CBP Detains, Separates Bahamian Child From Family Evacuating Hurricane Dorian

People await evacuation by boat at the port in Great Abaco, Bahamas after Hurricane Dorian struck the islands. (Photo credit: BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

A Bahamian child is currently being detained in a Florida facility after immigration officials separated her from her family, who had sought refuge from the devastation of Hurricane Dorian.

The Miami Herald reported on Tuesday that after 12-year-old Kaytora Paul arrived at West Palm Beach with her godmother this weekend, U.S. Customs and Border Patrol agents separated the two and refused to let the girl’s aunt pick her up at the airport because neither of the women were her mother.

Then the agents sent her to His House Children’s Home, an HHS-run migrant detention center in Miami for unaccompanied minors, where she currently remains in custody.

The girl’s mother, Katty Paul, told the Herald that finding out about her daughter’s detention was when she “really lost everything.”

“I thought losing my house was devastating. Or having to relocate to a different island or country was devastating,” said Paul, who arrived in the U.S. several days after her daughter. “But when I found out that they got her, my baby, I mean, there are no words.”

In order to get her daughter back, Paul has to go through the lengthy process of providing documented proof of their relationship — and she said she only has until September 26 to do it before she’s required to leave the country.

A CBP spokesperson told TPM in an emailed statement on Wednesday that the agency made “multiple attempts” to contact the girl’s family members but were “unsuccessful.”

“CBP exercises due diligence to guard against child exploitation and human smuggling during uncertainties created by natural disasters and emergencies,” the spokesperson said. “When encountering minors, there are legal requirements that CBP must follow that are in place to ensure the safety of the child.”

NBC News reported later on Wednesday that the Trump administration will deny Bahamian evacuees temporary protected status, preventing them from living in the U.S. while they wait for the situation in their hurricane-stricken home country to stabilize. It’s the same program the administration had tried to end for immigrants from Haiti, Sudan, Nicaragua and El Salvador last year before President Donald Trump’s infamous “shithole” comment torpedoed the attempt in court.

This story has been updated to include CBP’s response to TPM and the Trump administration’s TPS policy on Bahamian evacuees.

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for ghost ghost says:

    So many souless people …

    Did Trump somehow change them or were they always this cruel in their hearts?

  2. This is called using the excuse of potential child abuse by a close relative to commit actual child abuse by state apparatchiks.

  3. Amerika, go look in the mirror. We all look like trump now. But everyone knows about trump, even the quisling GOP, willing to trade 30 pieces of silver for the soul of the country. THEY are the real danger to the country now.

    Register people to vote. Get to the polls. Run for office. We’re better than the monsters at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.


  4. The only church Trump goes to is Our Lady of Perpetual Cruelty.

  5. By the nature of its mission, CPB and ICE are naturally going to be recruitment magnets for the worst kind of people unless a deliberate effort to screen them out is made, and no such effort was made. Bigots, power-trippers, sadists, and worse will are mixed in with the “I just needed a job” people and they are all going to be looking to the top for cues about where the boundaries are.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

94 more replies


Avatar for ajm Avatar for ealleniii Avatar for sysprog Avatar for old_curmudgeon Avatar for thepsyker Avatar for irasdad Avatar for sandyh Avatar for callmeeric Avatar for sniffit Avatar for sonsofares Avatar for lastroth Avatar for mcstubbins Avatar for darrtown Avatar for tena Avatar for bankerpup Avatar for ljb860 Avatar for rickjones Avatar for susanintheoc Avatar for carolson Avatar for evave2 Avatar for c_stedman Avatar for rmga Avatar for jumboperch Avatar for Akimbo

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: