Biggest Takeaways From Second Night Of CNN’s Democratic Debates

The second half of the Democratic candidates, relatively more uniform in policy than their night one counterparts, took the stage Wednesday to tussle on everything from criminal justice reform to deportations.

The night was punctuated with chanting hecklers, personal attacks and spotlights on the records of lawmakers like former Vice President Joe Biden and Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA).

Here are the biggest takeaways from the debate:

“Take it easy on me, kid”

The initial interactions between Biden, Harris and Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ) belied some of the underlying tensions between the three. Biden shook Harris’ hand with a folksy “take it easy on me, kid.”

When Booker strode onto the stage, he fixed Biden with a silent and steely gaze. He was much warmer with Harris, giving her a big hug as she called him “buddy.”

The Harris-Biden clash over busing was the most notable snippet from the first debate and Booker has since gotten in on the Biden jabs, earning himself some headlines and ratcheting up the three-way tension.

Harris took some serious heat

Harris was hit early and often by not only Biden, but also Sen. Michael Bennet (D-CO) and Rep. Tulsi Gabbard (D-HI). In the health care portion, the three of them took aim at her plan, sometimes subtly accusing her of dishonesty.

Here, Bennet calls her his “friend” then proceeds to implore honesty about the contents of her health care plan:

So much heckling

There were multiple bouts of heckling during the debate, some reaching such a pitch as to force the candidates to stop speaking.

The first occurred during New York Mayor Bill de Blasio’s introductory statement and seemed to spill over into Booker’s comments. They appear to have been chanting “fire Pantaleo!” a reference to the New York police officer who placed Eric Gardner in a fatal chokehold for selling loose cigarettes.

Later, the chant “three million deportations!” broke out while Biden was speaking on immigration, a reference to those deported under the Obama administration.

Biden took fire on immigration, criminal justice

Both de Blasio and Julián Castro slammed Biden on deportations under the Obama administration, and the former veep seemed flat-footed in response. It was a fairly predictable attack, as he’s the only candidate that served directly in a presidential administration overseeing deportations, as every administration does.

He took heat from Booker on criminal justice reform too, as the senator accused him both of having a poor track record on the issue and not being forward-oriented enough. Harris jumped on the topic too, revisiting the busing debate that was the hallmark of the first debate.

The Mueller report finally came up

The Mueller report came up Wednesday night after being completely omitted on night one. The question was most likely prompted by Harris’ statement about directing her Justice Department to prosecute President Donald Trump, should she become President.

It gave the candidates a chance to reiterate their calls for impeachment, though there isn’t much sunlight between them on the conviction that Mueller brought Trump’s misdeeds to the forefront.

Dem Debate Blog #3

10:12 PM: This exchange with Gillibrand is maybe the first time when Biden, even briefly, has given a nod to “okay, that wasn’t great but that was a long time ago.” It seemed instinctive and he didn’t stay with it long.

9:59 PM: Dana Bash’s questions are really right from the center-right DC consensus. Consistently.

9:48 PM: There are a bunch of really impressive candidates up on this stage, many of whom haven’t gotten any traction.

9:16 PM: Biden’s basically wearing Barack Obama as a coat.

Few Quick Thoughts

A lot of clatter in the first hour. What stands out to me most is that Biden is much more focused, much more aggressive. But he’s really not trying to compete within the conversations that are driving this campaign – not on immigration, not on health care. He’s focused on the general election campaign and that electorate. Harris seems a bit unused to being attacked from multiple sides at once. Booker is strong as usual.

Dem Debate Blog #2

9:05 PM: Biden definitely more forthright and focused than in the first debate. But he’s not really trying to compete on most of the debates that are animating this campaign. He’s focused on a general election campaign.

8:55 PM: Whatever you think of the specifics here, as I said last night, this question of whether or not unauthorized crossings constitute a civil or criminal offense is a pretty small part of the overall immigration question. It’s specific relevance is tied to Trump because he is using it as a tool to separate families.

There’s Another Debate?? Live Blog …

8:43 PM: This back and forth over private insurance is a good example of why it’s a deep disservice to voters that the four top candidates aren’t up on the stage together. It creates two debates where the debate on this central issue is just really distorted.

8:40 PM: As you know, I think the Sanders-style Medicare for All plan is a real liability in a general election. But this is a Democratic debate. And the moderators really aren’t pressing at all on questions like how many people does your plan cover, how does it contain costs? Ending private insurance is a big issue. But it’s hardly the only issue, to put it mildly.

8:34 PM: Seeing a lot of people saying Harris seemed wobbly. Not sure I see it that way.

8:18 PM: Not to snark but man, Bennet has a really, really soporific affect.

8:14 PM: Wow, De Blasio here to kick some wealthy person ass.

8:00 PM: Okay, let’s do this.

Republican Rep/Bigfoot Fan Under Fire From Local GOP For Officiating Gay Wedding

Bet you weren’t expecting this kind of reappearance from that particular congressman, were you?

Continue reading “Republican Rep/Bigfoot Fan Under Fire From Local GOP For Officiating Gay Wedding” →

Three Things To Watch During Round Two Of The CNN Debates

On Wednesday, another 10 candidates will take the stage after their peers battled it out over health care policy, taxes and electability for nearly three hours on night one of the debates.

Continue reading “Three Things To Watch During Round Two Of The CNN Debates” →

Ben Carson Booted Off Baltimore Church Property After Attempting To Hold Presser

Housing and Urban Development Secretary Ben Carson and his staffers were shown the door on Wednesday when he tried to hold a press conference at Morning Star Baptist Church of Christ in Baltimore.

Continue reading “Ben Carson Booted Off Baltimore Church Property After Attempting To Hold Presser” →

Readers on the Debate #6

From TPM Reader SS …

I’ve had similar thoughts as yours about the electoral danger of Warren’s embrace of Medicare for All. As a state-level healthcare reporter in the 1990s, I saw at close range the enormous political power of that industry. The beast will not go gently into that good night if Warren shows any possibility of winning the Democratic nomination. At the same time, I mostly agree with Warren’s policy direction and admire her political courage in taking such an unequivocal stance.

This gets me to reflect on my assumptions about electability. People win office all the time who advocate unpopular policy stances. Some even get elected – and reelected – despite considerable personal baggage. What then separates the winners from the losers?

Readers on the Debate #5

TPM Reader DR moves in a very different direction …

This may not be the issue everyone is talking about this morning, but I’m increasingly pissed off about the liberal vs. moderate framing everyone is using for last night’s debate.

I’ve been a liberal my whole life (60+ years) and now I’m a moderate or a centrist? No f—ing way. I’m heir to a long liberal tradition in this country that has always opposed the excesses of the left.