Jefferson Morley explains how Judge Sotomayor helped puncture the Vince Foster conspiracy theory bubble.
The new Quinnipiac poll has Americans approving of the Sotomayor pick by 54% to 24%.
Dems almost unanimously support, while Republicans oppose. But critically, independents support the nomination 48% to 31%.
Sen. John Cornyn’s swipe at Gingrich and Limbaugh yesterday on the Sotomayor candidacy shows what’s emerging as a critical effect of the confirmation battle. We know that a key dilemma for the GOP in the early Obama era is that they are increasingly divided between people who want to get the party back into the business of winning elections and ultras who want to go totally off the deep end with often extreme rhetoric and quests for ideological purity. What’s more, these ‘pragmatists, for lack of a better word, are cowed by the ultras because in a shrunken GOP the ultras make up a much larger percentage of the party.
The truth though is that taxes and fiscal policy, while key issues for conservatives, simply aren’t visceral and divisive in anywhere near the way race and gender are. So while this schism has been there for months, the Sotomayor battle — still only three days old — has thrown gasoline on the fire and intensified the rift dramatically.
Here’s more on the story.
George W. Bush, defending torture policies last night in Michigan: “The information we got saved lives.” That and the day’s other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.
War is very cool. Especially for those who survive it. Even more for those who can read about it and watch it on TV.
TPM Reader DW condenses the conservative logic: “If the Republicans make legitimate arguments against Sotomayor, they’ll be accused of doing it because of her race; thus, they’re left with only racial arguments.”
Now that it seems fairly clear that Benjamin Cardozo has lost any claim on being the first Hispanic Supreme Court Justice, we can note that he was the first and one assumes the only Justice to look like Conan O’Brien …
“Some lawyers just don’t like to be questioned by a woman. It was sexist, plain and simple.” — Judge Guido Calabresi, Judge Sotomayor’s colleague on the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, on suggestions that her tough questioning from the bench suggests a problem with her ‘temperament.’
This is from an article in the Times with the headline “Sotomayor’s Sharp Tongue Raises Issue of Temperament.” It’s by Jo Becker and Adam Liptak, two of the best, though I’m personally more familiar with Becker’s work since it’s been in areas where I’ve done reporting too.
Read the article. It is, I think, an example where the headline is not quite borne out by the article itself and where — choosing my words carefully — the ‘both-sides’ imperative of conventional newspaper journalism made lead to placing two unequal arguments on equal terms. The piece itself reads like Sotomayor is tough and can be intellectually combative and that her gender leads some to describe those qualities in, shall we say, much less flattering terms. Compare to Scalia. Give it a read. I’d be curious to know what you think.