D.C. Federal Judge Tosses Trump Suit To Block NY From Giving Congress His Tax Returns

WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 23: U.S. President Donald Trump poses for photographs with farmers and ranchers from across the country in the Oval Office at the White House May 23, 2019 in Washington, DC. As the U.S.-China tra... WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 23: U.S. President Donald Trump poses for photographs with farmers and ranchers from across the country in the Oval Office at the White House May 23, 2019 in Washington, DC. As the U.S.-China trade war continues to hurt American farmers with tariffs on everything from peanut butter to soybeans and orange juice, the federal government announced Thursday it will give an additional $16 billion bailout to those most affected. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

A Washington, D.C. federal judge on Monday rejected an attempt by President Donald Trump to prevent New York state from releasing his tax returns to Congress. But Trump could pursue the case in New York, the judge said.

Trump’s suit centers on a new law in New York that would allow the state to release his state tax returns (or those of certain other public officials) to Congress.

The House Ways and Means Committee hasn’t actually requested the documents yet, but Trump in July preemptively sued the committee, as well as New York’s attorney general and tax commissioner, to prevent such a request from being honored.

New York Attorney General Letitia James argued in July that Trump had not proven that the case could be argued in D.C. on jurisdictional grounds, and Judge Carl Nichols of the D.C. District Court agreed with her in his opinion Monday, dismissing Trump’s complaint.

“Even if Mr. Trump alleged that either New York Defendant was involved in the legislative process, he cites no authority for the proposition that enacting or helping to enact a state statute in another state would constitute ‘transacting business’ in the District of Columbia,” the judge wrote, knocking done one of several of Trump’s arguments that the dispute over the New York law could be adjudicated in Washington, D.C.

Nichols originally asked Trump, the committee and the New York officials to work things out among themselves. But the parties told the court a day later that they had opposite views of the case.

Nichols is a recent federal judge, a Trump nominee who was confirmed by the Senate in June.

“Mr. Trump may press his claims against the New York Defendants in this Court should future events support the exercise of personal jurisdiction over them, or he may opt to pursue those claims in an appropriate forum,” he concluded his opinion Monday.

Separately, the Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals declined last week to block a subpoena of Trump’s financial records, including his tax returns, in an ongoing state investigation. Trump’s attorneys have said they intend to take both that matter and another dispute over Trump’s financial records in D.C. to the Supreme Court if necessary.

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for dave48 dave48 says:

    The only real question is, when will SCOTUS hear any of these cases? It seems unlikely they would rule in Trump’s favor but, however they rule, their decision will be the only thing that can really bring an end to all of this silliness.

  2. Avatar for outis outis says:

    How long can this delaying go on?

  3. SCOTUS will not hear this one.

  4. Avatar for nemo nemo says:

    Note the case was argued in July. It’s now mid-November

  5. Avatar for sooner sooner says:

    “In his lawsuit, Trump’s attorneys argued that the state law was simply an effort to get information about his personal finances to embarrass him politically.“

    I had no idea the Chosen One carried the embarrassment gene. None at all

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

91 more replies


Avatar for discobot Avatar for sedonaz Avatar for playitagainrowlf Avatar for sooner Avatar for ncsteve Avatar for kilgoretrout Avatar for irasdad Avatar for sandyh Avatar for inversion Avatar for lastroth Avatar for schmed Avatar for dddinah Avatar for darrtown Avatar for pshah Avatar for tena Avatar for misterneutron Avatar for guysmiley Avatar for dannydorko Avatar for skeptical Avatar for justruss Avatar for paul_lukasiak Avatar for dicktater Avatar for ldcolton Avatar for kovie

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: