Why Did So Many People Hate Henry Kissinger So Much?

Henry Kissinger’s death yesterday at the grand, round age of 100 was greeted with a broad chorus of “It’s about times” and “good riddances” and “go straight to hells.” I have always been fascinated by the intensity of the animus toward the man. And to be clear: that’s not because I necessarily disagree with the verdict.

In the quickest possible summary, during his roughly eight years as first National Security Advisor and then Secretary of State, Kissinger spearheaded or oversaw two broad policies which account for most, but by no means all, of what that vituperation is about.

Continue reading “Why Did So Many People Hate Henry Kissinger So Much?”

How Scott Perry Went Off The Deep End In Effort To Debunk Trump Loss

It was just after 8 p.m. ET on Jan. 6, 2021. Law enforcement had just finished clearing the Capitol building, and Congress was beginning to reconvene to finish the task which Stop the Steal supporters had violently disrupted: formalizing Biden’s win, and Trump’s defeat, in the 2020 election.

Continue reading “How Scott Perry Went Off The Deep End In Effort To Debunk Trump Loss”

Senate Republicans Use Procedural Stunts To Try To Block Subpoenas Of Leo And Crow

Senate Judiciary Republicans on Thursday invoked a rarely used rule to try to run down the clock and prevent committee Democrats from voting to authorize subpoenas for right-wing power players Leonard Leo and Harlan Crow.

Continue reading “Senate Republicans Use Procedural Stunts To Try To Block Subpoenas Of Leo And Crow”

A Tortured And Deadly Legacy: Kissinger And Realpolitik In US Foreign Policy

This article is part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis. It was originally published at The Conversation.

Henry Kissinger, who died on Nov. 29, 2023, at age 100, exercised more than 50 years of influence on American foreign policy.

I am a scholar of American foreign policy who has written on Kissinger’s service from 1969 to 1977 as national security adviser and secretary of state under the Nixon and Ford administrations. I have seen how his foreign policy views and actions played out for good and, mostly, for ill.

When Kissinger entered government as Richard Nixon’s national security adviser, he espoused a narrow perspective of the national interest, known as “realpolitik,” primarily centered on maximizing the economic and military power of the United States.

Continue reading “A Tortured And Deadly Legacy: Kissinger And Realpolitik In US Foreign Policy”

George Santos On Brink Of Demotion Back To Baruch Volleyball Team

As the sun broke over the House office buildings Thursday, it enveloped George Santos — and the roughly 50 reporters and photographers, shivering in the 30-degree morning — in a heavenly glow. 

Continue reading “George Santos On Brink Of Demotion Back To Baruch Volleyball Team”

Trump Lawyer Warned Him That Defying MAL Subpoena Would Be A Crime

A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM’s Morning Memo. Sign up for the email version.

Damning New Evidence

Jennifer Little, a former Trump attorney, has told Special Counsel Jack Smith that she warned Trump that if he did not comply with a federal grand jury subpoena for all classified documents at Mar-a-Lago it would be a crime, according to new reporting from ABC News.

Sources said the lawyer, Jennifer Little, told investigators Trump “absolutely” understood the warning, which came during a pivotal meeting at Mar-a-Lago with Trump and another attorney, Evan Corcoran, who had recently joined Trump’s legal team.

The subpoena came after months of demands from the National Archives for Trump to return government documents that he took with him from the White House to Mar-a-Lago. Little says she was trying to impress upon Trump that a grand jury subpoena was different and more serious. “You’ve got to comply,” she allegedly warned Trump.

Again, these are the purported words of Trump’s own lawyer. Little and Trump attorney Evan Corcoran were forced to testify to the grand jury after U.S. District Judge Beryl A. Howell ruled that attorney-client privilege did not apply because their legal advice was used in furtherance of a crime.

Big Ooops

It looks like the DC Circuit Court of Appeals inadvertently unsealed a filing that it should not have. It came in the case of Rep. Scott Perry’s phone, which was seized by the FBI back in August 2022. Months of litigation ensued over whether Perry, a Pennsylvania Republican, was protected by the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause, and Perry won a partial though significant victory when he appealed the case. Those records had been under seal but they were briefly unsealed Wednesday afternoon, only to be resealed and blocked from public view later in the evening.

Politico’s Kyle Cheney has a good rundown on what the inadvertently unsealed documents show about Perry’s communications between Election Day 2022 and Jan. 6, 2021.

Arizona Prosecutes Election Deniers

Two county supervisors in Cochise County, Arizona, have been criminally charged by the state attorney general for refusing to certify 2022 election results.

Dunk-a-thon

The Henry Kissinger remembrances:

Spencer Ackerman: Henry Kissinger, War Criminal Beloved by America’s Ruling Class, Finally Dies

David Corn: Dead at 100, Henry Kissinger Leaves Behind a Bloody Legacy

Speaking Of Diplomats …

The headline really does say it all: “Tucker Carlson, Trump’s shadow diplomat”

India’s Alleged Assassination Plot In U.S. Is BONKERS

I can’t speak to the broader geopolitical implications, but in spy thriller terms the alleged Indian plot to assassinate a Sikh separatist in New York is heady – and comical – stuff.

It’s probably easiest to explain by separating what was real from what was law enforcement subterfuge, as alleged in the new federal indictment:

REAL:

Nikhil Gupta, the defendant charged with acting as an intermediary between Indian intelligence and would-be assassins

Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, the victim, who is not named in the indictment but matches the description as a vocal Sikh critic of India based in New York

Unnamed Indian government officer who has claimed to work in intelligence and recruited Gupta in the plot to assassinate Pannun

SUBTERFUGE:

The confidential source, an unnamed “criminal associate” who Gupta contacted for help in hiring a hitman but who turned out to be a U.S. government informant

The hitman, who turned out to be an undercover U.S. law enforcement officer

As you can see, this started as an assassination plot and ended up as a sting. And, man, do they have the receipts: communications, photos and video as it all played out, with Gupta fooled into thinking he was dealing with real bad actors.

As funny as that is, the stakes were real. As this sting was unfolding, the alleged Indian assassination plot on Canadian soil took place and was even referenced in the communications between Gupta and his Indian handler.

Point/Counterpoint

John Ganz: Israel Has Already Lost

Josh Marshall: Decision Time

Kevin McCarthy Got Tough With Trump … Really?

In two separate private conversations being reported on by the WaPo, Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) claims to have said “Fuck you” to Donald Trump after his ouster as speaker last month. McCarthy’s office now denies that he swore.

Short Honeymoon For Speaker Johnson?

Politico: “Johnson has antagonized conservatives most acutely by engaging in policy talks with fellow leaders, rather than pushing exclusively for base-pleasing wins that won’t survive in the Senate. That traditional approach won’t hurt Johnson with most of the House GOP — but as McCarthy’s ouster made clear, it only takes a handful of fed-up members to make a speaker’s life difficult.”

SCOTUS Flexes Its Anti-Regulatory Cred

TPM’s Kate Riga on oral arguments yesterday in a case the high court may use to chip away at the administrative state.

The Man Is Not Well

A revealing, disturbing, and inexplicable public outburst by Elon Musk:

Do you like Morning Memo? Let us know!

McCarthy Undecided On Whether To Continue Humiliation

Before leaving town for the holiday, former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) told CNN he was going to spend some of the break talking to his family about whether he should continue on with his career in the House. A month and a half removed from the spotlight and all the right flank-induced humiliation that came with it, McCarthy lamented he missed having a seat “at the table” and said he was “going to look at all options” politically for himself.

“I got the holidays. I will talk to my family about the ideas of what is going forward, and then I will make a decision,” he told CNN.

Continue reading “McCarthy Undecided On Whether To Continue Humiliation”

Right-Wing Justices Train Their Anti-Agency Ire On Big Bad Financial Regulator

The right-wing Supreme Court justices occasionally tipped into outright hostility Wednesday as they pressed a government lawyer with questions and hypotheticals about stripping the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) of some of its enforcement discretion. 

Continue reading “Right-Wing Justices Train Their Anti-Agency Ire On Big Bad Financial Regulator”

Decision Time

I wanted to flag to your attention this post by John Ganz, someone who, if you’re not familiar with him, is well worth becoming familiar with. Ganz and I see the questions about Israel, the Palestinians and Zionism differently. Indeed I disagree with the title of the post I’m sending you to. But what is most important in writing, especially in commentary, is not that it be “right” but that it be illuminating. Reading what is “right” is often reading a more polished version of what we already think — the utility of which is limited. Ganz manages to approach these questions with insight as well as texture and elegance, no simple feat.

On that matter of disagreement, I want to note something about what I have written on this issue. If you read carefully, I seldom make positive arguments for any particular position or question on this topic. I tend to point up what I see as disconnects or inconsistencies in pat arguments and responses. This is partly temperamental. I don’t like making arguments or claims that aren’t packaged with strong and concrete defenses. It’s also because with all the internal media and imagery there’s a huge amount of what is going on that we simply don’t know. One such question is whether Israel’s retaliation in response to the October 7th massacres is justified.

Continue reading “Decision Time”

Ex-DC Chief Judge Warns Of Creeping Authoritarianism

A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM’s Morning Memo. Sign up for the email version.

Big Liars And The Big Lies They Tell

No judge has had a better global view of the Trump prosecutions than U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell, who as chief judge in DC until earlier this year oversaw the grand juries investigating Trump’s election subversion efforts and his unlawful retention of classified documents at Mar-a-Lago.

It was Howell who made key rulings during the Jan. 6 grand jury proceedings on executive privilege, the crime-fraud exception to attorney-client privilege, and other investigative issues. As chief judge, she also had administrative responsibilities for the district court’s heavy case load of Jan. 6 rioter cases.

So when Howell warns of creeping authoritarianism in the United States, it’s worth taking notice.

Speaking last night at a lawyers event in DC, Howell quoted from Boston College historian Heather Cox Richardson’s new book, including:

  • “Big lies are springboards for authoritarians.”
  • The U.S. “is at a crossroads teetering on the brink of authoritarianism.”

Howell’s comments were reported by Politico’s Josh Gerstein:

“We are having a very surprising and downright troubling moment in this country when the very importance of facts is dismissed, or ignored,” Howell told the annual gala of the Women’s White Collar Defense Association at a downtown hotel. “That’s very risky business for all of us in our democracy. … The facts matter.”

Howell did not mention Trump by name but noted that the DC judges “regularly see the impact of big lies at the sentencing of hundreds, hundreds of individuals who have been convicted for offense conduct on Jan. 6, 2021.”

Convict-In-Chief?

TPM’s Josh Kovensky takes a closer look at some of the mechanisms available to Trump to make his prosecutions/convictions go away if he is elected president again.

Trump’s Shiny New Absurd Defense

Turning the last eight years on its head, Donald Trump now wants to use the intelligence community’s assessment of Russian interference in U.S. elections to demonstrate that it was not he who sowed public distrust.

That’s right. Trump wants to use the intelligence community that he abhorred and their assessments that he roundly and publicly rejected as fodder for his own criminal defense.

More On The New Mike Pence Reveals

Aaron Blake: The plot thickens on a Mike Pence Jan. 6 recusal

Rupert Murdoch Deposed In Smartmatic Case

The chairman emeritus of Fox Corp. and News Corp. is being deposed yesterday and today in Los Angeles in Smartmatic’s $2.7 billion defamation lawsuit against Fox News, Reuters reports.

No Plea Deals For Trump, Rudy, Or Meadows

Atlanta District Attorney Fani Willis has her eye on three big fish to whom plea deals will not be offered: Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani, and Mark Meadows, according to The Guardian:

The previously unreported decision has not been communicated formally and could still change, for instance, if prosecutors shift strategy. But it signals who prosecutors consider their main targets, and how they want to wield the power of Georgia’s racketeering statute to their advantage.

Hunter Biden Calls House GOP Bluff

The absurdity of the House GOP’s Trump-inspired Hunter Biden witch hunt came into even sharper focus Tuesday. Going on the offensive, Biden demanded a public hearing rather than a closed-door deposition with the House Oversight Committee. That sent Oversight Chair James Comer (R-KY) into paroxysms of backpedaling. Painful to watch:

If that wasn’t good enough, here’s Comer pretending it’s all public anyway (which could make it harder to negotiate future “private” sit-downs with the committee since they’re not really private):

Fox Tap Dances

The good folks at Fox News howled in protest at Hunter Biden wanting to make the witch hunt against him public:

Dems Dance

House Democrats had fun with all the fodder provided by their GOP colleagues:

We Will Still Have Santos To Kick Around

A Grievous Injustice

The three college students (Brown, Trinity (CT), and Haverford) of Palestinian descent who were shot over the weekend in Burlington, Vermont, continue to recover from their injuries. The most seriously wounded, Hisham Awartani, suffered spinal cord damage and has a long and uncertain road to recovery ahead.

The three young men were in Burlington visiting Awartani’s grandmother for Thanksgiving. Chris Hayes aired a long, compelling interview last night with Awartani’s uncle, who also lives in Burlington:

U.S. Water Utilities Hacked

Politico: “The federal government is investigating multiple hacks suspected to have been launched by an Iranian government-linked cyber group against U.S. water facilities that were using Israeli-made technology, according to two individuals familiar with the probes.”

New Charges Expected In India Assassination Plot In US

WaPo: “The discovery of a plot to assassinate a Sikh separatist on U.S. soil earlier this year so concerned the Biden administration that it dispatched its top two intelligence officials to New Delhi to demand the Indian government investigate and hold to account those responsible, senior administration officials said.”

Pope Evicts U.S. Cardinal From Vatican Apartment

Pope Francis has reportedly taken more drastic actions against the defiant retired American Cardinal Raymond Burke, a doctrinal conservative who is an outspoken critic of the pontiff, evicting him from his Vatican apartment and stripping him of his salary.

The Most Important Statistic Of All

New life expectancy data from the CDC shows the U.S. continues to lag other wealthy nations after taking a harder hit from COVID and bouncing back more slowly.

LOLOL

Former Rep. Liz Cheney’s new book includes her account of this bonkers exchange with Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) on his post-Jan. 6 pilgrimage to Mar-a-Lago:

Do you like Morning Memo? Let us know!