Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
12.29.08 | 11:51 am
More on Criminal Justice Reform

From TPM Reader MK:

Was pleased to see your quick post about Webb and criminal justice reform.
Webb does appear to be the new Democratic champion of these issues. I heard him speak at the National Press Club earlier this month. While he’s clearly just learning the field, he’s also courageous on some of the most fundamental points of citizenship and, of course, color. While he’s hung up on locking away ‘the right people’ — without entirely specifying who they might be — he’s willing to think of the problems in ways that can be solved with ‘alternatives to enforcement.’ That’s a sea-change from the ever-increasingly punitive rhetoric and practice Americans, mostly young Americans, have been subjected to for nearly forty years.

Anyway, he will, thankfully, replace Joe Biden as the standard bearer among forward-thinking Democrats on this issue.

Of course, over the years Democrats have been horrendous on issues of punishment, crime, incarceration, and all the mechanisms we have to try to prevent these things. Have they been as bad as Republicans? No. Have they been bankrupt and awful? Unequivocally. Biden, Schumer, Cuomo, most of all President Clinton, they have been abominable. You know this, of course. But I’m writing to say thanks for raising this issue on the blog. Democratic blogs have, generally, been as silent on this issue as the Democrat leadership has been negligent and nasty.

Anyway, here’s to hoping Obama and the Democrats show the courage to take on the great human problems of our time in 2009.

12.29.08 | 10:07 am
Heart of the Issue

As the Israeli assault on Gaza unfolds, and we receive new information about the death toll and new predictions about the prospects for any peace settlement, I wanted to refocus back on the essential issue that is still with us and will continue to be with us after this blow up fades into memory like the Second Lebanon War, Jenin, and the terrorist attacks and back and forths of the 1990s. Since the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process began going on twenty years ago, Israeli settlements in the West Bank have continued to expand every year. The settler population was 130,000 in 1995 and had grown to 270,000 by 2007 — through a mix of natural increase and immigration. The numbers have continued to increase right through the Olmert government, which I think really wanted to get about the business of uprooting settlements and solving the core issues. But he wasn’t willing or able to do it. Whatever you can say about Palestinian terror attacks or missiles into Southern Israel and whatever you can say Israeli incursions and aerial attacks, the situation is insoluble without dismantling those settlements. And that is why Hamas, as much as it thrives on war and confrontation, is a distraction — for some an intentional one, for others unintentional — from this core point. That’s why I think Bernard Avishai is right in his post from last week. The settler issue is intractable without an outside hand.

12.29.08 | 8:56 am
TPMtv: Sunday Show Roundup: Meanwhile, Back in Gaza…

A new president is coming into the White House but the story remains the same in the Middle East as a new round of violence has erupted in Israel and the Gaza Strip …

Full-size video at TPMtv.com.

12.29.08 | 8:29 am
Amen

Sen. Jim Webb (D-VA) set to tackle criminal justice reform.

12.29.08 | 8:13 am
Election Central Morning Roundup

Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) wants the Senate to go ahead and seat the winner of the Coleman-Franken recount (i.e., Franken) even if there’s a formal election contest. That and the day’s other political news in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup.

12.28.08 | 9:08 pm
–172314

12.28.08 | 5:05 pm
Truth in Headlines

Politico bristles at inter-holiday political news trough.

12.28.08 | 3:40 pm
More Good News for the Rat

Dan Slater, at the WSJ law blog, also thinks Toussie has a good case for holding on to his pardon. And he also flags some more strong, albeit circumstantial, evidence that Toussie was actually personally notified of his pardon.

12.28.08 | 12:34 pm
Election Central Sunday Roundup

In a big change for this country, incoming White House press secretary Robert Gibbs says that Barack Obama “wants and expects” disagreements within his administration. That and other political news in today’s Election Central Sunday Roundup.

12.27.08 | 12:25 pm
Not So Simple?

From fellow obsessive, TPM Reader JS …

You seem obsessed by Toussie; so am I. This thing is legally even more complex than you think. Apparently, Toussie wanted the pardon to free him from state law disabilities. I believe that it is state law that decides whether the pardon is effective for state purposes. If I am correct, the state law can ignore a valid federal pardon; it can follow whatever the federal rule may be for a revoked pardon; it can decide for its own whether NY state will recognize the revocation. I don’t know what it does, but I think that state sovereignty is pretty unquestioned here. (Warning: I am not a Constitutional lawyer and of course, nothing in this screed is legal advice, or creates an attorney-client relationship. The only thing confidential is, I hope, my name.)

The rubber will hit the road when Toussie wants to get his NY real estate license back. And it will likely be a New York state court that decides.

Late Update: 12/27/08: A few readers have written in to argue that JS is wrong because of the federal supremacy clause: state courts have no standing to judge the validity of the president’s pardon. But I think they’re missing the point. Technically, the president just kicked Toussie’s request back to the Pardon Attorney for a review. But let’s assume what’s very likely: that his request will now die at the Pardon Office. (Under the Pardon Office’s rules, I don’t think he’s even allowed to apply for a pardon for a few more years.) Sure, if a federal court resolved the issue of whether or not the president could revoke Toussie’s pardon, that would settle the matter. And state court’s would have to respect that decision. But given that Toussie apparently wanted this pardon to get out of under a state disability, it’s not clear to me by what means we’re going to get to a federal test case. What seems far more likely is that Toussie will go to the state of New York and ask for his real estate license back. He’ll have at least a pretty solid argument that he did receive a federal pardon — that the president wasn’t able rescind the pardon. Then the State of New York — first whatever agency issues real estate licenses and then perhaps a federal court — will have to decide whether Toussie has been absolved or not. Of course, I guess, if he gets rebuffed by that agency, Toussie could go to a federal court for relief, arguing they’re disregarding the federal supremacy clause. And then a federal court would have a chance to review. Clearly, at this point, I’m way too deep into the federalism thicket for my own good. But it does seem to me that JS is right that the first government agency to have to make sense of this may be part of the State of New York.