

Former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro took some time to relish in his successful evening on the debate stage Thursday morning, stating bluntly to CNN: “Clearly I had a great night.”

Continue reading “Castro Uses Morning TV Spot For Some Mild Gloating: ‘Clearly I Had A Great Night’” →

Trump Posts Doctored Video Of Himself Walking On Stage During MSNBC Glitch

President Trump can’t stop reveling in MSNBC’s technical glitch during the first Democratic debate.

Continue reading “Trump Posts Doctored Video Of Himself Walking On Stage During MSNBC Glitch” →

PA GOP Chair Resigns After Trove Of Sexts With Local Candidate Uncovered

Pennsylvania GOP chairman Val DiGiorgio resigned his post Wednesday after a tranche of sexually explicit messages, including a picture of his genitals, exchanged with a former City Council candidate was reported by the Philadelphia Inquirer.

When You Use Campaign Funds To Pay For Your Pet Rabbit’s Trip, You’re Doing It Wrong

This article is part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis.

Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-CA 50th) is facing possible criminal liability for a colorful litany of alleged misdeeds, such as paying for five mistresses with campaign money. But among the more unique allegations leveled against Rep. Hunter includes using campaign funds to fly his pet rabbit Eggburt on a vacation. Why are these crimes? Because our nation’s campaign finance laws limit who can pay for what.

This is a lesson that even the President still needs to learn.

Here’s some campaign finance history: Many American campaign finance laws were inspired by political scandals. Perhaps most infamously, the money in politics shenanigans in President Nixon’s 1972 re-election campaign included using illegal campaign funds to finance an illegal burglary of the DNC’s headquarters in the Watergate building. Revelations about Watergate led to the enactment of the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA), which still governs campaigns. A long forgotten scandal about insurance companies secretly funding the Republican Party in 1904 led to the Tillman Act, which bans corporate contributions to campaigns. Fear of Nazis influencing American elections during World War II led to a ban on foreigners’ spending in U.S. elections.

In campaign finance law, it matters a great deal which way the money flows. In many instances, money flowing one way is perfectly legal. But reverse the direction, and you’ll have investigators in FBI flak jackets at your door asking questions about criminal violations.

(The laws I’ve run through here are all federal. But it’s worth remembering that each of the 50 states have their own campaign finance laws. Some states are more strict and others are more permissive.)

Back to Rep. Hunter and his jet-setting pet rabbit Eggburt. Money in federal campaigns is meant to be used for — drum roll please — federal campaigns. There are rules against using campaign funds for personal use. Just ask ex-Congressman Jesse Jackson Jr., who went to prison for using campaign funds to buy Michael Jackson memorabilia.

And remember, which way the money flows is important. While it would be perfectly legal for Rep. Duncan Hunter to give his campaign an unlimited amount of money pursuant to a Supreme Court case called Buckley v. Valeo, Rep. Hunter was not allowed to dip his hand into his campaign’s till and treat it like his personal piggy bank. Perhaps because of government’s allegations about Rep. Hunter’s five mistresses, Rep. Hunter’s wife Margaret Hunter just flipped, so watch this space to see whether federal prosecutors can convict him for his alleged illegal personal use of over $200,000 in campaign funds.

Many have heard of Citizens United v. FEC, which allows corporations to spend money on political ads. What’s less known is that corporations are still banned under the Tillman Act from giving money to federal candidates directly. But when it comes to corporations in politics, it (again) makes a big legal difference who is paying whom. For instance, the Trump Campaign is allowed to rent locations from the Trump Organization for rallies at fair market rates. But the Trump Organization’s corporate arms cannot give money or things of value to the Trump Campaign under the 1907 Tillman Act. Even though this statute is over a hundred years old, it is still good law. In fact, the Supreme Court just turned down the opportunity to strike the Tillman Act in a recent case in 2019.

And finally the direction of money flows is important when it comes to foreign spending in U.S. elections. The law bans American political campaigns from accepting or soliciting a thing of value or money from a foreign national. But the money can go the other way. This prohibition, for instance, does not stop an American campaign from hiring a foreign national, so long as the foreign national is not given decision-making control over a campaign or PAC.

Thus, there is a huge difference between a law firm paying ex-MI6 British subject Christopher Steele to do research into an American presidential candidate, which is permitted under U.S. law, and accepting money from a foreign national, which is not allowed. A campaign paying money to a foreign national is kosher. But any offers of things of value or money from a foreign national to an American political campaign are banned.

Trump should know the difference, since Trump’s 2016 campaign hired a British firm called Cambridge Analytica, which is fine (so long as the foreign nationals working there didn’t take over control of the campaign). Meanwhile, any offers of help from a foreign government to the same campaign could lead to a multiple-year federal investigation by a special prosecutor.

So to sum up: rich individuals can self-finance a political campaign to their heart’s content; federal candidates can pay corporations for campaign expenses like buying bunting; and Americans campaigns can hire foreign nationals to do limited tasks. But what is not allowed includes: (1) corporations’ dumping money into federal campaigns, (2) foreigners’ dumping money into any American political campaign, and (3) paying for a Congressman’s pet rabbit to fly with him on his campaign’s dime. Oh and bonus (4) paying for mistresses with campaign money is also a big no-no.

Word to the wise: If you want bunny Eggburt along for the ride, pay for it yourself out of pocket. The same goes for paramours.

 


Ciara Torres-Spelliscy is a Professor of Law at Stetson University College of Law, a Brennan Center Fellow and the author of the book “Political Brands.”

The Underdog Candidates Who Made Waves Wednesday Night

In the first half hour of Wednesday night’s Democratic presidential debate, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) seemed like the star of the show. But as the night wore on, a few of the lesser-known candidates earned themselves some standout moments.

Continue reading “The Underdog Candidates Who Made Waves Wednesday Night” →

With Call For Decriminalization, Castro Nudges Dem Field Left On Immigration

In the first debate of the 2020 election cycle, the Democratic presidential candidates on stage were united in their anger over the Trump administration’s immigration policy. But there were also distinct differences among the candidates over how they would change immigration policy if elected.

Continue reading “With Call For Decriminalization, Castro Nudges Dem Field Left On Immigration” →

The Biggest Takeaways From The First Democratic Debate

The first night of the Democratic debates has concluded, giving viewers their first chance to see many of the candidates sharing a stage and exchanging ideas. Here are the biggest takeaways from night one:

Continue reading “The Biggest Takeaways From The First Democratic Debate” →