Only a day after issuing a presidential pardon to Isaac Robert Toussie, a real estate scammer from Brooklyn, President Bush decided to reverse the pardon, after it emerged that Toussie’s father had contributed almost $30,000 to the Republican party.
Pardons are absolute. They can’t be reviewed or reconsidered or overturned, even by the president who issued them. According to the White House press release, President Bush had sent a “Master Warrant of Clemency” with 19 names to the Pardon Attorney at DOJ to execute. But he hadn’t executed it yet. In other words, the White House is claiming none of these folks had actually been pardoned yet. So the president can just send word now not to ‘execute’ that one pardon.
I’d be curious to hear from constitutional lawyers on this. But I’m not sure the constitution would recognize this distinction. And to be arch about it, I think the unitary theory of the executive would suggest that the pardon is full and irrevocable once the president says he’s doing it. The power is the president’s — not the pardon attorney’s once the president sends on the request. The constitution doesn’t recognize or take any cognizance of the administrative procedures they’ve developed at the Justice Department.
I would think Toussie’s attorneys could make a pretty solid argument that the bell’s been rung. Too late.
Any constitutional scholars out there with nothing better to do on Christmas eve than to toss this one around?
Late Update: Or maybe not. A knowledge says there’s an 1869 case (in re Du Puy) that holds that the president can take back the pardon as long as it hasn’t been delivered to the grantee. A quick read of this suggests that this decision binding. That’s an old legal text citing this case to argue what I’ve italicized in this quote: “A pardon is a deed, to the validity of which delivery is essential, and delivery is not complete without acceptance, and a pardon by an outgoing President may be revoked by his successor before delivery.”
Late Late Update: A reader passes on some new information suggesting that Du Puy may no longer be the operative precedent in this case and that the Toussie pardon is not revocable. But there are limits on the hours even I’m willing to keep. So this will have to wait for tomorrow — jmm, 12/24/08, 11:22 PM.
Following up on my post below (and the critical phase we’re entering in January 2009), here’s a question I’m going to be thinking about over the holidays: what are the factions?
We’re going to hear a lot of pablum about how we’re beyond left and right or how ‘liberal’ and ‘conservative’ are outdated constructs. But that’s not what I’m talking about. What I mean is that the critical public policy questions we face post-2008 are different enough from those from earlier in this decade and back into the 1990s that the ways we divided up the players in the public square isn’t really that helpful in figuring out what’s happening or even who we should be supporting.
Let’s start with everything from the mid-point of the political spectrum left, or rather the whole ‘center’ and go left.
What are the factions or groups and what are they pushing for?
And please note that the following is offered in the mod of thinking aloud, less an effort to say anything definitively than to jump start the conversation.
It’s seems almost impossible to find anyone who doesn’t support vast amounts of near-term (say, two year horizon) stimulus (let’s peg ‘vast’ at $500 billion and up) until you get very far to the right end of the ideological spectrum. You’ve got political opportunists like John Boehner and Eric Cantor posturing about spending. But I think this is largely a distraction from where even most political people are. (And Republicans are at least a bit wrong-footed in this effort by the massive amounts of government spending their prime business supporters are currently begging for.) You’ve also got a debate about whether to have stimulus in the form of spending or taxes. But again, at least in broad strokes, I don’t see a lot of people seriously arguing for making tax cuts a big part of the equation.
So in terms of the center and the left, the key points are that the usual forces you’d expect to stand against these sorts of policies (Blue Dog Dems, Rubinite economics types, deficit hawks, etc.) have withdrawn their objections and agree that deficit spending and expansion of government expenditure (to the extent it crowds out private sector investment) are not significant concerns over the one to two year time horizon, given the extremity of the financial crisis.
But let’s break it down from there. What comes next? What Krugman points to in his Tuesday column is that within that broad, apparent consensus you’ve got a lot of people who think you spend like crazy to nurse the economy through the storm and then you go back to the status quo ante. As he puts it …
Right now everyone is talking about, say, two years of economic stimulus — which makes sense as a planning horizon. Too much of the economic commentary I’ve been reading seems to assume, however, that that’s really all we’ll need — that once a burst of deficit spending turns the economy around we can quickly go back to business as usual.
In fact, however, things can’t just go back to the way they were before the current crisis. And I hope the Obama people understand that.
So that’s one potential division, considering the center and left. Let’s call that the division between those favoring a Keynesian Holiday followed by a return to the same broad economic principles we’ve been following for ten to thirty years and those who believe that a brief period of massive government spending will have to prepare the way for thoroughgoing changes in national economic policy. In the latter case, perhaps a scale of reform on par with the New Deal, if not the policy prescriptions or precise ideological flavor of the Roosevelt administration.
Next there’s a cross-cutting division, though perhaps it’s also a matter of emphasis.
There’s a general but pretty vague sentiment that a lot of this new spending needs to go into infrastructure and research and development to move toward a green energy economy. But is that really an essential part of the equation for economic and/or environmental reasons? Or is it just something that would be nice to do a bit of as long as you’re spending a trillion-plus dollars? That seems like another potential cleavage, though I think almost everyone is being so vague about particulars that it’s hard to know where to draw the key dividing lines.
And then a few couple more points. I was talking to David Kurtz a few moments ago and he points out that another potential division, though one that shadows the others, is the question of order and precedence. What comes first? Does mass transit come first? Roads for cars? Green R&D? etc.
And finally there do seem to be some Republicans left. How do they fit in? Or, more interestingly, how do they break down? In a climate of super-high energy prices, there seemed to be a decent-sized constituency on the right for alternative energy sources to cut our reliance on foreign oil. And not all of them thought you could do that by drilling in the US, notwithstanding how many ‘wingers seemed to get inappropriately jazzed by hearing a fetching Sarah Palin yelling “Drill, Baby, Drill.”
Those are some initial thoughts on how to think of the main political grouping 2009 and going forward. Let me know your thoughts. As a reporter and an editor and someone who cares a lot about this country, this is a question I’m eager to get my head around.
Earlier I flagged the AP article about the environmental activist who snuck into a Bureau of Land Management auction and managed to marginally jack up the give-away prices a bunch of oil and gas companies were going to pay to lease the land. Now it turns out, according to one of our readers, that the ‘scam’ was only possible because the Bush administration did the whole thing on a rush basis in order to get as much of the public domain given away to energy industry cronies before January 20th …
The fuss over DeChristopher stems from his disruption of a last-minute push by the Bush administration to give away public lands for a pittance. That’s apparently why the rules were changed for this auction, waiving the time-consuming prequalification procedures that would ordinarily have prevented a stunt like this. As one former BLM director put it: “It was rush before the door slams behind them: ‘Let’s get as many leases out as possible.'”
But what I really love about the story is the complaint that DeChristopher “tainted the entire auction,” by running up prices by thousands of dollars on all the lots he didn’t actually win. Honestly, I don’t understand that. How could bidders have overpaid? They knew what they were buying, and presumably, they wouldn’t have been willing to bid
more than they felt the parcels were worth. So the complaint is that DeChristopher’s intervention narrowed the spread between the value of the rights and their price at auction. I understand why the bidders are angry, but shouldn’t BLM be pleased?Auctions work on the theory that open bidding will efficiently yield the highest price any bidder is willing to pay. DeChristopher’s stunt suggests that, for whatever reason, that’s often not the case at BLM auctions. It turns out that, when pressed, most bidders are willing to pay more, often much more. In other words, DeChristopher exposed the
fact that we’re routinely selling the rights to public land for less than its actual market value. No wonder BLM is mad.
Only a month before the raid on the public domain comes to a close.
At least for the moment.
From TPM Reader JM:
A a reader from Illinois, I consider it appropriate to try to influence the judges of the Golden Duke Awards.
Sarah Palin’s “Bridge to Nowhere” nomination in the category of Best Election Year Fib is certainly appropriate. But her second nomination for General Lying throughout the campaign is dangerous; if you give one Republican a prize for overall disregard for truth, they’ll all want one.
May I suggest, instead,.a special category for Sarah Palin? Many organizations provide special recognition to beginners. A bowling league once presented me with a plaster trophy for Most Improved Beginning Bowler. Something similar, like “Best Lying Newcomer to National Politics,” would narrowly honor The Barracuda for her dishonesty without causing resentment among veteran competitors.
Such an award would benefit Governor Palin and the American people alike, encouraging her to renew a quest for national office that would provide the nation with entertainment for years to come.
(ed.note: Kurtz’s snark is even better: “Nero: Fiddling Was ‘Right Approach'”)
From the Post …
Taking a swipe at the shifting response of the Treasury and Fed in addressing the financial crisis, he said: “When these gale-force winds hit our markets, there were panicked cries to change any and every rule of the marketplace: ‘Let’s try this. Let’s try that.’ What was needed was a steady hand.”
Cox said the biggest mistake of his tenure was agreeing in September to an extraordinary three-week ban on short selling of financial company stocks. But in publicly acknowledging for the first time that this ban was not productive, Cox said he had been under intense pressure from Treasury Secretary Henry M. Paulson Jr. and Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke to take this action and did so reluctantly. They “were of the view that if we did not act and act at that instant, these financial institutions could fail as a result and there would be nothing left to save,” Cox said.
Although Cox speaks of staying calm in the face of financial turmoil, lawmakers across the political spectrum counter that this is actually another way of saying that his agency remained passive during the worst global financial crisis in decades. And they say that Cox’s stewardship before this year — focusing on deregulation as the agency’s staff shrank — laid the groundwork for the meltdown.
Given the extreme economic pessimism that is gripping the country, economists, the markets and just about everyone else, it’s astounding in itself that these jobless numbers can keep exceeding expectations.
From the AP …
An environmental activist tainted an auction of oil and gas drilling leases Friday by bidding up parcels of land by hundreds of thousands of dollars without any intention of paying for them, a federal official said.
The process was thrown into chaos and the bidding halted for a time before the auction was closed, with 116 parcels totaling 148,598 acres having sold for $7.2 million plus fees.
“He’s tainted the entire auction,” said Kent Hoffman, deputy state director for the U.S. Bureau of Land Management in Utah.
Hoffman said buyers will have 10 days to reconsider and withdraw their bids if they think they paid too much.
Tim DeChristopher, a 27-year-old University of Utah economics student, said his plan was to disrupt the auction and he feels he accomplished his goal.
I’m all for transparent processes and this really screws that up. But I can’t help finding this clever and funny, especially since most of the leasing of public lands for energy extraction takes place on an only slightly less than criminal basis.