Are We Trapped in Trumpian DNA?

I have a long list of quibbles what with TPM Reader PJ shares here — mainly on conflating two very different meanings of “liberalism” and I think giving too little significance to the coalitional nature of the Democratic Party. But I wanted to share it with you because it’s a good contribution to the conversation …

I appreciate what you’re saying about the far left and liberalism. let me offer a bit of a counterpoint. I think there are some people who read Trump as an expression of something highly American. Maybe not intrinsically American, per se, but something that’s mixed in the DNA and which often takes over: white supremacy, masculinist fantasies of domination, an erotic fascination with violence. Moreover, we know where the roots of liberalism are: John Locke, contract theory, a social imagination that puts the individual at the center of the social world and struggles to understand that personhood is constantly being constructed, rather than etched in stone by a Maker.

Klobuchar’s Night?

TPM Reader RW thought it was Klobuchar’s night …

I’m an undecided New Hampshire democrat–at least I was until tonight. I attended the MSNBC watch party and thought Klobuchar hit it out of the park (and so did most of the crowd). I’ve seen most of the candidates during their swings through the state, many in intimate settings. For weeks my wife and I have been agonizing about whom to support.

An Upgrade

In post-acquittal campaign emails President Trump has upgraded himself from the “perfect phone call” to the “perfect president”.

From one just this morning. “Like I’ve been saying all along, I DID NOTHING WRONG. If they had just read the TRANSCRIPT, they would’ve seen that I’ve been a PERFECT PRESIDENT.”

A Party Switch

An update from the New York suburbs from TPM Reader FB …

Tonight, a Republican County Legislator in Westchester County New York, David Tubiolo from Yonkers, switched parties and became a Democrat. This left the 17-member Westchester County Board of Legislators, which as recently as 3 years ago had a Republican coalition majority and arch-conservative County Executive, with NO REPUBLICANS. The sole remaining member of the minority caucus is a registered Conservative from the town of Mt. Pleasant.

Biden Laments Being ‘The Underdog’ In New Hampshire Days Before Primary

Former Vice President Joe Biden said in a rare-post debate interview following the Democratic presidential debate in New Hampshire Friday night that he believes he is “the underdog” in the state’s upcoming Tuesday primary. Continue reading “Biden Laments Being ‘The Underdog’ In New Hampshire Days Before Primary” →

Our Top Takeaways From The Last Dem Debate Before New Hampshire

Seven Democratic presidential contenders on Friday gathered for the last debate before Monday’s presidential primary in the state, a crucial vote in the still-crowded candidate field.

In a two-and-a-half hour exchange only briefly interrupted by short commercial breaks, the Democrats on stage covered plenty of ground. Here are some takeaways:

Who’s the unifier?

Now that the caucuses/primaries are underway, the candidates want to show voters that they can unify the party when it comes time to pick a nominee.

For some, like former Vice President Joe Biden, that has been the message from the start. But as Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) picks up steam, he’s compelled to tweak his strategy a bit, to show that he can be more than the anti-establishment crusader.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) continued to envelop her progressive policies in a relatable, anecdotal shell and Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) tried to convey that she is a presidential everywoman. Expect candidates to keep trying to broaden their appeal as the convention looms ever closer.

Warren on ‘race conscious laws’

The Massachusetts senator oftentimes struggled to get a word in edgewise, but her answer on policies to address racial wealth disparities stood out for its strength.

“Race has totally permeated our criminal justice system,” Warren said, before arguing that criminal justice can’t be the only issue on which Democrats address racial disparities.

From home ownership to education, employment to entrepreneurship, she said, the next President should focus on “race conscious laws” to address past bias in the legal code.

Biden livens up 

After a surprisingly weak performance in Iowa, the former vice president needed to show the crowd in Manchester that he had the energy to take his campaign through all 50 states over two election cycles.

In large part, Biden did this, turning up the volume on his answers and delivering impassioned remarks on abortion access and childhood poverty and using his long history in Washington, D.C. to his advantage.

However, there were some definite weaknesses as well, such as the former vice president’s evasive response to recent offensive remarks by a campaign surrogate, the South Carolina legislator Dick Harpootlian.

Did Mayor Pete hold his own?

After a surprisingly strong performance in Iowa, where he’d concentrated a bunch of his campaign’s muscle, Pete Buttigieg had a lot to defend Friday night — he also got plenty of screen time, as his opponents took shots at him and, in so doing, gave him time to respond.

The former South Bend mayor held his own most of the time, given the newfound pressure he was under, but at times he slipped into clearly pre-rehearsed lines. A weak moment for Buttigieg came when moderator Linsey Davis noted that the racial disparity in marijuana arrests went up during Buttigieg’s mayorship. “We adopted a strategy that said that drug enforcement would be targeted in cases where there was a connection to the most violent group or gang connected to a murder,” the candidate replied, before pivoting to systemic racism. “These things are all connected, but that’s the point!”

Davis asked Warren if that was “a substantial answer from Mayor Buttigieg?”

“No,” Warren replied.

End Endless Wars… mostly

Every candidate on stage, when the discussion turned to foreign policy, struck some note of the now-familiar song among Democrats, about bringing the endless entanglement in Afghanistan to a conclusion. But most hedged when pressed on whether or not they would withdraw all American military might from the region.

“I have not argued for the placement of major numbers of U.S. combat troops,” Biden said at one point.

“We should work with our allies in managing terrorism, but we need to end this war in Afghanistan,” Warren said, striking a similar note before arguing that “we need to take our combat troops home.”

Debate Blog #2

10:38 PM: Given that some really big things are going to be decided Tuesday and in the week or two just after I didn’t come out of this debate having any more sense of what is going to happen.

9:05 PM: This David Muir guy really typifies the worst of how the big news organizations approach foreign affairs. Most of his questions have centered on goading people into saying they’d start more wars, kill more people. There’s more to our role in the world than macho test questions about whether you would have killed this person or attacked that country. And it’s not like I’m a big pacifist. But that’s a really skewed, warped way of looking at our role in the world.

9:03 PM: Biden started the debate distant and vague. He’s at least showing energy here and focus. Not the highest standard of course.

Debate Blog

8:52 PM: Good on Buttigieg for not getting goaded into saying he would have ordered the assassination of Soleimani. The ABC guy definitely tried.

8:48 PM: Bernie is 100% right. Reliving, relitigating 2016 is a disaster.

8:27 PM: Biden: “The politics of the past I think was not all that bad. … I don’t know what about the past of Barack Obama and Joe Biden was so bad.”

8:21 PM: One thing I keep thinking about in these health care debates is, can someone make the point that President Trump is trying to get rid of the ACA and eliminate protections for pre-existing conditions? I’m not saying that’s all that matters. We need to build on the ACA. But politically speaking, you just can’t never mention that.

8:16 PM: I respect Sanders for saying unprompted that everyone on the stage is going to support the nominee. I don’t doubt he means it. But that’s not what’s happening with his supporters. Not most of them, but many of the most vocal. That’s a big problem for all Democrats.

8:10 PM: Good follow-ups by Stephanopoulos. Bernie constantly talks about game-changing turnout, reshaping the electorate. But his own campaigns show little evidence of that.

8:08 PM: This is a rough display. I think Biden is right that both of the current frontrunners – Sanders and Buttigieg – are big big risks as the Democratic nominee. But Sanders is just more dynamic and coherent making his case than Biden is, in this specific exchange.