Feds Investigate Wisc. School After Letter Suggests It’d Expel LGBT Students

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

A religious school in Wisconsin was under federal investigation after it sent a letter to parents suggesting gay or transgender students would be expelled, The Baraboo News Republic reported Thursday.

St. John’s Lutheran School receives federal funding for its free lunch program and busing through a No Child Left Behind initiative, according to the report. That means the private religious school cannot discriminate based on race, religion, gender or sexuality.

But in a letter sent home to parents in February, Principal Craig Breitkreutz detailed the school’s strategy to get around those federal anti-discrimination guidelines without losing funding.

Breitkreutz informed parents that St. John’s now requires a birth certificate upon admission to the school. The school also changed its handbook agreement, which parents must sign prior to enrollment, to reflect that students may be dismissed for “sinful” choices, including homosexuality.

“If we cannot legally refuse students who are struggling with homosexuality or gender identification, we must maintain our right to hold to the truths of God’s Word,” Breitkreutz wrote. “In other words, although we do not have the right to refuse admittance to people choosing an outwardly sinful lifestyle, we do maintain the right to discipline and dismiss students for these choices.”

The letter spawned a discrimination complaint from the nonprofit Freedom From Religion Foundation, stating that the attempted loophole spelled out in Breitkreutz’s letter is illegal and thus the school should be ineligible for federal funding, according to the News Republic.

In response, the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which implements the free lunch program, opened an investigation.

“USDA is reviewing this complaint,” USDA spokeswoman Amanda Heitkamp told the newspaper. “We are firmly committed to ensuring federal protections against discrimination with respect to all of our programs and activities.”

Breitkreutz told the News Republic that if the funds were revoked, the school would lose access to programs like free lunches that help students. But he said he was sticking to the policy, arguing that being gay or transgender was equally as sinful as cheating on a test.

“We definitely don’t have a goal of finding a way to kick students out,” Breitkreutz told the News Republic. “I mean, that’s not the goal. The goal is to share with them God’s word.”

Breitkreutz told the newspaper that the school has not had to discipline any LGBT students since he arrived there two years ago. He added that students who did exhibit sinful behavior would be dealt with patiently, but if they would be expelled if they then continued to exhibit the behavior.

The school’s pastor, Nick Maglietto, flatly told the News Republic that the school is “not welcoming” to LGBT students.

“So rather than us trying to weed them out, it’s more letting them know where we’re coming from up front and making their choice based on whether this would be an environment for their child,” he said.

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for meri meri says:

    a) As soon as I saw it was something shitty, and it had “Lutheran school” I knew it was Wisconsin. The Lutherans there are almost as bad as Southern Baptists

    b) It’s obviously a religious school. Last I heard you can get away with anything as long as you can justify it as a religious belief. Why are the feds bothering them?

  2. But it would expel the filthy sinners with Christian love.

  3. “I mean, [expelling them is] not the goal. The goal is to share with them God’s word.”

    And that word is: GOD HATES YOU, FILTHY LGBT SINNER! Have a good day!

  4. So the parents must swear the enrolled children are heterosexual prior to their sexual development so that they can then be ‘disciplined’ if a self-appointed religious critic disagrees with that later maturation? A maturation, I must add, that came about under the self-appointed critic’s religious tutelage…

  5. The school’s pastor, Nick Maglietto, flatly told the News Republic that the school is “not welcoming” to LGBT students.

    Thank you for making that clear as day. Therefore, they’re ineligible for Federal funding. Good bye and good luck.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

74 more replies

Participants

Avatar for beccam Avatar for serge Avatar for texlib52 Avatar for meri Avatar for brooklyndweller Avatar for ncsteve Avatar for nowarino Avatar for brutus1910 Avatar for jinx_tpm Avatar for kenstarr Avatar for mantan Avatar for sherlock1 Avatar for progressiveoldman Avatar for midnight_rambler Avatar for fiftygigs Avatar for beattycat Avatar for spencersmom Avatar for professorpoopypants Avatar for doug834 Avatar for briannaamore Avatar for lizzymom Avatar for tiowally Avatar for cuwrs Avatar for 1988ranger

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: