Lawyers For Kim Davis: Yeah, That Peru Prayer Rally Photo Was Fake After All

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

The conservative, Christian law firm representing defiant Kentucky clerk Kim Davis admitted late Monday that a photo it circulated of a Peruvian prayer rally in solidarity with its client was actually a photo of another event entirely.

Liberty Counsel insisted in a press release that Peruvians still prayed for the Rowan County clerk, though.

The mistaken photo was shown Friday at the Values Voter Summit when Davis was presented with a “Cost of Discipleship Award.” Davis was jailed recently for contempt of court after refusing a judge’s order to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The photo’s caption explained it was of a “Lima, Peru prayer rally for Kim Davis.”

But ThinkProgress presented evidence Monday that the prayer gathering never actually happened, prompting the law firm, Liberty Counsel, to issue a press release defending the veracity of the photo.

The law firm initially copped to one mistake. While the caption shown at the Values Voter Summit said the photo was taken in Lima, Liberty Counsel said in its Monday press release the photo actually was taken at a soccer stadium in Northern Peru.

Liberty Counsel corrected a few more mistakes about the prayer rally in a second press release.

“It now appears that while prayer meetings did occur throughout Peru, the photograph presented to Mat Staver was an honest mistake and was of a different Christian assembly in a soccer field,” the release read.

Liberty Counsel attributed the photo and the story of the prayer rally to Julio Rosas, a Peruvian congressman who’s worked with the law firm’s founder, Mat Staver, in the past. Liberty Counsel said in its prior press release that Rosas organized the rally for Davis on Sept. 13, even though he wasn’t physically present in Peru to witness it that day, and had confirmed the rally’s existence three times.

“As the statement says, we have known Cong. Rosas for a long time and he is a trusted source,” Staver wrote Tuesday afternoon in an email to TPM. “We relied on the information he provided, but the photo he was provided while he was in the US was not accurate.

Still, Liberty Counsel argued that the incident was a simple mix-up and not an attempt to inflate the impact of Davis’ story.

“We have no reason to puff the Kim Davis story,” Staver said in the press release. “Her name has become known around the world. The people in Peru were very much aware of Kim Davis because her story was broadcast on a variety of media. However, the photograph was an honest mistake.”

This post has been updated.

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for darcy darcy says:

    In defense of lawyers, and I’ve had the misfortune of needing their “services” too often, the good ones are worth their weight in gold and the rest not so much.

  2. Avatar for mantan mantan says:

    The Discipleship has struck a Peruvian iceberg!!! Who could have guessed? Look for Kim to sing her big hit, “My Hate Will Go On”…

  3. They gotta be delusional if they ever seriously believed it.

  4. Avatar for korvu korvu says:

    Fuckers ought to be disbarred.

  5. Avatar for delmar delmar says:

    “It now appears that while prayer meetings did occur throughout Peru, the photograph presented to Mat Staver was an honest mistake and was of a different Christian assembly in a soccer field,” the release read.

    And for some reason, we just couldn’t find a single actual photo from any of all those other Peruvian prayer meetings in support of Kim Davis, so we just decided to use this one, because it’s just like all the others.

    Something tells me there is not a single Peruvian who knows about Kim Davis.

Continue the discussion at

43 more replies


Avatar for fgs Avatar for richardinjax Avatar for clunkertruck Avatar for chammy Avatar for dave_adams Avatar for voreason Avatar for crackerjack Avatar for labman57 Avatar for tomdibble Avatar for Lacuna-Synecdoche Avatar for mantan Avatar for sherlock1 Avatar for phillydave Avatar for ralph_vonholst Avatar for addicted4444 Avatar for candirue Avatar for robcat2075 Avatar for freewayblogger Avatar for ghamiltonsq Avatar for exspectator Avatar for dickweed Avatar for edhedh Avatar for delmar Avatar for tandude

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: