Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
07.09.08 | 1:52 pm
Beliefs

From The News & Observer …

L.F. Eason III gave up the only job he’d ever had rather than lower a flag to honor former U.S. Sen. Jesse Helms.

Eason, a 29-year veteran of the state Department of Agriculture, instructed his staff at a small Raleigh lab not to fly the U.S. or North Carolina flags at half-staff Monday, as called for in a directive to all state agencies by Gov. Mike Easley.

When a superior ordered the lab to follow the directive, Eason decided to retire rather than pay tribute to Helms. After several hours’ delay, one of Eason’s employees hung the flags at half-staff.

…

In a string of e-mail messages with his superiors, Eason was told he could either lower the flags or retire effective immediately.

Though he’s only 51, Eason chose to retire, although he pleaded several times to be allowed to stay at the lab. Eason, who had worked for the Agriculture Department since graduating from college, was paid $65,235 a year as the laboratory manager.

07.09.08 | 1:20 pm
So Formulaic

TPM Reader MO actually boils it down to a formula …

MGUT: Age + Over-handling = Cringe

My thoughts on the gauntlet that Josh just threw down. I say this as someone who would be classified as a grudgingly McCain admirer back in ’00 (as a combination of Clinton fatigue and a visceral distaste for Bush before it was cool):

The way McCain looks on the stump now reminds me of how my older relatives looked after I came back from college. Before I left, they were the people I always knew. When I got back, the changes that age produces were glaringly clear. As Josh says, a lot happens between 64 and 71. Furthermore, let’s compare McCain and Reagan – the last national politician running for office at an advanced age. McCain’s charisma has been based on energy and pugnaciousness. Reagan was always avuncular. McCain doesn’t do avuncular. And, of course, Reagan in ’80 was younger than McCain is now. The Reagan of ’84 was given a huge benefit of the doubt with regards to age because of incumbency.

Also, clearly, McCain is being over-handled in the way that reminds me of the Gore of ’00. In general, the more times people give you advice about your personal mannerisms, the less you come across as natural. That’s what people mean by WJC and Obama (and GWB, alas) being natural politicians.

So, I don’t think it has anything to do with the topics he’s covering. Sure, better speech writing would help to steer clear of landmines (here’s a hint: no jokes and no sarcasm!).

07.09.08 | 1:04 pm
The March of Time

TPM Election Central has the new DNC web ad hitting McCain on his Iraq flip-flops, particularly on his many and varied projections for when U.S. troops can come home.

07.09.08 | 1:01 pm
Hmmmm

TPM Reader KB on the Grand Unified Theory of McCain Crappiness (GUTMC — ‘Gutmuck’) …

I don’t think it’s any great mystery. Two things to keep in mind about McCain. One is that he was built for the New Hampshire primary of small groups, town halls, shaking hands and back-slapping on the media caravan. He simply does not fill the grand stage set-pieces of a general election. It seems to swallow him up. He does not paint in large graceful strokes the way Obama does. He is a pointillist. Second, if you recall the 2000 race, McCain was focused on fighting special interests, pork, and money in politics. National security was not a huge part of that primary conversation. His shtick was radically altered by 9/11, and it makes him a less appealing candidate, less happy-go-lucky, more conventional.

On the other hand, TPM Reader CB has a more 2008-specific analysis …

I think that you guys are on the right track with your theory about McCain’s poor stumping skills. In this cycle, he’s done so much pandering to try to win every interest group that he has lost any sense of conviction in what he believes in, outside of the need to stay in Iraq. That shows in his nervous laughter at his own jokes, his inability to really sell applause lines (and his getting caught off-guard when people applaud at other points), and his general lack of clarity about the terminology and specifics of his own proposals. The best speech I’ve seen him deliver this term was the one about how life is going to be in the victorious year of 2013, which he delivered with more conviction than he’s been able to give to telling us how we’re gonna get there.

He’s caught in a bind in that he needs to pander to his base to keep them from not showing up, but he also needs to reach out to independents, and the only way to do that is to be as vague as possible and promise as much as he can. That’s a tough sell, and the flop sweat is showing.

07.09.08 | 12:31 pm
Can You Help?

Today we’re trying to put together a unified theory of John McCain’s speech-making crappiness.

My initial theory was that if you look at the most outstanding instances of McCain’s awkward, cringe-inducing delivery they’re chiefly about domestic issues — economy and culture war stuff — that McCain doesn’t really care about. When he’s talking about the thing he’s jazzed up about — being right about the surge — his delivery is much more straightforward. A lot of this stuff is also packaged as attacks on Obama, as Ben pointed out.

But then David pointed out that the thing that really comes through to him about McCain’s delivery is a sense of entitlement. ‘I’m a Senator and I’m John McCain so just get on with it and make me president.”

Sort of like he’s not disciplined enough to learn to deliver his prefab lines or convincingly pretend he believes or cares about them. I hadn’t thought about it quite like this before. But this has the ring of truth to me. And perhaps the two meld together. McCain is big on Iraq and wants to talk about that. But the other stuff is mainly stuff he’s changed positions on anyway and doesn’t particularly care about. So he just goes through the motions.

Part of the reason may be that, despite a few of his claims to the contrary of late, I don’t think McCain has had many contested races in his political career. I don’t know exactly how his first election to the House went. But since he’s been in, it’s been pretty much smooth sailing. So a lot of this is just new to him.

This brings us back to the question of why McCain seems to suck so much this cycle whereas many people — even political opponents — thought he was solid as a candidate in 2000. And when I say ‘solid’, I mean a candidate whose public presentation was a big part of his attraction.

Inevitably, one part of the explanation is age. A lot happens between 63 and 72. But we also forget that much of the punch of McCain’s candidacy was his anger at key segments of the conservative establishment that attacked him for not toeing the line on issues important to the religious right and on tax policy. That was his punch. That got his goat up. But most of his snark lines this season are meant to kow-tow to those same folks. And in any case, his manner seems to say, why am I up here having to do this anyway? I’m John McCain. Who’s Barack Obama? Just make me president!

In any case, we’re still looking for the grand unified theory. So your thoughts are most welcome.

07.09.08 | 12:23 pm
Telecom Immunity Survives

Efforts to strip telecom immunity from the FISA bill just failed in the Senate. Not even close.

Late Update: The other two immunity-limiting amendments went down, too.

07.09.08 | 12:16 pm
“Absolute Disgrace”

Over at TPMCafe, Reed Hundt and Todd Gitlin decry McCain’s statement on Social Security–and the big question for both is why is it not getting any press?

07.09.08 | 12:14 pm
Wisecrackery

How does the AP treat the McCain joke about U.S. cigarette exports helping kill Iranians? Take a gander.

07.09.08 | 9:59 am
Quite a Statement

People say a lot of things about Social Security — a lot of it nonsense. But I haven’t heard something like this in a long time. John McCain says that Social Security, as originally conceived more than 70 years ago, is an “absolute disgrace.”

McCain told a townhall in Denver on Monday, “Americans have got to understand that. Americans have got to understand that we are paying present-day retirees with the taxes paid by young workers in America today. And that’s a disgrace. It’s an absolute disgrace and it’s got to be fixed.”

It’s really a disgrace? That’s how the system was designed to operate. And it’s served as financial bedrock of retirement security in this country for going on a century.

Late Update: Here’s the video…

07.09.08 | 9:52 am
Funny, As in Ha-Ha?

McCain and that trademark wit, this time taking a question about U.S. cigarette exports to Iran and turning it into another “Bomb Iran” moment: