Naomi Wolf: Media ‘Distorts’ My Questions About ISIL Beheading Videos

Naomi Wolf== The New York Premiere Screening of the Second Season of FINDING YOUR ROOTS== MoMA, New York== September 16, 2014== Photo-JIMI CELESTE/ ( via AP Images)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Journalist and author Naomi Wolf insisted in a letter to the news media Monday that she does not believe videos of Islamic State militants beheading American and British hostages were “staged.”

“I am not asserting that the ISIS videos have been staged,” she wrote in a Facebook post. “No one can yet know anything for sure about the ISIS videos as they have simply not been independently analyzed, according to the news outlets which we have contacted for more information about the verification process.”

A number of news sites, including TPM, picked up Wolf’s Facebook posts from over the weekend in which she argued that the beheading videos could not be taken as accurate without independent verification. In one post that was later deleted, Wolf wrote that while the hostages may have truly been abducted, “it takes five people to stage an event like this — two to be ‘parents’ — two to pose for in a ninja outfit….and one to contact the media that does not bother checking who ANY Of these other four people are.”

“I certainly sincerely apologize if one of my posts was insensitively worded,” Wolf wrote in Monday’s post. “I have taken that one down. But that does not mean I don’t stand by the need for all journalists to have two independent sources confirming a major story before they release it as confirmed.”

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for glans glans says:

    She asked good questions. She made good points. Let’s chill the hysteria.

  2. Avatar for dectra dectra says:

    Two points, sweetie…

    1. You ARE the ‘media’

    2. By showing Exactly What You Said On TAPE, your own words are what hung you by your petard…

  3. You also asserted that the troops being sent over to fight Ebola are going to bring it back to the states in order to take over the country. So excuse us sane folks for once again pointing out how much of a crackpot loon you are.

  4. I would suggest that everyone so consumed with outrage never wear earth tones again in protest.

    There are indeed many unanswered questions. She is correct to point out that these hostages appeared out of nowhere – they had not been reported as hostages allegedly under a media blackout.

    Why there was a blackout when other hostage-taking is reported is totally unclear, and a decidedly incurious corporate media is more consumed with fanning the flames of support for more slaughter, while dutifully ignoring reporting on the consequences of our own actions. It strikes me that the CIA does a lot of “humanitarian” work as well.

    I find these beheadings distinct from the babies-pulled-from-incubators meme only to the extent that these individuals were indeed brutally murdered. Meanwhile, Chelsea Manning rots in prison for showing Americans just one rather sanitized example of the murder we conduct. And our panties are all jammed up our asscrack over this distraction. Please.

  5. In other words, you’re saying – as she is – “maybe they were staged. Who knows?”

    I don’t think that constitutes “chilling the hysteria.”

Continue the discussion at

28 more replies


Avatar for system Avatar for doremus_jessup Avatar for webcelt Avatar for glans Avatar for ajm Avatar for pac Avatar for mattinpa Avatar for deckbose Avatar for trippin Avatar for wiscojoe Avatar for mrcomments Avatar for kerpow Avatar for wargreymon2013 Avatar for dectra Avatar for dnl Avatar for thunderclapnewman Avatar for CygnusX1isahole Avatar for Jonny66 Avatar for diturno Avatar for rdz78

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: