Bizarro Version Of McCarthy Speakership Fight Plays Out In Ohio 

As the aftershocks of the fierce speakership battle roil the chamber, Republicans’ anger turns inward, the opposing camps fighting each other. Unified Democrats, stuck in the minority, stand back and watch the spectacle. 

Continue reading “Bizarro Version Of McCarthy Speakership Fight Plays Out In Ohio “

Certainly Illinois Can Do Better Than Dick Durbin

I’ve been hearing from people in and out of the political world saying things like this: folks like Dick Durbin really need to retire. Yes, I’m talking about his Sunday show appearance yesterday and his commenting on the Biden classified documents. What I’m describing here isn’t only about Dick Durbin. But he is one of the prime offenders.

What is Dick Durbin doing in the Senate exactly? What I’ve seen from him, know of him mostly for years is appearances like that on the Sunday shows, ones which play to the D.C. press and establishment opinion. It’s of a piece with Durbin’s position or really non-position on “Roe and Reform.” Durbin was one of the prime holdouts. Well, he wasn’t even a holdout really — he simply wouldn’t discuss it at all. The best he could manage in mid-2022 were some vague comments about not being over-hasty about things.

Continue reading “Certainly Illinois Can Do Better Than Dick Durbin”

Promoters of Election Lies Also Hyped a Hospital for Ukraine. That Never Happened Either.

This article first appeared at ProPublica and The Dallas Morning News.

Gregg Phillips and Catherine Engelbrecht are best known as the election deniers behind True the Vote, a Texas-based nonprofit responsible for amplifying conspiracies that the 2020 presidential election was stolen.

But soon after Russia invaded Ukraine in early 2022, they shifted some of their focus to the war effort, jumping into the fray with an inspiring idea — to bring a mobile hospital to the region to care for victims of the conflict.

They called it The Freedom Hospital.

Phillips solicited donations on conservative media platforms, linked up with American veterans working in Ukraine and traveled to the region in March to meet with local officials. The Freedom Hospital’s website announced it was halfway to its goal of raising $25 million.

“Our recent project, The Freedom Hospital, in Ukraine helps old folks, women and kids near the fight receive healthcare,” Phillips wrote on the conservative social media site Truth Social on June 5.

But that was one of a series of misrepresentations from Phillips and The Freedom Hospital about the operation’s donations and accomplishments, according to a joint investigation by ProPublica and The Dallas Morning News. The Freedom Hospital never got off the ground, and, through their lawyers, Phillips and Engelbrecht now say they never raised significant amounts of money for the project.

They never brought the mobile hospital to the region.

Both Phillips and Engelbrecht declined to answer questions. According to their lawyers, who spoke to ProPublica and the News, the pair’s Ukraine project was a good-faith effort that was unsuccessful.

They said Phillips realized during his March trip to the region that the mission wasn’t feasible because local officials weren’t interested, because potential donors felt the U.S. government was already funneling enough money into the war effort, and because he was worried about the potential for local corruption.

“They pretty much abandoned it all as of, like, April,” Cameron Powell, a partner at Gregor, Wynne, Arney who’s one of the pair’s attorneys, said during a December interview. “Pretty much during his trip, he was deciding it’s probably not going to be feasible.”

Phillips continued to seek donations for months after that and gave the impression that the project was still in the works. The lawyers now say that is because the pair kept pushing forward “with their due diligence for a while longer” and declined to clarify exactly when the project was abandoned.

Asked about Phillips’ statements that The Freedom Hospital had raised half of its $25 million goal, the lawyers said that amount was an in-kind donation from the mobile hospital manufacturer, not cash. The manufacturer’s CEO disputed that account, saying it never pledged to make such a donation.

The Freedom Hospital’s Twitter account shared a quote from True the Vote’s Gregg Phillips on April 21, 2022. Credit: Screenshot by ProPublica and The Dallas Morning News

Created by Engelbrecht in 2010, True the Vote vaulted to national prominence after its work was featured in the 2022 Dinesh D’Souza movie “2000 Mules,” a film that included voter fraud claims that have been widely discredited.

The Ukraine venture is the latest in a string of failed initiatives and misleading statements from Engelbrecht and Phillips. Phillips has been a longtime True the Vote board member, and he and Engelbrecht have raised millions on the promise that they would reveal widespread voter fraud. But they have never supplied any evidence the election was stolen, leaving a trail of disappointed donors and frustrated partners, even as the false election-theft narrative has continued to be a potent force in American politics.

An “Awe-Inspiring” Mission

A former health and human services official for the states of Texas and Mississippi, Phillips was eager to use his expertise to aid the people of Ukraine when Russia invaded, his lawyers said.

The Freedom Hospital’s website, which is now defunct, described the project as “awe-inspiring.” A group of Americans had “banded together” to bring to the region “a state-of-the-art mobile emergency hospital system that can skirt battle zones to treat the wounded,” according to the site’s archive. “Every penny of your donation will be used to save lives,” the website stated, with a link to a PayPal donation site.

In March 2022, Phillips traveled to the region and discussed the project with several local governmental and religious officials.

The next month, he explained the ongoing effort to a podcaster. Phillips said his team was “ensuring that we could clear supply paths and ensure that the hospitals could remain sort of fully supplied and fully staffed” and that they had secured a warehouse.

The hospital’s Twitter account described the facility as a 100,000-square-foot warehouse donated by an unnamed family behind “Europe’s biggest transport company.”

The lawyers now say an unnamed citizens’ group offered use of an empty auditorium that was not ultimately needed.

A March 20, 2022, Facebook post from Artur Muntyan, a local official in Chernivtsi, Ukraine, shows him with other local government and religious officials as well as Gregg Phillips, who appears in the top left photo on the left side of the back row, and in the bottom middle photo on the right. Credit: Screenshot by ProPublica and The Dallas Morning News

Over the course of the spring, Phillips continued to promote the humanitarian effort, seeking donations and other support. On Twitter, he called it “history in the making.” In early June, he repeatedly discussed the project on Truth Social and said it was responsible for extracting “dozens” of elderly refugees from the region.

“My work and my calling is to create a private healthcare and extraction ecosystem for old folks, women and children,” he wrote in a post on June 5. “The Freedom Hospital is my commitment to God come to life.”

In the December interview, Powell, one of the pair’s lawyers, said Phillips finished the project’s feasibility study by the time he returned from Ukraine, at which time he told donors he couldn’t ask them to fund the project.

But this week, after being sent questions ahead of publication of this article, Powell was vaguer about the project’s timeline. When asked why Phillips continued promoting the hospital into June, he acknowledged his clients began to “harbor doubts” about the project months before without specifying when it was officially shuttered.

“The group came to the realization sometime after Gregg returned that the project was ‘probably’ not feasible, but it would be unrealistic to expect that realization occurred during a single, identifiable moment in time. There was no epiphany,” Powell said.

The project’s Twitter account still exists but has not tweeted since May 5.

Gregg Phillips continued to post about The Freedom Hospital on Truth Social through early June. Credit: Screenshot by ProPublica and The Dallas Morning New

True the Vote was listed as The Freedom Hospital’s fiscal sponsor on the project’s website and Engelbrecht successfully applied for nonprofit status for the hospital from the IRS in March.

Phillips and Englebrecht planned to get a medical unit from MED-1 Partners, a mobile hospital manufacturing company based in North Carolina. Phillips’ lawyers said he worked with sales representatives and was told the unit would come at “a substantial reduction in price, which MED-1 spoke of as an in-kind donation to help the effort.”

MED-1 Partners CEO Tim Masud told ProPublica and the News this account is not true.

MED-1 Partners was selling an older demo unit for a reduced price, the same price that would be offered to anyone interested in purchasing it, he said. Masud added neither he nor his authorized liaison on the deal described this reduced price as a donation or pledged to provide a donation to The Freedom Hospital.

