11 Days Later, Fox News Retracts Story On Phony ‘Navy SEAL’

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Fox News on Thursday retracted a story about a man claiming to have been a Navy SEAL and veteran of the Vietnam War — claims which were proven to be false.

On Oct. 8, Fox News aired a story about John Garofalo, a glass artist and supposedly decorated retired Navy SEAL who’d created a giant presidential seal made of glass as a gift to President Donald Trump, according to the Washington Post, who flagged the story Friday morning.

“Garofalo is used to working under pressure,” Fox News’ Bryan Llenas had said in a voice over in the original segment. “The Vietnam War veteran served seven years as a member of the nation’s first Navy SEAL team. He was awarded 22 commendations, including two Purple Hearts.”

He called Garofalo a hero in an interview.

“I don’t like to hear that,” Garofalo responded, wiping tears from his eyes. “Heroes are the ones that didn’t come home.”

The retraction came 11 days later.

“Garofalo claimed he was a Vietnam veteran, a member of the first U.S. Navy SEAL team, and a decorated war hero who was awarded two Purple Hearts,” the network said in a post on its website. “Unfortunately, all of Garofalo’s claims turned out to be untrue.”

Llenas addressed his story’s inaccuracies on air Friday:

According to Navy Times, Fox News’ video had been viewed more than 1.5 million times by Thursday. It has since appeared to have been removed.

Viewers took note immediately, according to Navy Times: Don Shipley, a retired SEAL himself who has experience revealing cases of stolen valor, told the publication that he notified the Fox News reporter the day after the story ran about Garofalo’s phony claims. He posted a short video on Oct. 9 saying Garofalo was “a total phony.”

Garofalo is a veteran of the Navy, but he did not serve in Vietnam, nor is not a retired SEAL.

“It got bigger and bigger,” Garofalo told Navy Times. “What I did I‘m ashamed of, and I didn’t mean to cause so much disgrace to the SEALs.”

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. So wait, was that fake news or fake-fake news? It’s so hard to tell with FUX News…

  2. I’m sure the so-called president will soon tweet about the “failing Fox FAKE NEWS. Sad!” And a follow-up tweet about the “loser who is disrespecting our sacred military” and still a third tweet inquiring “when will I get that giant glass presidential seal?”

  3. Don Shipley has a bunch of youtube videos of him confronting fake SEALs, a surprising number of whom are involved in Republican politics.

  4. Gosh…remember the days when FOX whined and sniveled because Obama didn’t respond for 4 days? Good times…

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

66 more replies

Participants

Avatar for sysprog Avatar for fargo116 Avatar for economides Avatar for steviedee111 Avatar for Lacuna-Synecdoche Avatar for carlosfiance Avatar for dont Avatar for gr Avatar for leeks Avatar for ignoreland Avatar for keninmn Avatar for ronbyers Avatar for reverend_truth_v_wicked Avatar for georgesalt Avatar for khaaannn Avatar for tribalogical Avatar for dommyluc Avatar for mimiki2 Avatar for canary02 Avatar for not_so_fluffy Avatar for maximus Avatar for gromilini Avatar for loss_mentality Avatar for lizbensky

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: