PHOENIX (AP) — A federal judge has struck down Arizona’s 2005 immigrant smuggling law on the grounds that it’s trumped by federal statutes.
The ruling Friday by U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton marked the latest in a string of restrictions placed by the courts on Arizona’s effort to get local police to confront illegal immigration.
Bolton ruled the state law deprives federal authorities of their exclusive right to prosecute smuggling crimes.
Arizona’s smuggling law was passed as lawmakers responded to voter frustration over the state’s position as the nation’s then-busiest immigrant smuggling hub.
The smuggling law had been used frequently in Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s trademark immigration efforts, though the courts have curbed his immigration powers over the 17 last months.
Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
This is an AP article so TPM can’t be held accountable, and it is quite likely that the author is not a native speaker of English, but this violates a basic rule of English grammar.
Ordinals (first, second, last, next, previous, etc.) and cardinal numbers are post-determiners and follow the determiner(s) but precede the pre-modifiers (adjectives) in a noun phrase. Ordinals precede cardinal numbers: “the first ten names”, “his first good book sold well; his previous nine books did not”.
It is sad that TPM has slipped from being a center for political analysis and devolved into a site for teaching English style and grammar through the exposure of flagrant solecisms.
The Arizona Ordinals, a minor league team no doubt
On the ballot here in AZ there was an initiative placed on the ballot by the Legislature to change the AZ Constitution. What the republicans (they have the majority in both state houses and have had them for 44+ years) wanted was for our state Constitution to trump the US Constitution so that if they felt federal officers (read Obama) did something they construed as unconstitutional they wouldn’t have to participate. State sovereignty was the issue. And the initiative was worded vaguely such that one was not sure what was the correct vote.
When last I checked the issue was not decided as the vote was very close. But it looks like The good judge has ended the issue.
Edit:
The issue is not decided:
From Huffington Post
Arizona
Proposition 122 - Rejection of Unconstitutional Federal Actions. Creates mechanism by which use of
state personnel and financial resources are employed only for purposes congruent with Constitution.
100% reporting
Yes
651,512
51.2%
No
620,929
48.8%
A no vote would have the effect keeping the law as it is (Us Constitution trumps all)
I could be wrong but shouldn’t it be: “…is not a native English speaker”?
Frank, AP or not, if bad grammar offends you (it offends me) then you need a bottle of wine before venturing into this site. You will not leave here unscathed.
The writers couldn’t pass my high school freshman class. There are no editors, and the people don’t even re-read what they have written before posting. They don’t even have basic knowledge concerning use of spell check.