Justice Breyer: Lawmakers Should ‘Think Long And Hard’ Before Expanding SCOTUS

on March 14, 2013 in Washington, DC.
Supreme Court Associate Justice Stephen Breyer awaits the start of a hearing on Capitol Hill March 14, 2013. (Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer on Tuesday cautioned that broad reforms like court expansion risk politicizing the high court.

The Associated Press reports that as he was giving a virtual lecture to Harvard Law School students and alumni, Breyer said his speech aimed to “make those whose initial instincts may favor important structural change or other similar institutional changes — such as forms of court-packing — think long and hard before they embody those changes in law.”

The justice argued that despite the Supreme Court having a conservative majority, it was “wrong” to consider the high court to be “another political institution,” citing the its rulings against Louisiana’s abortion clinic restriction and ex-President Donald Trump’s attempt to kill the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program.

However, per the Harvard Crimson, Breyer conceded that it can be “difficult to separate what counts as the jurisprudential view from what counts as political philosophy,” which “in turn can shape views of policy.”

But despite Breyer’s arguments, SCOTUS and justice appointments have in fact become a fixture in partisan politics in recent years, arguably beginning when then-Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) stonewalled former President Barack Obama from filling late Justice Antonin Scalia’s seat and left it vacant until Trump entered office. Republicans proceeded to ram through three justice confirmations in four years, which also saw them completely abandon McConnell’s made up rule about keeping SCOTUS seats empty in an election year with the appointment of Amy Coney-Barrett last fall.

The GOP’s shenanigans have fueled calls among progressives and Democrats to add seats to the Supreme Court and implement other reforms to counter the conservative takeover of the court, and some have urged 82-year old Breyer, who was appointed by former President Bill Clinton, to retire during President Joe Biden’s term.

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Maybe what he is trying to tell us is that he knows Brett Kavanaugh liked to go to Matt Gaetz parties.

  2. I’m not a lawmaker, but I do vote for people who are. I’ve thought about it long, and hard.

    DO IT!!

  3. …broad reforms like court expansion risk politicizing the high court.

    Heavens! Next thing you know, he’ll be concerned about whether COVID could spread.

  4. Avatar for leeks leeks says:

    While “court packing” is something that needs cautious deliberation it can not be said that to increase the number of Justices would start a cycle of “court packing.” We are currently deep into a cycle of “court packing.” The Republicans started "packing the court when they refused to confirm a replacement for Scalia. That injustice needs to be corrected before there can be an end to this current cycle.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

177 more replies

Participants

Avatar for zandru Avatar for meri Avatar for cervantes Avatar for becca656 Avatar for cvilledem Avatar for arrendis Avatar for leeks Avatar for thunderclapnewman Avatar for tena Avatar for jwr12 Avatar for castor_troy Avatar for canyoncountry Avatar for greysea Avatar for seamus42 Avatar for karlwlewis Avatar for dougsanders Avatar for txlawyer Avatar for gargoyle Avatar for emiliano4 Avatar for kovie Avatar for LeeHarveyGriswold Avatar for Fire_Joni_Ernst Avatar for xcopy Avatar for geographyjones

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: