5 Points From The Initial Report Of The Alleged Attempted Lynching In Indiana

BLOOMINGTON, INDIANA, UNITED STATES - 2020/07/10: Vauhxx Booker, who was attacked during an alleged attempted lynching on the 4th of July at Monroe Lake, speaks during a press conference at Peoples Park in Bloomington.Booker, and his attorney are asking for a grand jury trial to investigate the assault. (Photo by Jeremy Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)
BLOOMINGTON, INDIANA, UNITED STATES - 2020/07/10: Vauhxx Booker, who was attacked during an alleged attempted lynching on the 4th of July at Monroe Lake, speaks during a press conference at Peoples Park in Bloomingto... BLOOMINGTON, INDIANA, UNITED STATES - 2020/07/10: Vauhxx Booker, who was attacked during an alleged attempted lynching on the 4th of July at Monroe Lake, speaks during a press conference at Peoples Park in Bloomington. Booker, and his attorney are asking for a grand jury trial to investigate the assault. (Photo by Jeremy Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

The report released Thursday by the law enforcement arm of Indiana’s Department of Natural Resources is a muddied picture of a July 4 altercation in the woods replete with alcohol, fuzzy property lines and conflicting stories. 

Friends of Vauhxx Booker, who has said that he was the victim of an unprovoked attack and alleged lynching, told officers that Booker was trying to play peacemaker after a drunk and rowdy group of revelers repeatedly yelled “white power.” They described the ensuing fight as a ganging up on Booker, who is Black, and recounted calls for a “noose” and to “break his arm.”

The revelers told officers a very different story, that Booker got aggressive when they told him he was on private property, and that a fight broke out when he invaded the personal space of one of the women in the group. They described Booker as throwing the lion’s share of the punches. 

The report has now been handed over to the Monroe County prosecutor to decide whether to pursue charges. The FBI is also investigating the possible hate crime. Here are the highlights from the report:

Confederate Hat 

A key point in the story is what Sean Purdy, one of the revelers, was wearing — a cowboy hat with a Confederate flag print. Multiple witnesses said that the hat upset Booker, when he first came across the group. 

Alcohol

By their own admission, most of the revelers were fairly drunk by the time they encountered Booker and his friends. One of them, Jerry “Bubba” Cox, told officers that he had consumed a “12 pack” that day and “had a good buzz.” 

Property Line

Much of the initial conversation and belligerence centered on the property line between the private land owned by the family of one of the revelers and the public land surrounding the lake. Per officers who responded to the scene, the dividing line was not clearly marked.

More Alcohol

There are 10 mentions of beer in the 68-page document. Sabrina Cox, one of the revelers, said she drank 10 beers and was “intoxicated.” Some of the witnesses say that Booker gave Purdy a beer after their initial conversation about the private property. A responding officer described the partiers: “Their eyes were bloodshot, their speech was slurred, and they had difficulty making conversation with me.” 

Charges For All

The officers found grounds to potentially charge nearly everyone involved. Booker is listed with possible misdemeanor battery charges, as well as misdemeanor criminal trespass along with friend Ian Watkins. Of the other group, Cox is listed with a couple misdemeanor battery charges, and Purdy with misdemeanor battery and felony criminal confinement for pinning Booker down by a tree.

Latest Five Points

Notable Replies

  1. Lock ‘em up!

  2. “Ah, alcohol; the cause of and the solution to all our problems!” – H. Simpson

  3. Where do they relieve themselves after consuming 10 or 12 beers?

    The lake?

    Shouldn’t there be some environmental protection charges, as well?

  4. Avatar for krux krux says:

    The word “revelers”, used several times in the article to describe the drunk-off-their-asses/pro-confederacy/property rights group, tends to imply that crowd has unearned positive qualities.

  5. IN DNR bothsides it.

    I’d make a solid wager, however, that aspects of the DNR’s proposed report got fed back to the white guy’s legal team prior to publication. Just in time, in fact, for their legal team to proactively align with the DNR points before the alleged offenders issued a public statement 10 or so days after the incident occurred.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

14 more replies

Participants

Avatar for discobot Avatar for padfoot Avatar for epicurus Avatar for tigersharktoo Avatar for hychka Avatar for bboerner Avatar for kickbass Avatar for birdford Avatar for nycabj Avatar for dannydorko Avatar for freeulysses Avatar for krux Avatar for euglena4056 Avatar for tindalos Avatar for zillacop Avatar for jess11883 Avatar for 8franks Avatar for anon84323658

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: