Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
12.27.08 | 12:14 pm
Election Central Saturday Roundup

Rod Blagojevich insists those wiretapped conversations don’t show him doing anything wrong — in fact, they demonstrate how hard he’s worked on behalf of the people of Illinois. That and other political news in today’s Election Central Saturday Roundup

12.27.08 | 10:03 am
Cycle

Israel unleashes massive retaliatory attack on Gaza. Scores dead.

12.26.08 | 2:38 pm
Not So Fast!

As you’ve seen, I’ve become increasingly interested in this question of whether or not the president can withdraw a pardon, as President Bush has attempted to do in the case of Isaac Toussie. I’ve consulted a few experts and reviewed various cases. And I’m increasingly convinced that the president did not have the power to do this, notwithstanding the fact that few press reports seem to have taken this possibility very seriously.

Let’s break this down piece by piece.

No one disagrees that a presidential pardon cannot be revoked or taken back. The only question here is whether the Toussie pardon had in some sense not yet become official.

And there are two arguments floating around about why this pardon wasn’t set in stone yet before the president decided to take it back.

First is the argument put forward by the White House itself, that the president had sent requests for pardons to the Pardon Attorney but that the Pardon Attorney had yet to “execute and deliver grants of clemency to the named individuals.” According to the White House press release from Wednesday, the president got to him before he’d done that and “directed the Pardon Attorney not to execute and deliver a Grant of Clemency to Mr. Toussie.”

But from what I can tell, the Pardon Attorney doesn’t ‘execute’ anything. The current system of having the Pardon Attorney create certificates of pardon only goes back to the Eisenhower administration, and was then apparently only done to relieve the president of the chore of signing so many pardons and commutations. I spoke to former Pardon Attorney Margaret Colgate Love (1990-1997) who told me that “receiving the president’s warrant and sending notifications to the petitioners is purely ‘a ministerial act of notification.'” In layman’s terms, at this end of the transaction, the Pardon Attorney’s role is really just a matter of paperwork. “When we received the Master Warrant from the president,” said Love, “what our job was was to notify them, by telephone, and eventually by written notification. The document evidenced the president’s action. We never assumed that that document had any necessary legal significance.”

So just as a factual matter, the idea that the Pardon Attorney needs to ‘execute’ the pardons seems to be bogus. End of story.

The second argument has to do with notification. The idea here is that even though the president is the actor, his pardon only takes effect when the petitioner is notified. This reasoning depends on the Du Puy case from 1869, in which the Court ruled that President Grant could take back two pardons earlier issued by President Johnson because the petitioners had not yet been notified of their pardons. But the Du Puy case comes from a technological universe in which the US Marshal’s notification would have been the first the petitioner heard about it. But clearly that’s not the case anymore. There’s little doubt that Toussie heard about his pardon in the news prior to the president’s decision to rescind it.

More to the point, from talking to people familiar with the process, I understand that it is standard procedure for the petitioners or their counsel to be notified of their pardon either before or simultaneous with the public announcement. So there’s every reason to be believe that Toussie or his attorneys were specifically notified of his pardon, despite not getting the framable document that does not appear to have any legal significance.

Needless to say, I’m not an attorney or a constitutional expert. But I’ve seen few if any press write-ups with quotes from people with relevant expertise who say the president is actually able to do this. And my discussions with people with relevant expertise give me the strong impression that the president’s action is highly dubious in constitutional terms, even if no Court case has specifically addressed this combination of facts.

In any case, I feel sure we won’t have to wonder forever. If nothing else Toussie has a solid case to bring. So I feel confident the Court will eventually decide if this passes muster.

12.26.08 | 2:32 pm
A Choice, Not an Echo

With the earlier news about Katon Dawson and his whites only country club and today’s revelations about Chip Saltsman, it really does seem like the RNC chairmanship race is down to a straight-up match between the black candidates and the racist candidates.

12.26.08 | 11:30 am
Barack the Magic Negro

RNC chair wannabee Chip Saltsman’s Christmas gift to RNC members was a CD that includes the Rush Limbaugh “satirical” tune, “Barack, the Magic Negro.”

12.26.08 | 11:21 am
Don’t Let the Door Hitchya

Percentage of Americans “glad [President Bush] is leaving”: 75%.

Percentage of Americans who say President Bush “is a person you admire”: 27%.

… “brought the kind of change the country needed”: 13%.

… “say President Bush is the worst president in history”: 28%.

From the latest CNN poll.

12.26.08 | 8:58 am
Pardon Hawk

With this latest pardon controversy — and the possibility of more self-serving pardons to come from President Bush (Libby, Cheney, et al.?) — there’s another rush of commentary suggesting we curtail or even abolish the president’s pardon power. For my own part, though, not only am I against getting rid of the power, I actually think this current crop of pardons is pretty shabby in terms of stinginess.

President Bush’s pardons (these and the ones from earlier in his administration) are mostly pardons for people who committed relatively minor crimes and got relatively minor punishment and have long since served their sentences.

I understand the symbolic importance of clearing people’s names. But that’s pretty thin gruel. I’d much rather see some people doing serious hard time getting sprung from prison. Long term imprisonment is a life-crushing, brutal thing. Often the punishment fits the crime. But certainly there are more than a few people languishing in prison who, either because of an original miscarriage of justice or subsequent meritorious acts, have a claim on a second chance?

I think the vast majority of people in prison on low level federal drug charges don’t deserve the sentences they have. But that would involve so many people that it’s not realistic as a wrong to be righted by pardons. And the use of pardons I’m advocating does create an inevitable problem of arbitrariness — some prisoners have grace come down upon them out of the blue and, inevitably, some others no less deserving get nothing. The whole concept of the pardon power is in uncomfortable tension with the rule of law. In many ways, it’s archaic. But I think some leavening of mercy is an essential escape valve to make the justice system actually just. In its punishing capacity, the state is a vast, impersonal, crushing, awful thing. Some sliver of hope is crucial.

Late Update: To drive home the point above, the current formal pardon process requires petitioners to go through the DOJ’s Pardon Attorney, a specific career DOJ attorney charged with evaluating pardons. But the Pardon Attorney’s petition guidelines require that you have already been out of prison for five years before you even apply. So the only pardons the system even envisages are the essentially symbolic sort — pardon after you’ve already done the time. Commutations are different, of course. But the strictures are pretty stiff there too.

12.26.08 | 8:47 am
Election Central Morning Roundup

The man and woman most admired by Americans? Obama and Hillary, according to Gallup. (Sarah Palin came in second.) That and the day’s other political news in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup.

12.26.08 | 7:57 am
No Respect

I went on C-Span this morning. I’ve been on TV plenty of times, but not in a while. And this was the first time my older son seemed older enough (25 months) to get the concept, that it was kind of neat seeing his dad on TV. So after I left the studio I called my wife.

Apparently it was neat for about two minutes. Then he wanted to watch Madagascar again.

12.25.08 | 8:55 pm
Tad More on Pardons

As you know, President Bush took the close to unprecedented step of revoking one of his own pardons yesterday. In fact, from what I can tell, it may actually be unprecedented, since the earlier cases appear to have been instances of revoking a predecessor’s pardon. (In other words, this looks like the first revocation on the basis of a goof rather than a difference of policy or opinion.) That’s what happened in 1869 when, three days into his presidency, President Grant cancelled two pardons his predecessor President Johnson had given.

In any case, it turns out there’s a blog exclusively focused on the pardon power — pardonpower.com. One of the contributors to the blog, P.S. Ruckman, Jr., did a post earlier today on whether or not the president can revoke a pardon. And he says he’s sure the president can do so.

But I’m not sure that’s the last word on the matter.

Like others who say that the president can rescind a pardon, Ruckman appears to base his argument on in re Du Puy from 1869. In that case, the Court held that President Grant was within his rights to rescind President Johnson’s pardons because they had not yet been delivered to the grantees.

But last night a reader sent in some testimony from the hearings on the Clinton pardons that took place just after President Bush was sworn in in 2001. As you’ll remember, they focused heavily on the infamous Marc Rich pardon. And the question came up whether there wasn’t something President Bush could do to undo Clinton’s pardon.

Key testimony was provided by Margaret Colgate Love, herself a contributor to pardonpower.com and also former DOJ Pardon Attorney from 1990-1997.

When asked by Rep. Hostettler (R) whether President Bush couldn’t undo Clinton’s pardons under the Du Puy case, she seemed to say that Du Puy had been superseded in this regard by Biddle v. Perovich from 1927 …

No, once the pardon warrant is signed, that is the public act that accomplishes the clemency action. I believe that Supreme Court case law has made it pretty clear that a pardon is a public act, and so all that business about the deeds and delivery, I think, has pretty much has been overtaken by the Biddle case; that it is a public act and once a warrant is signed–I mean, know from my own experience that we did not deliver pardon warrants, individual pardon warrants, to the recipients sometimes for weeks. I am embarrassed to say, because we just did not–I am sure, frankly, if you look, I suspect that a number of the 176 have not gotten theirs yet, either, and that is a warrant that is signed by Roger Adams, who is the current Pardon Attorney. Roger Adams does not have any authority to do anything other than simply deliver what the President did, and this is a document that somebody can frame and hang on their kitchen wall or something. But it is nothing more than a symbol, a sign of what the President did in signing a document with 140 names on it.

This is not my area of specialty. So I won’t try to get too far into the technicalities. But from a quick layman’s reading, the issue in Biddle seems to be the reasoning that the presidential pardon power, which grew from royal prerogative, was no longer a private act of grace from a sovereign but a part of the constitutional system. And as such, whether or not it had been delivered was irrelevant.

There are a few things that aren’t completely on point in Biddle. It was about a commutation, not a pardon. And that still leaves the issue of whether the pardon didn’t really become valid until the Pardon Attorney ‘executed’ it. But Love seems to have expressed a pretty clear opinion on that too.

Certainly, Love’s personal opinion isn’t definitive. But as a former Pardon Attorney herself and someone who’s now in private practice specializing in pardons, I would think she’s as firmly rooted in the relevant precedents and law as anyone. So until I see more, I’m back to thinking that President Bush’s revocation of this pardon just may not fly.

As I wrote last night, I’m eager to hear from experts in the field who can shed more light on this.