Pennsylvania GOP Files Federal Lawsuit To Allow Out-Of-County Poll Watchers

Voters wait in line for a polling place to open at Eastlan Baptist Church, Saturday, Feb. 20, 2016 in Greenville, S.C. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

The Pennsylvania Republican Party filed a complaint late Friday night asking a federal court to allow out-of-county poll watchers to monitor voting stations on Election Day.

Filed on behalf of eight Keystone State voters, the suit alleges that state law restricting poll watchers to the county in which they’re registered violates the First Amendment and denies them their right to equal protection under the law.

Donald Trump has raised unfounded fears that the Nov. 8 election will be “rigged” by illegitimate ballots cast by undocumented immigrants, people voting multiple times, and “dead people.” All of them, he claims, will vote for Hillary Clinton.

He has called on his supporters to go “watch” voters in “certain areas” to ensure no fraud is committed, directing them to communities with large black populations like Philadelphia and Chicago.

Elections experts and secretaries of state have condemned his comments as dangerous and untrue, noting that voter fraud is extraordinarily rare. Invalid voter registrations are typically the result of outdated record-keeping rather than willful fraud.

Still, Republican Party of Pennsylvania GOP Communications Director Megan Sweeney told the Morning Call that the state party’s federal suit was simple “a commonsense remedy to ensure the fairest election possible.”

University of California law professor Rick Hasen, who runs the Election Law Blog, noted the “awfully late” date of the suit in a Friday post and said the U.S. Constitutional issues at hand seem “exceptionally weak.”

“The argument is that the failure to allow some voters within the state to serve as poll watchers violates equal protection, due process and First Amendment speech rights,” Hasen wrote. “I have never seen such an argument not extended to the act of voting, but to the act of watching at the polls.”

“I cannot see how this severely burdens voters’ rights,” Hasen continued, saying he doesn’t think the federal arguments “have much of a chance of going anywhere.”

A spokesman for Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf (D) concurred, calling the suit baseless.”

“It is shameful that the Pennsylvania Republican Party has joined Donald Trump in his dangerous claims of widespread voter fraud in Pennsylvania,” spokesman Jeff Sheridan told the Morning Call, accusing the GOP of “trying to cause chaos and disruption.”

The suit was filed in Federal District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania against the Keystone State’s Secretary of State Pedro A. Cortes, a Democrat.

Read the full complaint below:

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. We all know what they really want. They want “us” to go monitor “them.”

  2. Desperate much?

  3. Maybe I’m just missing something, but how is the First Amendment involved? They are still free to say anything they want. They’re even free to say whatever they want in whatever county they want. They’re just not free to intimidate voters.

  4. Keep up the good work on DEM GOTV .
    Providing new incentives every day
    First Brewer and the "hispanics don’t vote "
    now this?
    A bigger collection of clueless morons has never been assembled in one location .
    The underpants gnomes of political stratergy

    1. Poll Watchers
    2. ???
    3. Switch all those swing voters .

    It would be funny if it wasn’t so pathetic

Continue the discussion at

181 more replies


Avatar for jw1 Avatar for mattinpa Avatar for jdkahler Avatar for cervantes Avatar for vonq Avatar for steviedee111 Avatar for meow2u3 Avatar for baffie2 Avatar for emjayay Avatar for maxaroo Avatar for ignoreland Avatar for cincypix Avatar for thunderclapnewman Avatar for tena Avatar for antisachetdethe Avatar for bkmn Avatar for kwd101 Avatar for pmaroneyb Avatar for edhedh Avatar for erratum Avatar for katscherger Avatar for edys Avatar for lisaport Avatar for kumquat16

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: