I think I may have spoken too soon when I said that Palin didn’t have any Couric type moments in this debate. Here’s her discussion of the current financial crisis — note particularly her description of what is happening to the economy which starts about 45 seconds in …
Watching the debate I noticed that Biden referred to the Muslim population of Bosnia and Herzegovina as “Bosniaks“. This is actually the correct term, though in English people often say simply Bosnian Muslims. When he said it, the first thing I though was, I wonder how many right-wingers would jump on this as a gaffe on the model of candidate George W. Bush’s reference to ‘Grecians.’
I don’t know who else exposed their own ignorance by falling into this trap. But Cokie Roberts did.
Late Update: Here’s the video:
Late Update: Seems like Mona Charen and Joanna Weiss in the Boston Globe flubbed this one too. And, alas, the folks at RedState got burned too.
This may not have gotten a lot of attention. But in the post-debate commentary, Chris Matthews had Howard Fineman and Roger Simon on. And Simon started in on some aggressive tire-swinging. And as this was happening, a member of the crowd raised this anti-tire-swinging sign. Here you see it behind Matthews. But it was raised in Simon’s line of sight and he would be the logical target since he was the clear tire swinger on the panel …
(ed.note: Special thanks to TPM Reader MC for catching this critical moment.)
Late Update: For a brief primer on tire-swinging, see this post.
So Late It’s Morning Update: Here’s the text version of Simon’s tire-swinging.
Hmmm. Sarah Palin wants to give the Vice President more control over running the Senate? Here’s Sen. Kit Bond, one of Palin’s surrogates, saying maybe that’s not such a hot idea.
Greg Sargent: “Biden Won, Because He Made Forceful Case Against McCain“
So what did our top general in Afghanistan really say about an Afghanistan ‘Surge’? Not what Palin claimed. We have the details here.
The claim from this debate that is still sitting with me is this: Gov. Palin said that Sen. Biden supported McCain’s Iraq policies “pretty adamantly until this race.” Well, that’s complete nonsense. At least since 2004 they’ve been on completely different sides of this question. That was one of her biggest attack lines through the debate. And it’s completely false.
We’ll be hearing more about this.
Here’s the vid …
Another point that bears some notice. Biden got Palin to agree that she believes in full civil rights for gay couples. I think she’ll want another bite at that apple.
Here’s the vid. The key exchange comes at 1:40 in to the video …
We were just talking about why Palin did better tonight than she did in her interviews. I think it’s actually very simple. No follow ups. It’s not a criticism of Gwen Ifill. It wasn’t the format she was supposed to work with. But if you look at Palin’s interview trainwrecks things always got bad on the follow up — when the interviewer (Gibson or Couric) pressed her on the nebulous answer for some specifics, which she couldn’t provide. That’s the difference.
My global thought on this debate is that it helped the Obama-Biden ticket more than McCain-Palin’s. But I also think it probably helped stop some of the hemorrhaging and morale breakdown among hardcore Republicans.
One clear fact about this debate is that Palin didn’t have one of those stammering moments that we’ve seen especially in the Couric interview. She got the name of the top general in Afghanistan wrong. And she dug in on a clearly false claim when she said that Joe Biden had supported McCain’s Iraq policies up until this campaign started. That’s nonsense. And I suspect we’ll see that whopper taken apart over the next hours and days. Still, though, these whoppers and gaffes aren’t in the same category. (I mean, a pretty ridiculous standard — she clearly has virtually no grasp of any major national political or policy issue.) For that reason, as I said, I think she gives base Republicans a reason to feel reassured and permission to stop feeling embarrassed.
One thing that I think is easy to overlook here is that Biden did really well. He started a little slow. But he quickly got into his groove and in the second half there were several answers that he took the debate squarely to John McCain in a way that I thought was very effective.
So basically a win for Biden because he just did a lot better and it’s Obama-Biden who want the trajectory of the race to stay as is. She made herself less of an embarrassment and gave core Republicans a reason to stop being embarrassed. But there were a bunch of flatly false or nonsensical things she said — and we’ll see those picked apart over the next few days.