In Banning Journos, Elon Musk Continues To Show Exactly Who He Is

A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM’s Morning Memo.

Waste And Destruction

Like with Trump, we know everything we need to know about Elon Musk. New scandals or outbursts of impulsivity or additional episodes of narcissistic self-absorption are merely duplicative. All that’s left to do is to chronicle the waste and destruction they leave in their paths.

Last night’s Twitter ban of multiple journalists is just further confirmation of numerous sound judgments already made:

  • Musk is not a free speech champion.
  • Musk is erratic, inconsistent, unreliable, and attention-craving.
  • Musk’s actions and decisions are not guided by underlying principles or values.
  • Musk savors inflicting pain and abuse.
  • Musk enjoys your scolding and opprobrium because it feels like attention.

Broken, petulant, emotionally stunted rich white men are nothing new. What might be new is that decades of regressive tax policy, feckless anti-trust enforcement, and market worship by policymakers have created an untethered and unaccountable new billionaire class.

Latest Installment In The Meadows Texts Series

This went up last evening: “Kari Lake’s Cameo In The Meadows Texts Shows How 2020 Election Denial Became An Enduring Movement”

TPM On TV

TPM’s Hunter Walker talks about the Meadows Texts with Katie Phang:

Everyone Is Covering The Meadows Texts

David Corn: “Newly Revealed Texts Show Mark Meadows Is a Liar”

First Read: “Jan. 6 continues to stain GOP, text messages show”

Charlie Pierce: “Mark Meadows’ Texts Are a Rich Tapestry of Conniving and Political Derangement”

Wonkette: “So, before we get into the substance of Mark Meadows’s texts, let’s acknowledge the threshold scandal that he was the one running point to coordinate both the coup rally and the campaign. Which is FUCKING CRAZY!”

Rudy G Takes It On The Chin In DC Bar Case

A D.C. bar disciplinary panel has reached a preliminary finding that Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani violated ethics rules in one of his 2020 Big Lie cases in Pennsylvania. Bar investigators are recommending disbarment.

The tentative decision was reached in public proceedings held Thursday, and Rudy was not happy:

Tea-Leaf Reading On Jack Smith

Bloomberg’s Zoe Tillman teases out some new information about special counsel Jack Smith’s investigation: a new D.C. federal grand jury handling Jan. 6 matters was impaneled on Sept. 15 for a six-month term after an earlier grand jury expired. With a six-month term, the new grand jury will be available to hear evidence until March 2023.

Great Headline

Via Law & Crime: Arizona Governor-Elect Katie Hobbs Tells Judge Court ‘Should Not Indulge’ Losing Candidate Kari Lake’s ‘Absurd’ Lawsuit ‘a Minute Longer’

Paul Pelosi Smears Exposed

Chris Hayes on the new evidence that has emerged in the criminal case against Paul Pelosi’s assailant and how it further undermines the horrible smears casually pushed by Tucker Carlson and others in the days after the attack:

Stiff Sentences In Whitmer Kidnapping Case

The longest prison sentences handed down so far in the plot to kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D): Pete Musico, 12 years; Joe Morrison, 10 years; and Paul Bellar, seven years.

Senate Passes Stopgap Spending Bill

In a late-night vote, the Senate approved a stopgap spending bill to fund the government through Dec. 23, setting the stage for consideration of the still-to-be-unveiled $1.7 trillion omnibus package.

Three Years Later, Louisiana State Police Charged In Death Of Black Driver

Four Louisiana state troopers and a sheriff’s deputy were charged in the death of Ronald Greene, a Black man who died in 2019 while in police custody after a traffic stop. The case was initially whitewashed, but disturbing body cam footage emerged that ignited public outrage and eventually led to a criminal investigation of the officers allegedly involved.

Interesting Read

Longtime NYT labor reporter Steven Greenhouse, now retired, writes at length on the labor dispute at the Gray Lady.

Just In Time For Christmas!

I’m sad to report that some of you seemed to have been taken in by Trump’s announcement that he would make a big announcement. Maybe he’ll run for speaker! Maybe he has a new legal strategy! Maybe … but no.

Like the cheap salesman he is, Trump announced a new line of $99 NFT trading cards portraying him in various heroic poses, like this one:

Philip Bump asks a good question: Who convinced Donald Trump that Trump NFTs were a good idea? “[T]he art in the NFT line largely consists of clumsily Photoshopping Trump’s head onto manly, svelte figures,” Bump dryly notes.

Jimmy Fallon: “You know your campaign isn’t going well when your re-election strategy is, ‘Maybe people will like me as a Pokemon.’ Trump was like, ‘These cards are like classified documents — you’ve got to catch them all.’”

Even some Trump supporters weren’t fooled.

Do you like Morning Memo? Let us know!

Kari Lake’s Cameo In The Meadows Texts Shows How 2020 Election Denial Became An Enduring Movement

Failed Arizona gubernatorial candidate Kari Lake makes only one appearance in the 2,319 text messages former President Trump’s last chief of staff Mark Meadows provided to the House select committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack. However, Lake’s cameo provides an especially vivid example of how the challenge to Trump’s 2020 loss helped spur the creation of a new political movement that remains a force in American politics.

Lake is an election denier extraordinaire who is still engaged in a frivolous lawsuit to contest her loss nearly one month after that race was called. Before (publicly) jumping into politics, Lake had a longtime career as an anchor at KSAZ-TV, the local Fox affiliate in Phoenix. Lake was still in this position on November 7, 2020, when, based on the text log, Arizona Republican Party Chairwoman Kelli Ward texted Meadows with a hot tip that she said came from Lake. 

11/7/20 4:20 p.m.

I hate to keep bothering you when you are sick. Kari Lake – Fox 10 reporter who is conservative and who interviewed DJT a couple of times brought me info from one of her sources that relates to election integrity and voting machines and modems associated with them. She says it affects all 50 states. I don’t think she’d bring me something that she didn’t think was credible. The person is afraid to go to the FBI and actually fears for his life and the life of his family according to Kari. Who should I send this to in order to fact find?

Kelli Ward

In other words, according to Ward, Lake, who had interviewed Trump, had come to the leader of the state’s Republican Party with information from a “source” that called into question the election result in Arizona, where Joe Biden won. Ward’s message came shortly after most of the major broadcast networks declared that Biden had won the presidency. Lake declined to comment on this story.

Lake may have felt her source was “credible” and this person may have genuinely been deathly afraid, but even in the short text, it is apparent their claims were absurd. States and even various local jurisdictions have different systems for counting votes and many of these are not connected to the internet at all. The idea there could be any method to use “modems” to affect voting in “all 50 states” is virtually impossible. 

Ward, who did not respond to a request for comment, followed that text up with another one eight minutes later where she sent Meadows contact information for a man she described as “an attorney of 46 years in Florida and former military police in the army.” 

“He’s credible,” Ward wrote. 

TPM is not identifying the man because he is not a public figure. Reached via phone on Thursday, the man declined to comment about whether he communicated with Lake or if he believed modems had impacted the election nationally. 

“I’m not going to make any comment,” the man said before hanging up. 

Ward was intimately involved in the efforts to challenge the 2020 race. Ward fought a subpoena from the Jan. 6 committee for her phone logs from T-Mobile all the way to the Supreme Court, where she lost last month. She was also subpoenaed in June by a federal grand jury investigating Trump’s fake electors scheme. According to the log, Ward exchanged over 40 messages with Meadows. They include texts indicating Ward worked with Trump’s lawyer Rudy Giuliani and that she pressed local officials including Arizona’s Republican Gov. Doug Ducey about various challenges to the election.

The text log, which is not necessarily a complete record of Meadows’ communications, does not contain any response to Ward’s message about Lake’s “source.” For more information about the story behind the text log and our procedures for publishing the messages, read the introduction to this series. Meadows and the select committee did not respond to requests for comment on this story.

Lake’s personal politics have run the gamut over the years. For a profile that ran in October, the Washington Post spoke to friends and colleagues who described her as having been excited about Barack Obama and disillusioned with the forever wars in the Middle East. Between 2008 and 2012, Lake switched back and forth between the two parties. Her outlook steadily lurched to the right after Trump’s election in 2016, the Post reported. 

In 2019, she got in trouble at work for cheerfully posting on Parler, an online hang for the far-right, which only intensified when she was caught on a hot mic discussing the kerfuffle and dismissing a local alt-weekly as a “rag for selling marijuana.” Last year, Lake left journalism to embark on a campaign built on looking backwards, fixating on the supposedly stolen 2020 election.

Lake’s television experience imbued her with the charisma that made so many either fear or admire her as a budding MAGAworld celebrity. But while her path to politics was unique, her final destination was not. 

Based on a count from the Washington Post, Lake was one of 291 election deniers who ran for U.S. House, Senate or major statewide offices this cycle. Most, like Lake, were radicalized in 2020, when Trump infected the Republican Party with baseless doubts about the election’s validity. Many, like Lake, also lost: a big theme of this cycle was the widespread failure of the candidates who tried to win critical general elections on a Big Lie platform. 

Nevertheless, Lake’s story provides a vivid example of how, for some, belief in 2020 conspiracies grew into efforts to enter the political realm. Even now, while she continues pursuing a case to get her loss overturned, Lake is staying active on social media, directing supporters to read her lawsuit on a website festooned with bright “donate” buttons in all caps. 

“If they thought we would just sulk and accept the results of a rigged, sham election, they were wrong,” Lake said in a typically glossy, direct-to-camera address this week. “My resolve to fight for the millions of Arizonans disgusted with years of botched elections is stronger than ever.” 

Beating Trump in the Primary is The Easy Part

On the issue of whether Trump is “done,” as I put it below, the primary itself really isn’t the question. There seems little doubt that another Republican could defeat Donald Trump for the nomination, though I’m skeptical of whether that person is Ron DeSantis. The more operative question is what you do with Trump after you beat him. Normally you have a primary battle and one candidate comes out on top. It may be a cakewalk or a brutal slog. But one candidate gets the most delegates and the others fall in behind that candidate.

It’s very difficult, though, to imagine Donald Trump losing a hard fought primary struggle and then just gracefully falling in line as a surrogate for the guy who beat him. In fact, it’s basically impossible to imagine that happening.

Continue reading “Beating Trump in the Primary is The Easy Part”

‘Punked’: Trump Unveils His ‘MAJOR ANNOUNCEMENT’ And It Lands With A Thud

Former President Donald Trump teased a “major announcement” on Wednesday night. It was a big production complete with a grainy animation of Trump, who is currently running to regain his old job, shooting lasers out of his eyes and ripping open a button-down shirt to reveal a Superman-style costume complete with a gleaming “T” on his muscled chest. 

Continue reading “‘Punked’: Trump Unveils His ‘MAJOR ANNOUNCEMENT’ And It Lands With A Thud”

Is Trump Done?

I’ve treated it as a given that Trump is the nominee in 2024 if he wants to be. But today’s “Major Announcement” from Trump, which ended up being a new set of NFT playing cards with Trump in a bulging Superman suit, crystalizes my growing doubts about whether he still has the juice to go another round. We’ve also seen a couple polls this week which show a clear majority of self-described Republican primary voters prefer Ron DeSantis over Trump, albeit with DeSantis continuing Trump’s policies. But polls can change. Nor does a poll more than a year out from the first primary capture all the kinetic dimensions of an actual primary battle. What is less changeable are the growing signs that Trump is just a loser.

Continue reading “Is Trump Done?”

It’s All Meadows Texts All The Time

A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM’s Morning Memo.

What A Week

TPM’s series on the Meadows Texts continues to be the dominant news story of the week. A big shoutout to the entire TPM team for the hard work and long hours required to pull this off. It was an all-hands-on-deck effort. Special kudos to lead reporter Hunter Walker and lead editor John Light.

Let’s dive right into the past 24 hours of coverage.

The Latest On The Meadows Texts

The two newest installments in our ongoing series:

TPM On TV

Hunter Walker was on last night with Chris Hayes, who is just as into the Meadows Texts as we are:

TPM On The Radio

Josh Kovensky talks with Atlanta NPR station WABE. Listen.

So Much More TV Coverage!

Morning Joe marvels over the Meadows Texts:

Joy Reid talks about the Meadows Texts with Asha Rangappa:

Ari Melber goes deeper on the Meadows Texts:

Lawrence O’Donnell zeroes in on our coverage of Rudy Giuliani’s appearance in the Meadows Texts:

More Reactions!

Harry Litman: “Don’t ask don’t tell how @TPM got its hands on the Meadows texts, but they’ve performed a real public service. The texts are totally damning and show not just Meadows but lawmakers (34 of them!) and others all willingly conspiring in the Big Lie attempted coup. Utterly shameful.”

Joyce Vance: “The burdens of proof are different in courts of law & the court of public opinion. Whether any of these members of Congress are ever prosecuted, the text messages are compelling evidence there were elected officials willing to disregard the Constitution to hold power.”

Jonathan Chait: “Text messages to and from White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows around the time of the January 6 insurrection, obtained by Talking Points Memo, confirm the impression. Meadows and his allies in Congress truly believed the election was stolen and truly believed they could and should steal it back. In these messages, Republicans can be seen over and over again repeating wild conspiracy theories about voting machines …”

Pushback!

Not everyone is happy with our series on the Meadows Texts:

  • Here’s former Trump DOJ official Jeffrey Clark — you remember the guy Trump wanted to install as acting attorney general to complete all the couping — seeming to go after TPM’s Josh Kovensky for his “ties to Ukraine.” (Before coming to TPM, Kovensky wrote for the English-language Kyiv Post.)
  • Sean Hannity was very not happy about being contacted for a Meadows Texts story:

We Have Memes!

Local Coverage Of The Meadows Texts

Atlanta Journal-Constitution: “Texts show Georgia Republicans sharing election conspiracy theories to aid Trump”

City & State PA: “A timeline of Scott Perry’s texts following the 2020 election”

The Deepest Cuts On the Meadows Texts

Sarah Posner: “Newly revealed texts between Allen and former White House chief of staff Mark Meadows, published while the hearing was in progress, dramatically show how deeply Christian nationalist ideology runs through the Republican Party, and how it continues to underlie Republicans’ ongoing denial that Jan. 6 was a violent attempt to overthrow the government.”

Greg Sargent:

And text messages from House Republicans to Trump’s chief of staff, Mark Meadows, unearthed by Talking Points Memo, show members of Congress scheming in the run-up to Jan. 6 to overturn Trump’s loss in all kinds of ways, with one even calling for Trump to declare martial law.

What all this means is that the insurrectionist spirit will run strong in next year’s GOP-controlled House, which would be likely to try to help with any effort by Trump — or an imitator — to subvert the 2024 presidential election. Under current law, if a GOP-controlled state legislature appointed electors for the Republican nominee in defiance of the state’s popular vote, the GOP House could count those electors, leading to a stolen election or constitutional crisis.

Jack Smith On The Case

CNN confirms: “Smith’s team has now sent subpoenas to local and state officials in all seven of the key states – Georgia, New Mexico, Nevada, Michigan, Arizona, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin – targeted by former President Donald Trump Trump and his allies as part of their bid to upend Joe Biden’s legitimate victory.”

Forgot About This One

How could I forget! Former Trump official Peter Navarro is still facing contempt of Congress charges. His trial is now scheduled to begin Jan. 30.

Good Reads

Boston Globe: “Like a plot from ‘The Americans’: An alleged Russian smuggling ring found in N.H. town” 

Daily Beast: “Inside the Jury Room for the Trump Org Criminal Trial”

NYT: “Trump Organization Was Held in Contempt After Secret Trial Last Year”

The Ritualistic Defenestration Of Kevin McCarthy

If not for the Meadows Texts, the wraithing of Kevin McCarthy would be can’t-stop-watching story of the week.

Politico: “Come on down? House GOP weighs the right price to topple a speaker”

CNN: “McCarthy’s impossible GOP math”

NYT: “Despite Trump’s Lobbying, McCarthy’s Speaker Bid Remains Imperiled on the Right”

CNN: McCarthy Snaps At CNN Reporter

Receding Into The Past

The new official portrait of Nancy Pelosi unveiled yesterday at the Capitol:

The U.S. Postal Service will honor the late John Lewis with a new commemorative stamp:

Do you like Morning Memo? Let us know!