Judge Refuses To Release Butina From Jail And Scolds Both Sides

Mariia Butina, leader of a pro-gun organization, speaks on October 8, 2013 during a press conference in Moscow. - A 29-year-old Russian woman has been arrested for conspiring to influence US politics by cultivating t... Mariia Butina, leader of a pro-gun organization, speaks on October 8, 2013 during a press conference in Moscow. - A 29-year-old Russian woman has been arrested for conspiring to influence US politics by cultivating ties with political groups including the National Rifle Association, the powerful gun rights lobby. Mariia Butina, whose name is sometimes spelled Maria, was arrested in Washington on July 15, 2018 and appeared in court on July 16, the Justice Department said. (Photo by STR / AFP) (Photo credit should read STR/AFP/Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

A federal judge in Washington, D.C., Monday denied the request of alleged Russian agent Mariia Butina to be released from jail before her trial.

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan said at a hearing Monday that she agreed with the conclusions previously reached by a magistrate judge that Butina was a flight risk, due to the serious nature of her crime, her lack of connections to the United States and the fact that Russia does not have an extradition treaty with the United States.

Chutkan also issued a gag order in the case, scolding Butina attorney Robert Driscoll for his public comments about the case and saying he had “crossed the line.”

There comes a point, Chutkan said, where you defend your client in court, and “not on the public airways.”

At the same time, Chutkan scolded prosecutors for making “rather salacious” allegations about the defendant offering to trade sex for an employment position. The government largely walked back those allegations in a new filing Friday. Chutkan said it took her a few minutes to look at Butina’s text messages about sex and tell they were a joke. “I am concerned” that someone at the Justice Department would look at those messages and make that allegation, Chutkan said in court.

“Mr. Driscoll is right” Chutkan said, that the “notorious” allegations “damaged [Butina’s] reputation.”

Butina is charged with conspiracy and acting as a foreign agent without properly registering. According to the government’s court filings and independent reporting, she sought to make connections with influential members of the Republican Party, particularly through the National Rifle Association, in order to improve U.S. relations with Russia.

She has pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Driscoll also got a tongue lashing from the judge for submitting videos Monday morning to go along with Butina’s request to be released from jail. The videos, according to the judge, were tapes of birthday greetings from Butina’s parents for her “boyfriend” — known as Person 1 in the court docs, but reportedly GOP operative Paul Erickson — as well as a video of Butina and Erikson lip-synching  the theme from the Disney classic “Beauty and the Beast.”

“I am not on sure what on earth their relevance is,”  Chutkan said of videos, while chiding Driscoll for submitting them mere hours before the hearing.

Lawyers for Butina have mounted a blistering defense, accusing prosecutors of wrongfully smearing her as a seductress, mischaracterizing the evidence against her, and misrepresenting benign conduct as criminal.

The defense counsel’s fiery rhetoric in their pleadings also got a call-out from Chutkan, who called the language “inflammatory” and “quite descriptive.”

The judge said she was “not sure if the language is designed” to influence her thinking about the case, hinting that here too, Driscoll is speaking to the press rather than to the court.

Correction: Due to an editing error, the judge was initially misidentified in this post. We regret the error.

Latest Muckraker

Notable Replies

  1. There is nothing benign about working with the NRA to funnel Russian money to Republican candidates and office holders.

    Hell, there’s nothing benign about working with the NRA, period.

  2. Howell said it took her a few minutes to look at Butina’s text messages about sex and tell they were a joke.

    Like I said, in the other thread…

    In any event, a good decision all around - don’t let her skip to Mother Russia, and make the lawyers STFU.

  3. It would appear that the Red Sparrow walk-back was not the guilt-clearing statement that some made it out to be…

  4. a video of Butina and Erikson lip-synching the theme from the Disney classic “Beauty and the Beast.”

    Driscoll thought a video of them lip-synching would impress the court? Every attorney worth his salt knows courts aren’t swayed by anything less than karaoke.

    Had he presented a video of Paul and Mariia actually crooning I’m sure the judge would’ve immediately released Butina on her own recognizance; had they performed it in costume in front of a bar full of drunken Russians she probably would’ve garnered an apology and, possibly, cab fare to the Russian Embassy as well.

    Some people just don’t understand the legal system.

  5. Avatar for tsp tsp says:

    (ahem) That happened to be a video of them on RT’s Lip-syncking vit de Czars.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

16 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for scavok Avatar for richardinjax Avatar for Lacuna-Synecdoche Avatar for ottnott Avatar for candirue Avatar for schmed Avatar for texastwostep Avatar for misterneutron Avatar for tsp Avatar for tiowally Avatar for asturcot Avatar for canadachris Avatar for brian512 Avatar for alana Avatar for timbo Avatar for dannydorko Avatar for tompaine73 Avatar for captaintangent Avatar for justruss Avatar for rascal_crone

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: