Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
07.09.08 | 6:57 pm
Kennedy Returns

Sen. Teddy Kennedy (D-MA) returns to cheers on the senate floor, July 9th, 2008, his first appearance since being diagnosed with a malignant brain tumor on May 20th, 2008 …

07.09.08 | 5:12 pm
TPMtv: McCain’s Absolute Disgrace

Fresh from the airwaves, we hit the video vault to find out just why John McCain believes Social Security is an “absolute disgrace” (including special new debamboozling video to help you not be spun by the McCain camp’s damage control …)

High-res version at Veracifier.com.

07.09.08 | 3:50 pm
McCain: Don’t Get All Grammary on Me!

Okay, when last we checked in on the McCain Social Security is an “absolute disgrace” front, we asked you let us know if any journalist got a chance to put the question to McCain. And TPM Reader DB just flagged for me the fact that ABC’s Jake Tapper managed to get an answer.

Jake runs through the play-by-play to this point and then puts the question to McCain spokesman Brian Rogers.

Remember, here’s the quote.

“Americans have got to understand that. Americans have got to understand that we are paying present-day retirees with the taxes paid by young workers in America today. And that’s a disgrace. It’s an absolute disgrace and it’s got to be fixed.”

And here’s the video …

Now, the meaning of the words are very clear. He’s saying that the fact that Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system is an “absolute disgrace.”

And here’s the explanation from McCain’s guy Rogers, as elicited by Tapper …

McCain spox Brian Rogers says that “the disgrace is our failure to fix the long-run imbalance in Social Security — a failure of leadership evidenced by our willingness to kick to problem to the next generation of leaders. He’s also describing the looming and increasing demographic pressures confronting the Social Security system and Washington’s utter failure to address it.”

Now, this goes against the plain meaning of the words. But everybody has words come out the wrong way sometimes, or they say things they don’t really quite mean. IN other words, if it’s just tripping over your words, who cares. But digital video recording is a wonderful thing. And that’s why we can know pretty clearly that Rogers’ explanation is bogus and that this is precisely what McCain meant.

The townhall meeting where McCain said Social Security was “an absolute disgrace” was on Monday in Denver. Just yesterday McCain went on CNN and said more or less exactly the same thing on CNN.

In response to a question from CNN’s John Roberts, McCain said, “Let’s describe it [i.e. Social Security] for what it is. They pay their taxes and right now their taxes are going to pay the retirement of present-day retirees. That’s why it’s broken, that’s why we can fix it.”

He doesn’t use the flamethrower language of “absolute disgrace” but he says very clearly that what’s wrong with Social Security — “why it’s broken” — is the way it was designed to work and has worked for almost 80 years, because it’s a pay-as-you-go system, “pay their taxes and right now their taxes are going to pay the retirement of present-day retirees.” In other words, there’s no question that John McCain thinks that the problem with Social Security is the way it was designed at the very beginning, the way it was always designed to work. Sometimes he just uses more flowery language than others.

07.09.08 | 3:10 pm
FISA Passes Senate

The final vote was a rout: 69-28.

No surprises here. Just the weight of disappointment.

Late Update: Worth noting that Hillary voted against the bill, while Obama –as we’ve noted here before — changed positions on telecom immunity and voted for the bill.

07.09.08 | 3:10 pm
Sneak Peak

TPMtv now has its own blog, with all our video clips for the day, as well as the blog stylings of TPMtv producer/editor Ben Craw.

07.09.08 | 3:05 pm
No Appeasing Social Security

I’m very interested to see if anyone asks McCain about his statement that Social Security is an “absolute disgrace.” If you see him asked, let us know.

07.09.08 | 3:03 pm
Languid

Has excessive media fluffing robbed John McCain of his hard edge?

A very interesting and perceptive analysis from TPM Reader DB …

My own attempt at a GUT of McCain’s general lousiness as a stump speaker–in which I attempt to unify the separate fields of flip-flopping, Social Security trashing, and casual jokes about bombing or otherwise killing foreigners–goes as follows: It’s the media’s fault.

Let me explain. As is obvious, the media has been giving McCain a free pass on everything. It always has. The reason is that the media likes McCain. Again, it always has. It likes his status as a former POW. It likes the fact that he provides reporters with unlimited access. It likes the fact that he has always been a very quotable maverick.

So the media has never held McCain accountable for what he says. Gaffes are overlooked, factual misstatements are glossed over, and inconsistencies are forgiven. This has always been true of the way the media has treated McCain.

But what has been the obvious consequence of this? It is simply that McCain has never had to learn the self-discipline that other successful politicians learn and deeply internalize very early in their careers. I know some successful politicians and have worked closely with one of them for many years. These individuals were able to progress in their careers precisely because the careful scrutiny given them by the media taught them never to speak before thinking, always to be right about their facts, and always to consider the long-term consequences of anything they might say in public.

Because the media treated him as an exception to its normal rules, McCain simply never developed these habits of careful thought, analysis, and speech. And now he is paying the price. With the current pervasiveness of video coverage of everything he says, he is blithely creating one Democratic attack ad after another against him. In these ads, he serves as both the director and the star. But behind the scenes there is always the producer. In this case, the producer is the media.

In these past few months, we Democrats have been gnashing our teeth over the things the media has let McCain get away with. As it happens, we Democrats have been torturing ourselves for no reason. For by the very act of constantly applying a double standard to try to help McCain, the media has damaged him beyond repair.

I am willing to bet that, having never had to learn these basic candidate skills, McCain will continue to damage himself in the coming months as he makes one after another self-destructive statement on the record. He will thereby do our work for us.

Perhaps the lesson is this: those whom the media gods wish to destroy, first they fail to hold accountable.

07.09.08 | 3:01 pm
Wishin’ and Hopin’

ABC: McCain setting the stage for comeback leading to triumphant presidential glory.

07.09.08 | 2:36 pm
Are They Really Talking About the Same Hearing?

Congressional Quarterly:

State Department Official Downplays Iran’s Strategic Influence

On the same day Iran test-fired missiles in a show of force in the Persian Gulf, the Bush administration Wednesday sought to downplay the country’s power and influence.

“For its part, Tehran seems to relish heightening concerns by promoting the illusion that Iran is on the ascendance,” Undersecretary of State William Burns said in prepared testimony for the House Foreign Affairs Committee. “However, Iran is not 10 feet tall, nor is it even the dominant regional actor.

CNN:

Leading diplomat calls Iran a top concern for U.S.

Iran is as serious a problem as any the U.S. faces today, top State Department official William Burns said Wednesday, hours after the Islamic republic test-fired a long-range missile.

Burns, the undersecretary of state for political affairs, made the comments testifying before the House Foreign Affairs Committee.

07.09.08 | 2:07 pm
Fred-based GUTMC

TPM Reader RM gives us his GUTMC with Fred Thompson in the mix …

I’ve been saying for months that McCain has a bad case of Republican entitlement. He’s as bad as Fred Thompson was in the sense that the idea that you actually have to RUN for president – like, actually ask people to vote for you – not only befuddles but vaguely offends him. I’m sure he made his real decision to run well before the 2006 elections, and he thought it was just going to be a cakewalk.

That leads to the next facet of my GUTMC: McCain can prattle on about his supposed experience and Obama’s supposed lack, but if we’re talking about the states of their campaigns, he has no more experience running for president than Obama does – much less in fact, if you count Obama’s tough primary fight. McCain is a long-term senator, but how many big-deal speeches has he ever given on national TV? Has he ever had reporters (some of them “unfriendly”) following him around for this long? He’s used to gearing up for an hour every other week or so on Meet the Press and maybe having a few “helpful” reporters around to write down “what he meant” rather than what he said, but he was not and is not prepared to have his exact words broadcast nationwide every day.

I would speculate that it’s a generational/technological thing, but that could be interpreted as a slap at McCain’s age, and that would make McCain and Bob Schieffer cry, so it’s on the list of things you can’t say about McCain. So I have absolutely no idea why it is.