Selling A Swastika Product Turns Out To Be A Branding Problem For Sears

Screen grab of the listing for the swastika ring that was for sale on Sears' website.
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

The people who run the Twitter account for Sears department stores spent most of the past 24 hours trying to explain why one of the company’s websites had been selling rings emblazoned with a swastika.

The stream of tweets mostly included a boilerplate explanation blaming it on a “3rd party merchant,” but occasionally it branched out into the surreal, including an appeal for someone going by the name “unicorn” to renew his or her faith in the Sears brand.

Before the product was removed, Jewish parenting site Kveller was able to get a screenshot of the listing (shown above), which was classified as part of the retailer’s “men’s punk rock style” jewelry collection.

The ring was described as a “gothic jewelry item” made of “.925 Thai silver.” Of the swastika emblazoned on it, the description noted that it was “not for Neo Nazi or any Nazi implication. These jewelry items are going to make you look beautiful at your next dinner date.”

Here’s a sampling from the Sears Twitter stream, but the whole thing is worth a look:

By late Tuesday morning, the company issued a longer statement on its website, including an apology, and began referring people on Twitter to it.

“Like many who have connected with our company, we are outraged that more than one of our independent third-party sellers posted offensive items on Sears Marketplace,” the statement said. “We sincerely apologize that these items were posted to our site and want you to know that the ring was not posted by Sears, but by independent third-party vendors.”

The ring was also being sold on Amazon.com, according to Haaretz, but was listed as unavailable.

Latest Livewire
50
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. “It wasn’t our fault! It was that damned 3rd party marketplace thingie what screwed us!”

    FAIL.

  2. But but but…“free market!!!”

  3. Not surprising if you’ve ever seen Sears’ website. You look for, say, vacuum cleaner bags, or parts for a washer and you’re inundated with tangentially related items, most of which are from third party sellers.

    The Rand-loving Sears boss wants to make all kinds of money for Sears by any means except by you know, selling their own stuff.

    It’s so frustrating that I don’t even use it anymore.

  4. I hope Sears also pulls down its Kraftsmen line of swastika power tools.

  5. I never know how to interpret independent sellers with swastika decorations.

    • Are they genuine Neo-Nazis? Generally not, but it’s something you can’t dismiss out of hand.
    • Are they not from the West, and thus the other, positive associations for the Swastika in Hinduism, Buddhism and associated religions take primacy?
    • Are they someone New Agey who just doesn’t care?

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

44 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for pluckyinky Avatar for jw1 Avatar for charliee Avatar for foundryman Avatar for docmoore Avatar for teenlaqueefa Avatar for callmeeric Avatar for sniffit Avatar for yskov Avatar for weatherservo9 Avatar for slappymagoo Avatar for midnight_rambler Avatar for theghostofeustacetilley Avatar for astralfire Avatar for okicu Avatar for 538liberal Avatar for tao Avatar for xenophonii Avatar for mrf Avatar for khaaannn Avatar for darrtown Avatar for silverspringer Avatar for emilianoelmexicano

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: