WATCH: Alleged CIA Torture ‘Architect’ Gives First-Ever On-Camera Interview

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

A retired Air Force psychologist, who has been alleged in press reports for nearly a decade to be an architect of the Central Intelligence Agency’s torture program, gave a first-ever on-camera interview to Vice News in the wake of the Senate Intelligence Committee’s damning report on the so-called enhanced interrogation program.

Vice News spoke with Dr. James Mitchell in his element, paddling in the marshlands of Florida, over drinks at his local watering hole, and at his home in Tampa. He and interviewer Kaj Larsen covered the utility of the agency’s harsh tactics, his relationship with and understanding of radical Islam, and his own reflections on more than a decade at war with terror.

Throughout the 25-minute interview, Mitchell is evasive about his role in the CIA’s program, which has been reported in publications like the New Yorker. “I’d really like to respond to those questions, but I can’t,” he says at one point, citing a non-disclosure agreement. When answering another question, he prefaces his answer with: “I’m not trying to imply it was me.

But Mitchell is largely responsive to Larsen’s questions, and perhaps the most striking moment is when he reacts to the intelligence committee’s findings that torture had not yielded actionable intelligence. It wasn’t supposed to, he says. It was supposed to make detainees more responsive to other questioning.

“It’s almost like a good cop, bad cop kind of set-up,” he says, “with a really bad cop.”

The point, he says, “was to facilitate getting actionable intelligence by making a bad cop that was bad enough that the person would engage with the good cop,” Mitchell continues. “I would be stunned if they found any kind of evidence that EITs, as they were being applied, yielded actionable intelligence.”

Larsen also pieces through Mitchell’s personal library with him, which is stacked with the Koran and other Islamic books. At one point, they flip through a book of Sharia law. Mitchell explains that the general public misunderstands the mindset of Islamic terrorists.

“We tend to think of them as suicidal fanatics,” he says. “It’s less like becoming a suicidal fanatic and more like becoming a Jedi warrior.”

He also waffles when asked if waterboarding specifically is torture.

“I don’t think it’s the right thing to do. I don’t think it’s the wrong thing to do,” he says. “It’s like every tool in the tool bag. You can underuse it. You can overuse it.”

Though, later, he adds: “I don’t think you should do anything that violates the torture convention.”

Mitchell is largely dispassionate when describing the interrogation program, his role and the public debate. But the one time when he shows emotion is when he recalls how he got involved in the first place. He remembers how he felt on 9/11 and knowing that he wanted to do something to help.

“When somebody asked me if I’d be willing to help,” he says, after pausing more than once to fight back tears, “I was willing to help.”

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. “When somebody asked me if I’d be willing to help,” he says, after pausing more than once to fight back tears, “I was willing to help.”

    And he only charged 81 MILLION DOLLARS!

  2. When they make the movie, this guy should be played by Donald Sutherland.

  3. Avatar for anniew anniew says:

    The term banality of evil comes to mind.

  4. Where does that sick motherfucker stand on the issue of anal rape? That’s what I wanna know. Is that torture Mitchell? Is that your doing Mitchell? That’s a fucking crime. So is murder.

    Immunity is what he got for all his “troubles” along with $81 million split two ways. Is he still a practicing psychologist? He sure is a fucking sadist. BTW, who was his inspiration, Joseph fucking Mengele???

  5. Avatar for hoppy hoppy says:

    This guy has so thoroughly rationalized his acts that I doubt that he now has any idea why he did whatever he did. He apparently decided that the Geneva Conventions were just suggestions and proceeded from there.

Continue the discussion at

19 more replies


Avatar for system1 Avatar for slbinva Avatar for anniew Avatar for jw1 Avatar for srfromgr Avatar for lochsabill Avatar for hoppy Avatar for mattinpa Avatar for dv01 Avatar for tcinla Avatar for teenlaqueefa Avatar for pdxer Avatar for anouthouse Avatar for mantan Avatar for chuck_voellinger Avatar for normankelley Avatar for taters Avatar for gr Avatar for twowolves Avatar for robertwaldmann Avatar for saminchicago

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: