Toward the end, one of Biden’s most powerful moments in the debate …
Needless to say, getting the name of the top general in Afghanistan wrong just shows that Palin is new to the subject matter. But lying about what he said is a much bigger deal.
10:03 PM … Didn’t Palin just get the name wrong of our Army commander in Afghanistan. His name is David D. McKiernan. Who’s the McClellan she was talking about? She pretty clearly misstated what he said, but she seems not even to know who he is. And here’s the article with the General saying what Biden said he said, that a surge type strategy wouldn’t work.
Here’s the vid …
10:06 PM … What’s Palin talking about saying that Biden was supporting McCain’s line on Iraq during the primaries? Really? Can we go to the videotape on that?
10:14 PM … What’d she just say? That she’d like the VP to take a stronger role in the senate?
10:15 PM … A bit earlier Gov. Palin said that Sen. Biden supported McCain’s policies on Iraq until this race. Let’s do some fact-checking on that. Here’s her quote: “You had supported John McCain’s military strategies pretty adamantly until this race.” What’s she basing that on.
10:18 PM … “America is a nation of exceptionalism.”
10:21 PM … Biden saving the best for last. Very powerful.
10:29 PM … Palin: “I like answering the tough questions.”
10:33 PM … Here was one of Palin’s weirdest moments ….
9:03 PM … “Can I call you Joe.” That was actually well done. Cosmetic, yes. But still good optics.
9:04 PM … Biden’s strategy seems to be not to look at anybody.
9:06 PM … Oversight? McCain for greater oversight? Just a few days ago, Palin got stumped when asked for any example of McCain being for any kind of oversight.
9:10 PM … Really hoping that Biden comes back at McCain’s record of always being for lax oversight … He’s sort of doing it here, but not really driving the point home …
9:13 PM … Palin repeats the $42,000 dollar a year tax increase lie.
9:14 PM … Now, this is a Joe Biden I can believe in.
9:17 PM … Palin, lie, lie, lie …
9:18 PM … Isn’t this government out of the way line in a bit of tension with Palin’s call for tighter regulation?
9:21 PM … Hmmm. That was pretty good on Biden’s part and he’s getting into his rhythm. But there were a lot of numbers flying around in that health care answer.
9:24 PM … Wait, Palin undid what was done in 2005 Energy Bill? Really?
9:45 PM … Someone go back and see how Palin said the economic crisis was a toxic mess on Main Street that was threatening to spill over to Wall Street.
9:51 PM … Spain!
9:56 PM … Very solid from Biden.
9:56 PM … Wo … what happened with the nuclear weapons answer?
10:00 PM … Did Palin just get the name wrong of the top US General in Afghanistan?
The spin from the Obama campaign and from various independent commentators (who seem to mean it) is that Sarah Palin is actually a pretty good debater. So, given how ridiculous she’s been in these network interviews, is there any way that can possibly be true?
In a narrow sense at least, I think the answer is, Yes. When we were doing research on her position on the Road to Nowhere back during her 2006 gubernatorial run, I watched a number of her debates. And she was pretty good. She definitely held her own. She played the role of the common sense political outsider. And she was good at turning a line, especially ones that were cutting without seeming angry or hostile.
The key though was the issues. Those debates were about local Alaska issues that she clearly knew well enough to give pat answers. They were also highly structured debates where there wasn’t a lot of give and take. But it seemed clear that when she felt comfortable with the issues and had some sense of where they were, she was confident and affable and came off well. But that’s the key. She appears to know nothing about national economic or foreign policy issues. It’s as simple as that.
I also think my colleague Greg Sargent is right on the mark when he says that the terrible interviews actually raised the bar for Palin. As they say, better to stay mum and have people assume you’re a fool than open your mouth and remove all doubt. At the moment, I think the consensus is that Palin’s a fool. So just stumbling through with some bromides, I don’t think that will do it. Because people will assume that she’s a fool who got off a few bromides. Successfully executed zingers may juice up McCain’s core supporters. But I think to change non-right-wingers’ views about whether Palin belongs in the White House she has to do or say something that gives some reason to believe that those interviews gave an unrealistic view of her.
Is it acceptable now to use infant children as political props?
In a conference call with reporters this afternoon that was heavy on damage control in the wake of reports that McCain is conceding Michigan to Obama, the McCain campaign acknowledged that the six core battleground states are now Ohio, Virgina, Florida, Missouri, Indiana, and North Carolina. In other words, as Josh noted earlier, McCain is now fighting just to hold onto the red states Bush won in 2004.
National Review argues the advantages of having an unstable personality as president.