Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
07.20.08 | 1:06 pm
Nice Try

Der Spiegel is standing by its story, its translation of what Maliki said.

And as Ben Smith aptly puts it, “It’s almost a convention of politics that when a politician says he was misquoted, but doesn’t detail the misquote or offer an alternative, he’s really saying he wishes he hadn’t said what he did, or that he needs to issue a pro-forma denial to please someone. The Iraqi Prime Minister’s vague denial seems to fall in that category. The fact that it arrived to the American press via CENTCOM, seems to support that.”

Matt Yglesias enumerates the reasons why this ‘walk back’ almost certainly falls into the latter category.

I’ll be watching to see whether the major papers continue to downplay the story. As Todd Gitlin notes, of the LA Times, Washington Post and NY Times, only the LAT put the story on the front page of their Sunday paper, though the Post had it as an ambiguous subhed on their front page Obama to War Zone story.

Notably and humorously, the Post editorial page appears to ignore the issue entirely.

Late Update: TPM Reader TB notes that weekend editorials are usually banked in advance and not written in response to the news of the preceeding day. In this case, the topic seems so central to the Post editors’ concerns that I thought they might take a crack at it. But TB makes a good and fair point.

07.20.08 | 12:43 pm
Election Central Sunday Roundup

Joe Lieberman says the very fact of Barack Obama’s upcoming visit to Iraq is proof that John McCain was right about the war and the surge. That and other political news in today’s Election Central Sunday Roundup.

07.20.08 | 11:43 am
Netroots Nation Sunday Blogging

San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom just introduced the concluding speaker here at Netroots Nation, Van Jones (two ridiculously good-looking guys, by the way). First time I’ve heard Newsom speak in person. He is indeed high-wattage, a policy wonk with a commanding stage presence and no end of charisma.

I’ll confess to having no idea who Van Jones was before last week, to the dismay of Andrew Golis, our deputy publisher, who’s been giving me no end of grief about that. For those of you who don’t know Van, he’s a Yale law grad who went on to found the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights in Oakland and is president of Green for All, which focuses on the unequal impacts of environmental degradation and climate change on the poor and disenfranchised.

Van arrived in Austin directly from an 8-day boat trip above the Arctic Circle with President Carter, Madeline Albright, Google’s Larry Page and other business and political leaders.

We’re going to be interviewing Van after his speech for TPMtv and will bring you that interview in the coming days.

07.20.08 | 11:15 am
Strange Bedfellows

Former Rep. Bob Barr (R-GA) showed up at Netroots Nation Saturday. Barr is the Libertarian candidate for President, but he’s still best known his over-the-top buffoonery during the Clinton impeachment saga, so his presence at a gathering of progressive Democrats had some of the same dissonance for me as seeing former Nixon counsel John Dean here. Times change. Maybe people do, too:

07.20.08 | 12:24 am
McCain Following Obama Meme

Here’s a campaign memo the Obama campaign released today about McCain following Obama on key foreign policy issues.

07.19.08 | 11:40 pm
Burying the Lede

Todd Gitlin notes the major papers’ rather reticent response to al Maliki’s Der Spiegel interview.

Todd wrote about three hours ago. As of just before midnight, as far as I can tell, the Post relegates the story to two paragraphs near the top of the paper’s story about Obama’s trip to Afghanistan. The article returns to the topic and provides some elaboration at the end. The Times gives the story almost the identical treatment — a short reference below the lede and returned to at the end of the piece.

The most credulous take I’ve seen so far is CNN’s which all but takes al Dabbagh’s ‘translation error’ explanation at face value.

Let me know what write-ups you’re seeing.

Late Update: I’m not sure precisely what it ‘means’. But in scanning around the major news sites I’m noticing that the better coverage of this story seems to be in the big papers’ blogs rather than in their front page stories — most of which are now out on the websites.

07.19.08 | 9:24 pm
Satire Eight Paces Up on Reality

I try to learn as much as I can about foreign cultures. And I’m learning that it’s very difficult to translate the nuances of the Arabic of Iraqi leaders when they’re speaking at variance with the talking points of the Bush White House. Language is a funny thing.

Along those lines, Dr. Ali al-Dabbagh, who the Times calls a spokesman for the Iraqi government, has released a statement saying that Prime Minister Maliki’s statement was “misunderstood and mistranslated” and “not conveyed accurately regarding the vision of Senator Barack Obama, U.S. presidential candidate, on the timeframe for U.S. forces withdrawal from Iraq.” But as the Times notes al Dabbagh did not specify what had been mistranslated.

Another interesting detail, noted by the Times. al-Dabbagh’s statement was released by CentCom. I do not know how often Iraqi government statements are released by CentCom.

In any case, here’s the rest of al-Dabbagh’s ‘clarification‘ …

Al-Dabbagh explained that Mr. al-Maliki confirmed the existence of an Iraqi vision stems from the reality with regard to Iraq security needs, as the positive developments of the security situation and the improvement witnessed in Iraqi cities makes the subject of U.S. forces’ withdrawal within prospects, horizons and timetables agreed upon and in the light of the continuing positive developments on the ground, and security that came within the Strategic Plan for Cooperation which was laid and developed by Mr. Maliki and President George Bush. The Iraqi government appreciates and values the efforts of all the friends who continue to support and supporting Iraqi security forces.

Al-Dabbagh underscored that the statements made by the head of the ministerial council (Prime Minister al-Maliki) or any of the members of the Iraqi government should not be understood as support to any U.S. presidential candidates.

Late Update: CNN plays it pretty straightforwardly as a mistranslation. Considerably more credulous than the Times.

07.19.08 | 7:51 pm
Not Many

TPM Reader RD has a good question some of the more pliant journos would do well to consider …

I take it from watching the news and reading the coverage of the campaign that Obama’s a big fat flip-flopper.

But it makes me wonder… At this point, is there any significant policy position that John McCain currently holds, on any topic, that he’s consistently held over the past 10 years? I mean that as a serious question. On economics, foreign policy, environmental policy, immigration, the role of evangelicals, you name it, it’s hard for me to pin down. I guess maybe on free trade?

07.19.08 | 6:39 pm
Pretty Weak

The McCain campaign has just come out with their response to Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al Maliki’s endorsement of Obama’s withdrawal plan. I think the clotted, dodging-the-issue nature of the response communicates very clearly the box this has placed the McCain camp in.

ARLINGTON, VA — Today, McCain 2008 Senior Foreign Policy Advisor Randy Scheunemann issued the following statement:

“The difference between John McCain and Barack Obama is that Barack Obama advocates an unconditional withdrawal that ignores the facts on the ground and the advice of our top military commanders. John McCain believes withdrawal must be based on conditions on the ground. Prime Minister Maliki has repeatedly affirmed the same view, and did so again today. Timing is not as important as whether we leave with victory and honor, which is of no apparent concern to Barack Obama. The fundamental truth remains that Senator McCain was right about the surge and Senator Obama was wrong. We would not be in the position to discuss a responsible withdrawal today if Senator Obama’s views had prevailed.”

Got that? Rolls off the tongue, doesn’t it? Set aside for the moment that McCain doesn’t believe in withdrawal at all. Scheunemann is betting on our believing that Maliki himself doesn’t know what he means.

Late Update: CNN has finally picked up the Maliki statement story. There’s some effort to play it down but there’s only so much you can. It will be particularly interesting to see the response of the jejune Washington Post OpEd page.

07.19.08 | 6:33 pm
Pelosi on TPMtv

Here’s the full TPMtv interview with Speaker Pelosi down at Netroots Nation (see this clip for Pelosi’s comments on President Bush’s “Time Horizon” for withdrawal from Iraq).

David presses Speaker Pelosi on FISA. Take a look …

To comment on this interview, click here.