UK Parliament Rejects Four Alternatives To Theresa May’s Ailing Brexit Deal

Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May leaves after speaking during a press conference on December 14, 2018 in Brussels on the second day of a European Summit aimed at discussing the Brexit deal, the long-term budget a... Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May leaves after speaking during a press conference on December 14, 2018 in Brussels on the second day of a European Summit aimed at discussing the Brexit deal, the long-term budget and the single market. - May says further Brexit talks will take place with EU in coming days, AFP reported on December 14. (Photo by JOHN THYS / AFP) (Photo credit should read JOHN THYS/AFP/Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

LONDON (AP) — Britain’s Parliament has spoken — and it has said no, again.

Lawmakers seeking a way out of the country’s Brexit morass on Monday rejected four alternatives to the government’s unpopular European Union divorce deal that would have softened or even halted Britain’s departure.

With just 12 days until the U.K. must come up with a new plan or crash out of the bloc in chaos, the House of Commons threw out four alternatives to Prime Minister Theresa May’s thrice-rejected Brexit deal — though in some cases by a whisker.

The result leaves the government with a range of unpalatable choices. It can gamble on a fourth attempt to push May’s unloved deal through Parliament, let Britain tumble out of the bloc without a deal, or roll the dice by opting for a snap election to shake up Parliament.

Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay said the government would continue to seek support for a “credible” plan for leaving the EU.

“This house has continuously rejected leaving without a deal just as it has rejected not leaving at all,” he said. “Therefore the only option is to find a way through which allows the U.K. to leave with a deal.”

May has summoned her Cabinet for a marathon meeting Tuesday to thrash out the options. The prime minister, who is renowned for her dogged determination, could try to bring her Brexit agreement back for a fourth time later this week.

The narrowest defeat — 276 votes to 273 — was for a plan to keep Britain in a customs union with the EU, guaranteeing smooth and tariff-free trade in goods. A motion that went further, calling for Britain to stay in the EU’s borderless single market for both goods and services, was defeated 282-261.

A third proposal calling for any Brexit deal Britain strikes with the EU to be put to a public referendum was defeated 292-280.

The fourth, which would let Britain cancel Brexit if it came within two days of crashing out of the bloc without a deal, fell by a wider margin, 292-191.

May had already ruled out all the ideas under consideration. But the divorce deal she negotiated with the EU has been rejected by Parliament three times, leaving Britain facing a no-deal Brexit that could cause turmoil for people and businesses on both sides of the Channel.

Defense Minister Tobias Ellwood urged fellow Conservative lawmakers to compromise to ensure an orderly Brexit.

“When you put your deal through three times and colleagues and others have not supported it, but you still want to honor the referendum result itself, you still want to get out of Europe, then something small has to give,” he said.

The April 12 deadline, imposed by the EU, gives May less than two weeks to bridge the hostile divide that separates those in her government who want to sever links with the EU and those who want to keep the ties that have bound Britain to the bloc for almost 50 years.

The impasse is raising expectations that lawmakers could try to trigger a snap election in the hope a new configuration in Parliament would break the Brexit logjam. But the Conservatives are worried that could hand power to the opposition Labour Party.

The range of choices, and lack of consensus, reflect a Parliament and a government deeply divided over how — and whether — to leave the EU.

Justice Secretary David Gauke said leaving the bloc without a deal was “not the responsible thing for a government to do.”

But Chief Secretary to the Treasury Liz Truss said it would be better than a soft Brexit.

“I don’t have any fear of no-deal,” she said.

The Brexit impasse has alarmed businesses, who say the uncertainty has deterred investment and undermined economic growth.

The chief executive of industrial manufacturer Siemens U.K. implored lawmakers to unite around a compromise deal, saying “Brexit is exhausting our business and wrecking the country’s tremendous reputation as an economic powerhouse.”

Juergen Maier urged lawmakers to keep Britain in a customs union with the EU, saying that would allow frictionless trade to continue. In a letter published by the Politico website, Maier said “where the U.K. used to be beacon for stability, we are now becoming a laughing stock.”

EU leaders have called a special summit on April 10 to consider any request from Britain for a delay to Brexit — or to make last-minute preparations for Britain’s departure without a deal two days later.

European Commission chief Jean-Claude Juncker said it was time for the British Parliament to spell out what it wanted on Brexit.

“A sphinx is an open book in direct comparison with the British Parliament,” he told the Saarland state legislature in Saarbruecken, Germany. “We must get the sphinx to talk now. Enough of the long silence.”

Latest World News

Notable Replies

  1. Keep wishing for a pony in one hand and Brexiting in the other. See which one fills up first.

  2. One of my favorite lines from The West Wing is when Leo McGary tells the ambassador to Great Britain, who was frustrating the hell out of him with elitist humor, “Yea, but we opened up a can of whoop ass on you at Yorktown.” Now, I love Great Britain, and I want them to save themselves…so FFS have a re-vote!

    Speaking of The West Wing…of which I was a huge fan…

    Here are some fond memories: Martin Sheen for Prez also too… :smiley:
  3. What a group of fuck-ups.

  4. The option that makes the most sense, dropping out of Brexit, is the one that got the least support. The British Parliament is as screwed up as the House of Representatives when the Repugs were in control. The US is going to suffer for some time because of the morons who elected Trump but Britain’s morons are going to inflict more severe suffering on their country with Brexit. It is going to make interesting reading for decades and centuries from now – how the two main English speaking countries in the world adopted disastrous policies and elected morons for no apparent reasons other than fear, stupidity, racism, and misogyny.

  5. Avatar for outis outis says:

    Just call a new public referendum, with people now having some idea what it is all about. They can vote again to leave, but they cannot vote for the EU to give them a plum deal in the bargain.

Continue the discussion at

36 more replies


Avatar for system1 Avatar for valgalky23 Avatar for webcelt Avatar for ajm Avatar for secular_humanist Avatar for playitagainrowlf Avatar for daveminnj Avatar for old_curmudgeon Avatar for ncsteve Avatar for eggrollian Avatar for cervantes Avatar for george_spiggott Avatar for sniffit Avatar for addicted4444 Avatar for castor_troy Avatar for khyber900 Avatar for brian512 Avatar for maximus Avatar for erik_t Avatar for demosthenes59 Avatar for christiandemocrat Avatar for greenman66 Avatar for outis Avatar for dicktater

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: