With Primary Decided, Stage Is Set For Wisconsin Supreme Court Barnburner

Liberal Janet Protasiewicz and conservative Dan Kelly garnered the most primary votes.
Courtesy: janetforjustice.com / wicourts.gov.
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

One liberal and one conservative won the most votes Tuesday, setting up a massively significant Wisconsin Supreme Court general election on April 4.

Milwaukee County Judge Janet Protasiewicz and former state Supreme Court Justice Dan Kelly — ideological opposites on many hot-button issues — will square off in an election that could alter the state’s trajectory. If Protasiewicz wins, liberals will retake the court’s majority for the first time in nearly 15 years. 

Protasiewicz was the first to make it through to the general election; the Associated Press called her primary night win well under an hour after polls closed.

Kelly snatched second place after duking it out with Waukesha County Judge Jennifer Dorow, who placed a close third. Dane County Judge Everett Mitchell, the other liberal in the race, trailed in fourth. Democrats considered Dorow the stronger general election opponent, especially in light of Kelly’s 10-point-plus loss to Jill Karofsky in 2020.

Dynamics between the two conservatives became acrimonious at the tail-end of the race, as Kelly refused to say if he’d endorse Dorow, should she best him in the primary. 

The already eye-poppingly expensive race will only become more so. This bench is expected to face cases on the state’s draconian abortion ban, aggressively gerrymandered maps and any potential disputes stemming from the 2024 election.

Protasiewicz has campaigned on protecting abortion access and called the Republican-passed legislative and congressional maps “rigged.” 

Kelly was revealed last week to have been paid $120,000 by Republicans to advise on the fake electors scheme in Wisconsin, a key gambit in Donald Trump’s attempts to overturn the 2020 election. He’s been on the Republican National Committee’s payroll as recently as December.

The Wisconsin Supreme Court narrowly dismissed Trump’s election lawsuit in 2020 — a decision that prompted Kelly to call Supreme Court Justice Brian Hagedorn, the only conservative who joined the liberals, “supremely unreliable.”  

Kelly has also accused groups supporting abortion access of doing so “to preserve sexual libertinism,” participated in a Big Lie-fueled “election integrity” tour and expressed support for the late Antonin Scalia’s dissent in Obergefell v. Hodges.

Notable Replies

  1. Two words (at least): Ben Wikler.

  2. Half way to a Wisconsin Supreme Court that ends extreme and undemocratic gerrymandering and letting voters choose members of the state legislature and the US House instead of GOP politicians.

  3. Let’s go Badgers!

  4. It wasn’t that long ago that Shirley Abrahamson was Chief Justice. Wisconsin can do so much better than it is doing now!

  5. Setting aside political parties, Protasiewicz is clearly the best person for the job. This isn’t the time for radical conservatism.

    Conservatives have made a mess of America

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

41 more replies

Participants

Avatar for dr_coyote Avatar for jackson_frisell Avatar for robaruba Avatar for ncsteve Avatar for globalguy Avatar for irasdad Avatar for harry_r_sohl Avatar for generalsternwood Avatar for moreyampersand Avatar for fiftygigs Avatar for hornblower Avatar for jonney_5 Avatar for chicago11 Avatar for ozziecat Avatar for nobiru Avatar for dedwords Avatar for khyber900 Avatar for iconoclast Avatar for prometheus_bic Avatar for demosthenes59 Avatar for euglena4056 Avatar for stevecoh1 Avatar for occamscoin Avatar for emiliano4

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: