Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
05.06.08 | 2:06 pm
Hillary the Shotslinger

Terry McAuliffe is on a roll today, telling MSNBC:

“She loves to sit, throw ’em back. So to me this is nothin’ new. We all hear about the story that she and John McCain actually had a shot contest, I think in the Ukraine or somewhere around the world. And she actually beat John McCain in a shot contest. She’s a girl from Illinois who likes to throw ’em down with the rest of us.”

Watch the video here.

05.06.08 | 2:00 pm
Sigh …

From TPM Reader AB …

It’s interesting that you’re batting around this topic today. Because I just got off the phone with my Dad, who’s an 80 y.o. died-in-the-wool Democratic and would vote for Hillary in a second (but as a former upstate Scranton, Pa. area first generation Polish immigrant probably won’t ever vote for Obama.

I was complaining about what it’s costing to fill the gas tank, and he started on about how Hillary and McCain want to do something about it by “getting rid of that tax” while “the black guy” is against that.

I said, simply and in terms he could understand:

“If the government knocks off those 18 cents a gallon, what do you think the oil companies are going do? They’re going to raise the price of gas by 18 cents and you’ll be paying exactly the same amount. Until September when even McCain and Hillary say they’ll put the tax back on, and you’ll end up paying even more than before. It’s not gas tax relief for you, it’s a give-away to the oil companies”.

I think that really struck him as something he never actually considered, because he switched to the old “well, we’ve got to get all of those politicians out of the oil companies’ back pockets, . . . ”

I really don’t understand why the Obama campaign isn’t slamming this message hard.

Ask Hillary and McCain how they know the oil companies won’t raise their prices, and ask them and the press to try to get the oil companies on record promising not to do so. They can’t do it. They have no answer. That’s the response.

05.06.08 | 12:40 pm
Annals of Friggin’ Obvious Messaging

From TPM Reader JW …

In response to Kurtz’s citation of GP (and as an avid Obama supporter), I have to lay a good deal of the blame for not making the basic, easily understandable, factually accurate assertion that Hillary’s plan WON’T SAVE ANYONE ANY MONEY squarely at the feet of the Obama campaign and its surrogates. I flipped around several cable news stations yesterday, and heard at least a half dozen different “Obama supporters” lambaste Hillary’s plan on the basis of its disingenuousness (including Clinton’s “double dipping” with the windfall profits tax that will never be signed into law by this Administration), it’s “gimmickry,” its short-term only impact, and its INSUFFICIENT help to the common man (i.e. “only $0.30 a day”). Only AFTER laying out all those (admittedly valid) rationales did I ever hear an Obama surrogate, if they still had time to do so, make the point that a tax reduction would not be passed on to the consumer at the pump. It seems to me like this should have been the FIRST thing the Obama camp hit, from day one, with supportive emphasis on all the rest of the absolutely on-target reasons that this is a shameless, and ineffectual, pander by Clinton. I applaud my candidate for hitting back hard on this ridiculous “idea,” but I wish they would have realized earlier how to hammer on it more effectively. Perhaps then the MSM talking heads would have focused on that, rather than the dearth of credible economists who support the plan.

Late Update: TPM Reader DG responds …

JW is exaggerating. I saw an Obama ad on the TPM Election Central website that made exactly the point JW is hitting on, that the consumer won’t benefit from the tax holiday. Maybe Obama surrogates could play that up more on TV, but the point isn’t being ignored entirely by the campaign.

I think I’m with JW on this one though. Yes, the point is out there somewhere in the back and forth. But most of what I’m hearing from the Obama campaign is some version of it’s not responsible and it’s not even very much money. Both are true. But ‘it won’t save you any money’ is much more straightforward and has the added advantage, according to virtually every economist, of being true.

05.06.08 | 11:56 am
Zogby Doubles Down

According to Zogby, Obama is expanding his lead (51%-37%) in North Carolina and may even be jumping ahead in Indiana. His number for today in Indiana is Obama leading 45%-43%. But he says that Monday night’s single total actually had him beating Clinton 47%-41%, which would suggest possible late movement into an actual lead. But he’s really still an outlier, even though a couple late polls yesterday had only a five point margin for Hillary. (SurveyUSA had a 12 point margin for Hillary.)

If Zogby has this one nailed there will be lots of crowing. But given his record this year I’ll believe it when I see it.

I fondly remember my own personal Zogby epiphany moment. I don’t recall who my interlocutor was. But I told this person that the thing with Zogby was that he relatively frequently nailed final totals right on the nose, even if pretty frequently his numbers were way off. To which my friend very wisely responded, “Josh, that means he sucks.” And I thought, “Hmmm, I guess that’s right.”

05.06.08 | 11:20 am
Flashback to 1992

Return with us now to the thrilling days of yesteryear, when a Clinton running for President not only thought economists mattered but touted their support for his economic plan in this TV ad:

05.06.08 | 11:00 am
Why The Sudden Focus on Reality?

TPM Reader YF finds this whole gas tax debate unsettling:

I have to say that I am really very surprised by the oddly rational, and near universal, condemnation of Hillary’s gas tax plan by the mainstream media. It’s been a long time since the TV talking heads were so focused on reality and for just a moment I actually got my hopes up that they might begin working their seriously atrophied logic and reason muscles and apply this new rigor to, say, the situation in Iraq. Ok- I won’t hold my breath . . .

And how pathetic is the Clinton campaign that they cannot come up with the name of just one freakin’ economist to throw back at the talking heads when they ask their favorite question of the moment “Just name one economist that agrees with the gas tax holiday.” You can’t find some hack Econ prof at East Jesus State University that will go on the record in favor? Are you kidding me? And this is the “grown up” campaign that is ready to roll on “day one”? I wouldn’t hire these people to wash my car.

Also- please note that no one on television seems to be mentioning that the gas tax plan is also favored by a little known individual by the name of John McCain. You’d think, watching the teevee, that Hillary is the only person favoring this notion . . . .

Late Update: TPM Reader GP takes it one step farther:

Something else that nobody on television seems to be mentioning is that Hillary’s plan WON’T CHANGE the price of gas. This is a key point. Now, I don’t want to totally pile onto the media because at least they are somewhat challenging her on this which is more than I expect, but when they keep asking “Can you name one economist that supports your plan?”, the Clinton campaign keeps firing back with “I don’t care about economists, I care about the people and this will save them money, which might not seem like a big deal to you…”, etc, etc.

The media is allowing the Clinton campaign to frame the narrative as “Clinton’s proposal will save the common man money, and that’s all that matters.”

But it WON’T save them money. That’s the point people should be making. It’s not just that economists think it’s an overall bad plan. They are saying that it won’t even do what you say it’s going to do!

If her plan was simply a matter of “saving the common man money” at the expense “ignoring long-term advice from economists”, she might even have a point. It might actually be a GOOD idea to help the average American save a few cents even if overall the plan isn’t a great idea.

But her plan won’t do what she says it will. It won’t save the average American money. At all.

Why doesn’t the media say THAT?

05.06.08 | 10:29 am
Today’s Must Read

Looks like Bush Administration plans to time the Gitmo trials for maximum 2008 Election Day impact have gone awry.

05.06.08 | 10:04 am
Hillary’s War on Economists

Top Hillary surrogate Sen. Robert Menendez (D-NJ) was on MSNBC this morning defending her gas tax holiday: “Thank God that we don’t have economists making necessarily public policy . . .”



Late Update
: Sen. Menendez has issued a clarification of his remarks.

05.06.08 | 9:50 am
Turn Out the Lights, The Party’s Over

Dana Milbank, on the extended twilight of the Bush Presidency.

05.05.08 | 9:19 pm
Clinton To Put Gravity Under Scrutiny

What is Hillary talking about? She’s going to break up the OPEC oil cartel? Because we have such a strong hand to play now with the OPEC member states? And isn’t the main issue here a matter of rising demand, principally for rapidly expanding economies in Asia, not monopoly pricing?

Hillary is certainly not the first candidate to bash the oil producing states or oil companies around election time. And the polls seem to show it’s working for her. But I’m concerned about the widening gap between reality and her campaign trail statements. First with the pledge to obliterate Iran if they attack Israel, then the rebellion against economists and now this.

Where are we going here?