Report: Medicare Rule Pays For Prescriptions Of Dead Beneficiaries

FILE - In this Sept. 18, 2014 file photo, Medicaid Administrator Marilyn Tavenner testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington. A government watchdog agency says Medicare’s prescription drug program kept paying for cost... FILE - In this Sept. 18, 2014 file photo, Medicaid Administrator Marilyn Tavenner testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington. A government watchdog agency says Medicare’s prescription drug program kept paying for costly medications even after patients were dead. The problem seems to have started with a bureaucratic rule now getting a second look. A report coming out Friday from the Health and Human Services inspector general says Medicare has been allowing payment for prescriptions filled up to 32 days after a patient’s death. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta, File) MORE LESS

WASHINGTON (AP) — Call it drugs for the departed: Medicare’s prescription program kept paying for costly medications even after patients were dead.

The problem was traced back to a head-scratching bureaucratic rule that’s now getting a second look.

A report coming out Friday from the Health and Human Services Department’s inspector general says the Medicare rule allows payment for prescriptions filled up to 32 days after a patient’s death — at odds with the program’s basic principles, not to mention common sense.

“Drugs for deceased beneficiaries are clearly not medically indicated, which is a requirement for (Medicare) coverage,” the IG report said. It urged immediate changes to eliminate or restrict the payment policy.

Medicare said it’s working on a fix.

Investigators examined claims from 2012 for a tiny sliver of Medicare drugs — medications to treat HIV, the virus that causes AIDS — and then cross-referenced them with death records. They found that the program paid for drugs for 158 beneficiaries after they were already dead. The cost to taxpayers: $292,381, an average of $1,850 for each beneficiary.

Medicare’s “current practices allowed most of these payments to occur,” the report said.

Of 348 prescriptions dispensed for the dead beneficiaries, nearly half were filled more than a week after the patient died. Sometimes multiple prescriptions were filled on behalf of a single dead person.

Investigators don’t know what happened to the medications obtained on behalf of dead people, but some may have been diverted to the underground market for prescription medicines. The report said HIV drugs can be targets for fraud since they can be very expensive; one common HIV drug costs about $1,700 for a month’s supply, it said.

Medicare is the government’s premier health insurance program, providing coverage to about 55 million seniors and disabled people. Prescription coverage delivered through private insurance plans began in 2006 as a major expansion of the program. But it’s also been a target for scams.

The report did not estimate the potential financial impact across the $85 billion-a-year Medicare prescription program known as Part D. But investigators believe the waste may add up to millions of dollars.

“The exposure for the entire Part D program could be significant,” said Miriam Anderson, team leader on the report. “The payment policy is the same for all drugs, whether they are $2,000 drugs to treat HIV or $4 generic drugs.”

In a formal response, Medicare agreed with the investigators’ recommendations.

“After reviewing this report, (Medicare) has had preliminary discussions with the industry to revisit the need for a 32-day window,” wrote Marilyn Tavenner, the Obama administration’s Medicare chief.

Medicare had originally maintained that the date of service listed in the billing records could instead reflect when a pharmacy submitted bills for payment. That billing date might have actually occurred after a prescription was filled, since some nursing home and institutional pharmacies submit their bills in monthly bundles.

However, the inspector general’s investigators found that about 80 percent of the prescriptions for dead beneficiaries were filled at neighborhood pharmacies, undercutting Medicare’s first explanation. As for the remainder, the investigators said they didn’t see any reason pharmacies can’t report an accurate date of service.

Investigators said they stumbled on the problem during an examination of coverage for AIDS drugs dispensed toMedicare beneficiaries. Sexually transmitted diseases are an increasingly recognized problem among older people.

That earlier investigation raised questions about expensive medications billed on behalf of nearly 1,600 Medicare recipients.

Some had no HIV diagnosis in their records, but they were prescribed the drugs anyway. Others were receiving excessively large supplies of medications. Several were getting prescriptions filled from an unusually large number of pharmacies.

Prescription drug fraud has many angles. When the high price of a drug puts it out of reach for certain patients, it can create an underground market. And some medications, like painkillers and anti-anxiety pills, are constantly sought after by people with substance-abuse issues.

___

Online:

HHS Inspector General: http://oig.hhs.gov/oei/reports/oei-02-11-00172.pdf

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

3
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. This is actually a tricky problem. My wife works in a clinic with a lot of Medicare patients. Billing is complicated already, to say the least.

    Nursing homes, clinics and hospitals may well be billing for prescriptions after a patient has died, even though those prescriptions were delivered (or simply ordered) while the patient was still alive. The 32 day window (exactly one day over the longest month) is probably designed to take care of that.

    However, it seems like that billing window is being exploited, at least to a degree. But the challenge will be how to close the window without putting a serious burden on institutional providers.

    I hope Medicare moves slowly and carefully to change the rules, to avoid another hit to an already highly burdened billing departments in medical institutions. It’s already a paperwork nightmare.

  2. This topic is of particular interest to me because I worked on the team that wrote the Medicare/Medicaid fraud/waste/abuse detection software implemented in 2009 and written into law as part of the ACA.

    The level of Medicare/Medicaid fraud is epidemic. It had been pretty easy to submit fraudulent claims for procedures, drugs, services and medical equipment, and the enforcement was pitifully weak. The new software used the research and input from thousands of health care professionals to write metrics that would search for particular patterns - claims from dead doctors, or on behalf of dead beneficiaries, excessive claims for procedures and equipment (such as docs performing 60 operation a day or a patient receiving 10 wheelchairs, etc). Amazingly, prior to this time there were NO automated checks of any kind.

    The providers and companies suspected of fraud are turned over to the FBI. As of 2010, over $6B in fraudulent claims had been recovered. It’s probably more by this time, but I haven’t kept up with it since retirement.

    Part of the explanation for delays has to do with how the massive amounts of data are transferred from one federal system to another for comparison. Companies may be late in providing data. There are billions of records to process and the comparison has to be timed properly, usually once a month. So I can see how a 30-day lag would be shrugged off as “falling through the cracks.”

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for clemmers Avatar for KenR4th

Continue Discussion