In March, Masud said the company drafted a letter of intent for a project called “The Freedom Children’s Hospital” that required a $150,000 deposit. But it was never signed and no money changed hands.

“All we did was offer a hospital for sale to a group of people. That’s it,” Masud said.

Powell said his clients raised only $268 for the project through PayPal, which the lawyers said was returned “at Mr. Phillips’ direction.” Another of the group’s attorneys, Michael Wynne, said in a December phone call that the project had raised no other funds through other means.

The Freedom Hospital’s website, which is now defunct, called for donations and said it was halfway to raising $25 million. Credit: Screenshot of the Wayback Machine by ProPublica and The Dallas Morning News

On April 21, The Freedom Hospital posted a video on its YouTube account with a caption saying that its “team” was “reporting” from Ukraine. But The Freedom Hospital had no role in producing the video.

Christopher Loverro, a Los Angeles-based actor and veteran, made the video, which he said was shot in front of a recently bombed Ukrainian preschool.

In an interview, Loverro said he has never had any connection to The Freedom Hospital and had not given anyone permission to use his work. After being contacted by ProPublica and the News, Loverro said he reported the video to YouTube and commented on the post, warning: “This is a scam. Do not donate to this organization.”

After ProPublica and the News sent the lawyers questions about the video, Loverro said a woman named Catherine, who was associated with the project, contacted him for the first time to discuss The Freedom Hospital. Following that conversation, he said he had no reason to doubt the woman, who told him the project was a legitimate humanitarian effort with “no fraud involved” that simply came to naught.

Phillips’ lawyers said he did not post the video and does not have access to The Freedom Hospital’s YouTube account to remove it. It was likely posted by one of “several volunteers working on the Freedom Hospital project at that time,” they added.

The video and a donation request still remain up on the project’s YouTube channel.

The Freedom Hospital’s YouTube channel has posted one video. An actor and veteran said he produced the video and did not give the project permission to use it. Credit: Screenshot by ProPublica and The Dallas Morning News

Complaints

The Freedom Hospital project and other efforts troubled one of True the Vote’s contractors enough that he submitted a complaint in June referencing the hospital and a number of other concerns to the Texas attorney general’s criminal investigation division.

“After a series of bizarre calls and communications over several months, Gregg told us he’d raised the money for [The Freedom Hospital]. Several times he told us it was $2.5 million. He also gave us the figures of $10 million. He also marketed that they needed $25 million,” Kyle Reyes, whose company had worked on marketing initiatives for True the Vote, wrote.

ProPublica and the News obtained the complaint through a public records request.

In the document, Reyes accused True the Vote of a wide range of questionable business practices and said the organization had not paid his marketing firm for the services it performed.

Wynne said the complaint is “demonstrably false.” It’s unclear what the status of Reyes’ complaint is; the Texas attorney general’s office did not respond to a request for comment.

The questions about The Freedom Hospital come as Engelbrecht and Phillips are facing new scrutiny over continued failed efforts to prove widespread fraud in the American election system.

The pair have frequently profited handsomely from their election denial work, according to an investigation by Reveal that found loans issued to Engelbrecht and self-dealing contracts to nonprofit insiders. (Their attorney at the time said that there was nothing inherently wrong about the contracts.) The outgoing attorney general of Arizona, once an ally, now wants the group investigated for potential “financial improprieties” related to this work. In November, the pair spent a week in jail on contempt of court charges for failing to disclose a source behind their election fraud claims.

Reyes told ProPublica and the News that he terminated his firm’s contract with True the Vote in June. After Reyes filed his complaint, he said, True the Vote paid his company the outstanding invoices about $25,000.

“As conservatives, we need to hold our fellow brothers and sisters to the same standard that we hold everyone in America to — no matter what side of the political aisle you’re on,” he said.

Weak-Kneed Hill Dems Fold In Face Of GOP Onslaught Over Biden Docs

A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM’s Morning Memo.

With Friends Like These …

You can be annoyed with Joe Biden over his mishandling of classified documents.

