Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
12.30.08 | 8:16 am
Election Central Morning Roundup

Larry Wilkerson recalls Bush as a “Sarah Palin-like president.” That and the day’s other political news in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup.

12.30.08 | 8:14 am
Role Playing

Mitch McConnell tries budget hawk costume on for size.

12.29.08 | 11:04 pm
Coulda Told You That

Bush aides tell Vanity Fair that Katrina did him in.

12.29.08 | 10:13 pm
No Title Can Do It Justice

Treasury to lend up to a billion to GM buy to buy a bigger stake in its own financing subsidiary GMAC, which has also become a bank holding company to qualify for $5 billion in TARP funds from Treasury.

12.29.08 | 9:39 pm
Classy to the End

Norm Coleman okays counting ballots — but only his own.

12.29.08 | 6:14 pm
The Long Goodbye

I think I have this right. The Republican party has decided on the racial joke issue as the vehicle to reintroduce themselves to the American people after the 2008 blow out.

Am I missing something?

12.29.08 | 3:15 pm
Show Me the Money

If Bernie Madoff swindled $50 billion, where’d the money actually go? We walk you through the possibilities.

12.29.08 | 2:19 pm
The Height of Folly

TPM Reader BG chimes in …

I basically agree with everything that you’ve written. I believe that the expansion of settlements in the West Bank is and has been a major problem in resolving the issue. It must be resolved, and the resolution is for most of the settlements to be dismantled and their inhabitants relocated back to within the Green Line. As a volunteer for Rabbis for Human Rights in 2000, I witnessed first hand the moral decay represented by the settlements and their most radical inhabitants.

But, I must note that it was not the issue of settlements that was the principal problem in causing the collapse of the Camp David negotiations in 2000. Indeed, the Barak government was willing to give up most of the settlements (with the exception of Ariel, Maale Adumim and Gush Etzion), and relocate their inhabitants. Israel also accepted Clinton’s proposal of December 2000 which would have seen Israel ceding close to 96% of the West Bank.

Rather, the Camp David negotiates collapsed upon issues concerning sovereignty in Jerusalem and Palestinian Right of Return. So, while the settlements are and were a major issue, and I believe a continuing shame for Israel on a number of levels (which I need not get into here), this was one of the issues where the parties were in the closest agreement, and which the Barak government was willing to make far reaching concessions.

What happened in the 2000 Camp David negotiations is a very controversial question. But I don’t think we need to get into all the nitty gritty of it. Because you still have the key issue, which is this: at some point you’ll need to have have a two state solution. Barak may have agreed to dismantle most of the settlements, though it’s a bit more complicated than that. But that doesn’t necessarily mean he would have been able to deliver on that commitment politically. However that may be, at some point you need to have a two state solution. That means wrapping up the settlements. And the more you let them grow, the more and more difficult it will become to uproot them because the entire Israeli political system will become more and more hostage to the radicalism and, as BG puts it, the moral decay of the settlements.

Ben Gurion, who was no slouch in his Zionism, saw this all very clearly in the aftermath of the Six Day War. Trying to settle and absorb the West Bank was the height of folly. Unfortunately he was old and retired. And many people who should have known better got swept up in the logic of settlement.

12.29.08 | 1:26 pm
Gaza and Settlements

A longtime reader wrote in in response to my post below saying that I was off base since Hamas doesn’t recognize even the concept of the settlements — in the sense of distinguishing between towns in Israel proper, the pre-1967 borders and those in the West Bank. But that misunderstands my point. I don’t think Hamas makes that distinction. But I don’t think that’s the point. I thought I’d print what I wrote him in response.

I’m actually not sure how much we’re disagreeing. In many ways I agree that Gaza and the West Bank have become two separate issues — not just in terms of negotiating strategy but in terms of final outcomes. But Israel has a profound strategic interest in a viable settlement with the West Bank Palestinians. Come up with some settlement of that issue and the Gaza issue because much, much less of a big deal. But no settlement of the West Bank issue is possible with continued expansion of settlements. Indeed, I would say no settlement is possible without uprooting almost all the current West Bank settlements, with the possible exception of some in the girdle around Jerusalem. That’s the core issue. And what’s happening right now in Gaza does not change any of that. Of course, Hamas makes no distinction of the Green Line. That’s a given. But I don’t think that’s the point. Israel desperately needs the West Bank issue settled. Everything that makes that more difficult endangers the state.