Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
05.28.09 | 1:30 pm
Sotomayor Had It Easy

Conservatives like John Derbyshire are using the Sotomayor nomination to beef up, in their own minds, their working class white cred:

I get mighty annoyed by the unspoken implication in a lot of commentary that anyone not a member of a Protected Minority must have grown up in a twelve-bedroom lakeside mansion and been chauffered off to prep school with a silver spoon in his mouth. …

Was it really not possible to correct past injustices without creating an entire — and apparently permanent — class convinced that accidents of geography or biology have gifted them with special insight, wisdom, and “empathy”?

Mighty annoyed? Really?

Derbyshire was responding to one of his readers who was eager to “rain on the Sotomayor ‘compelling life story’ parade,” as she put it:

The woman grew up in the capital of the world, went to two Ivy League schools, and was blessed by Providence with the precisely correct right race-gender two-fer for the moment.

This is a story of privilege, dammit, not adversity.

They’re mad, and they’re not gonna take it anymore!

05.28.09 | 12:19 pm
Sotomayor Debate Careens Toward Complete Nonsense

According to The Politico, charges that Sonia Sotomayor is a “racist” are picking up steam and must be addressed. At least according to Lanny Davis and Chris Lehane.

05.28.09 | 11:39 am
Truly Can’t Help Themselves

Here’s your next emerging meme. Rep. Tom Tancredo (R-Blood & Soil) just went on CNN attacking Sonia Sotomayor for belonging to La Raza which he called a “Latino KKK.”

As I said this morning, it’s painfully revealing how conservatives simply cannot helping going hard on the race front with Sotomayor or, as David Kurtz just put it, can’t help imagining that everyone else is as racist as many of them are.

For those who aren’t familiar with it, La Raza is basically a Latino equivalent of B’nai Brith or the NAACP. Garden variety and uncontroversial unless you thinks it’s a public safety issue if more than a handful of Mexicans or Puerto Ricans get together in one place at the same time.

There’s much more of this coming.

05.28.09 | 11:20 am
High Brow and Low Brow

When we go through this ritual of Supreme Court nomination and confirmation, the brainier publications look at the interest groups and great legal questions. But there’s another part of the story — in some ways bigger in terms of the result and often more gripping to my attention– that is everywhere but too little discussed. And that is, the cast of spinmeisters and freakbots on the cable shows either smearing or carrying the water of the nominee.

And right out of the gate the chief anti-Sotomayor rabble rouser seemed to be a woman named Wendy Long. You can see her yacking it up on all the shows. You’ve probably seen her somewhere. In our ed. meeting this morning Brian Beutler raised the point that Curtis Levey — another highly visible freakbot — is not only the chief TV spinner for his group The Committee for Justice but also runs the group. And Long is only the TV yacker for her group, the Judicial Confirmation Network. And he even says that Levey’s group has more muscle. So I had to take Brian to task and explain that he shouldn’t waste my time with all those details. Wendy Long is the chief freakbot on TV. And really, what else matters?

So if you want to know a bit more about her, here’s our run-down.

We want to keep an eye on Long though. So when you see her on TV, pay attention to what she says. And she says anything particularly nuts, drop us a line. And you have any more relevant background, let us know about that too.

05.28.09 | 11:18 am
What Wisdom Will She Offer Next?

Liz Cheney comments on “enhanced marriage techniques” — denies gay marriage is torture.

05.28.09 | 11:00 am
Unexpected Ally?

Okay. Over recent days I’ve plumbed the question of whether Sonia Sotomayor would be the first or the second ‘Hispanic’ Supreme Court Justice. I’d first learned in the direction of ‘second’ — thinking that Benjamin Cardozo, a Sephardic Jew of Portuguese ancestry who served on the Court in the 1930s might have been the first. But tips and rejoinders from readers slowly led me to reconsider the matter. First is the fact that — whatever the history and etymology of the word ‘Hispanic’ — it seems clear that ‘Hispanic’ today generally refers to people from a Spanish language heritage, not people from Portugal or a Portuguese speaking country like Brazil. There are various other complications — Portuguese-American members of Congress have often joined the Hispanic Caucus, the US government seems to have given its imprimatur to the no-Portugal/Brazil formulation, some question about whether Cardozo’s ancestors may have been crypto-Spanish crypto-Jews (my own semi-analytic, semi-farcical locution) and much more. But it all leans against Cardozo’s candidacy.

But now Karl Rove is chiming in on Cardozo’s behalf in today’s Journal …

While the next two to four months of maneuverings and hearings may provide more insights into the views of Mr. Obama’s pick, barring an unforeseen development — not unheard of in Supreme Court nominations — Judge Sotomayor will become the second Hispanic (Benjamin Cardozo was Sephardic) and third woman confirmed to the Supreme Court. Democrats will win the vote, but Republicans can win the argument by making a clear case against the judicial activism she represents.

Clearly, Rove does not have as knowledgeable a readership as TPM.

05.28.09 | 9:24 am
Very Interesting Article

We’re watching very closely for news about this afternoon’s meeting between President Obama and Palestinian Authority President Abbas at the White House. (I’m also curious why they’re holding it so late in the afternoon; but that’s another matter.) In the ether there’s also this pretty direct back and forth today between Secretary Clinton and the Netanyahu government on the settlement issue.

But what just caught my attention was this article MJ Rosenberg just flagged in today’s Yediot Ahronoth. It’s an interview with former US Ambassador to Israel Martin Indyk which is very blunt about Israeli intransigence on this issue. There’s no English language version of the article but MJ has translated and flagged some key quotes.

I used to think of Indyk as on the mildly dovish but essentially mainstream, which is where I used to consider myself. But I didn’t think of him as someone who’d say stuff like this or voice a very different view of the 2000 trainwreck than is generally accepted here in the US.

05.28.09 | 8:48 am
Kyl: It’s “A Slap At Hispanics”

Return to those thrilling days of yesteryear (2003) when any opposition to Bush appeals court nominee Miguel Estrada was derided by the GOP as nothing but racism.

05.28.09 | 8:23 am
Not One Iota of Taint?

Can we all agree now that at a minimum Roland Burris wasn’t really the elder statesman of Illinois politics with a sterling character who was utterly removed from and disinterested in all the unseemly jockeying for Obama’s empty Senate seat?

05.28.09 | 5:50 am
Shorter and Longer Politico

Sotomayor nomination showing media’s left-wing bias.