You can be chagrined that there’d have been no special counsel appointed were it not for Donald Trump’s classified document debacle.

You can be resigned to bad faith Republicans using it as a cudgel against Biden for the next two years while letting Trump skate.

But if you’re a prominent Democrat going on national TV, you need a plan, a strategy, a clear point that you’re ready to make. Alas … Democratic TV appearances over the weekend spawned headlines like this:

Bloomberg: Even Democrats Are Now Critical of Biden Over Documents Fiasco

Politico: Democrats ding Biden on documents even as they push back against GOP

For some pushback on the weak-kneed Dem line, see Josh Marshall.

Manchin Looks Wobbly On Debt Ceiling

The West Virginia senator declared it a “mistake” for President Biden not to negotiate with House Republicans over the debt ceiling – while Republicans howl over Biden’s refusal to negotiate under terroristic threat.

Mostly Quiet On The Jack Smith Front

With not much news coming out of Special Counsel Jack Smith’s probes, the WaPo profiles his work on Kosovo war crimes.

Proud Boys Are Still At It

  • Salt Lake City: A man identifying as a the founder of the local Proud Boy chapter was reportedly armed with a semi-automatic rifle and a 9mm handgun during a protest at an all-ages drag show Friday night.
  • San Diego: A YMCA closed Saturday in anticipation of protests over it allowing transgender residents access to locker rooms. “Around a half-dozen men wore hats and shirts representing the Proud Boys” during the protest, the local newspaper reported.  

Proud Boys Seditious Conspiracy Trial Resumes

The trial of the Proud Boys members, including leader Enrique Tarrio, continues today in Washington, D.C.

Oath Keepers Jury Still Deliberating

The jury has the case in the lower profile of the two back-to-back trials of Oath Keepers on seditious conspiracy charges.

More On Those Marines Arrested For Jan. 6

A bit more clarity on the intel roles held by the three Marines charged with Jan. 6 crimes:

  • Sgt. Joshua Abate: special communications signals analyst
  • Sgt. Dodge Dale Hellonen: special communications signals analyst
  • Cpl. Micah Coomer: intelligence surveillance reconnaissance system engineer

How they were caught is revealing:

The FBI said Abate admitted to entering the Capitol “with two ‘buddies’” during a June 2022 interview that was part of his security clearance process while assigned to the Marine Corps’ Cryptologic Support Battalion, which is partnered and headquartered with the NSA at Fort Meade. 

For his part, Coomer posted to Instagram photos from inside the Capitol on Jan. 6:

According to charging papers filed Tuesday and unsealed Thursday, Coomer posted photographs on Instagram taken from inside the Capitol during the breach, captioned “Glad to be apart of history.” Data provided by Facebook in connection with an August 2021 federal search warrant showed that in a Jan. 31 direct message on Instagram, Coomer allegedly “stated his belief ‘that everything in this country is corrupt. We honestly need a fresh restart. I’m waiting for the boogaloo.’”

The Big Lie Just Baked In Now

Politico: “The new Alabama secretary of state’s first move in office showed how ideas stemming from the stolen election myth are affecting government.”

Sanctions Get Trump’s Attention

One day after being sanctioned by a federal judge in Florida to the tune of nearly $1 million, former President Trump dismissed his dubious lawsuit against New York Attorney General Tish James that was pending before the same judge.

Klain Out, Zients In

Ron Klain gets a chance to do what relatively few White House chiefs of staff have been able to pull off: leave on his own timetable.

Jeff Zients, who lead the Biden administration’s COVID response, has very little political experience. “His selection suggests that the president could lean on Mr. Zients to help run the government while other advisers focus on the politics of winning a second term,” the NYT notes.

Confirmed

The Supreme Court justices were not subject to the same scrutiny as their clerks and court staff in the Dobbs draft leak probe.

Jeffries Not Backing Away From Looming Confrontation With McCarthy

The Democratic minority leader is pushing ahead with plans to name California Reps. Adam Schiff and Eric Swalwell to the intel committee and Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) to the Foreign Affairs Committee despite the speaker’s vow to strip the three Democratic reps of those committee assignments, Punchbowl reports.

Looking Ahead

Monday-Tuesday: Congress returns.

Tuesday: A judge in Georgia hears arguments on whether the final report of the special grand jury empaneled by District Attorney Fani Willis should be released to the public.

Test Case

Is there room for someone like Mitch Daniels in the current GOP?

Scoop Of The Day

NYT: Russian Agents Suspected of Directing Far-Right Group to Mail Bombs in Spain

To Laugh Or Cry?

Do you like Morning Memo? Let us know!

The Debt Limit is Unconstitutional

Along with a categorical refusal to negotiate on raising the debt ceiling, Democrats need to start now making the affirmative case that the debt ceiling is itself unconstitutional. Back in 2011 President Obama said he had spoken to legal scholars and concluded this was not “a winning argument.”

This again is an example of Democrats playing to the elite legal academy, credentialed opinion.

Continue reading “The Debt Limit is Unconstitutional”

Durbin Troubles

The other issue with Durbin, and the far more important one, is the debt limit. He said the right things this morning in the same interview: no negotiation on the debt limit, period. But that’s now. Durbin is the deputy leader in the Senate. All the gravitational pull to seek press and elite D.C. approbation will be put to the test in coming months over the debt ceiling. Durbin’s a very weak reed to rely on.

Durbin An Embarrassment

Like more than a few Democrats, Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL) embarrassed himself this morning on the Biden documents case. He said President Biden is “diminished” by the situation. On Trump and Biden: “At its heart, the issue is the same. Those documents should not have been in the personal possession of either Joe Biden or Donald Trump,” he said. In each case, after whacking Biden around a bit, he went on to lamely distinguish between the two situations. Those distinctions, needless to say, will never be the headlines, never garner attention, never be what shapes news coverage. Manchin of course was worse, saying Biden “should have a lot of regrets” and questioning whether we know whether Biden’s or Trump’s actions are more egregious.

Continue reading “Durbin An Embarrassment”

Klain to Depart as Chief of Staff

Ron Klain, White House Chief of Staff, will reportedly announce he’s departing the position shortly. I have no inside knowledge of what’s behind this. I suspect it’s mostly the reality that there’s a short half life to the position itself. Indeed, rattling around my head for 20 years is a Klain anecdote in which he told his staff, when departing as Al Gore’s Chief of Staff in 1999, that the position is ”like a milk carton, and milk cartons have an expiration date.” I doubt it is about any substantive disagreements about anything

The only thing I can think to add about the transition is that this period is a major transition regardless. The next two years will be very, very different from the last two. There aren’t going to be any big legislative initiatives — no trying to get House progressives somehow on board with whatever new demand comes from Manchin and Sinema. That’s done. It will be about two things: First, seeing whether the House Freedom Caucus breaks the Republic or whether they are in turn broken by President Biden. Second, laying the groundwork for the 2024 election in which everything will be on the line. The outcome of the first largely determines the possibilities for the second.

Given this shift it wouldn’t surprise me if we saw a few more personnel changes. It’s just a very different brief.

Websites Selling Abortion Pills Are Sharing Sensitive Data With Google

This article was originally published at ProPublica, a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative newsroom.

Online pharmacies that sell abortion pills are sharing sensitive data with Google and other third parties, which may allow law enforcement to prosecute those who use the medications to end their pregnancies, a ProPublica analysis has found.

Continue reading “Websites Selling Abortion Pills Are Sharing Sensitive Data With Google”

Supreme Court Marshal Spoke With Justices During Dobbs Leak Probe, Did Not Make Them Sign Sworn Affidavits

The Supreme Court Marshal said Friday that she did speak with the justices during her investigation into the source of the Dobbs leak, but that she did not ask them to sign sworn affidavits. 

Continue reading “Supreme Court Marshal Spoke With Justices During Dobbs Leak Probe, Did Not Make Them Sign Sworn Affidavits”