Haitians Booted From Dominican Republic Face Uncertain Future

Andre Joseph, 53, who says he was born in the Dominican Republic and lived there until being deported the day before, sits inside a school classroom where residents have allowed him and other deportees to sleep in th... Andre Joseph, 53, who says he was born in the Dominican Republic and lived there until being deported the day before, sits inside a school classroom where residents have allowed him and other deportees to sleep in the village of Fonbaya, Haiti, Thursday, June 18, 2015. Thousands of people began preparing Thursday for deportation from the Dominican Republic after failing to obtain legal residency as part of a government program to crack down on migrants, most of them from neighboring Haiti or of Haitian descent. (AP Photo/Rebecca Blackwell) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

FONBAYA, Haiti (AP) — Saint-Soi Souverin sat on a bench resting and thinking about his plight after being uprooted from his longtime home on the other side of the border in the Dominican Republic, far from the Haitian shelter where he is staying.

Dominican authorities deported the 35-year-old farm worker along with his wife and four children early this week, leaving Souverin to ponder what he will do in Haiti — a deeply poor country that he left at age 17 to find work in the relatively more prosperous Dominican Republic.

“I’m not taking this well,” he told The Associated Press in Spanish as his small daughter fell asleep on the shelter’s concrete floor Thursday. “They sent me here with two empty hands. Everything I own was left behind.”

The Dominican Republic has long had uneasy relations with migrant workers like Souverin and it is becoming decidedly more unfriendly.

Human rights activists worry that tens of thousands of people will face Souverin’s plight in the coming weeks and months now that the Dominican government is pledging to deport non-citizens who did not submit applications to establish legal residency before Wednesday night’s deadline. Most of those affected are from neighboring Haiti or ofHaitian descent.

An estimated 460,000 Haitian migrants live in the Dominican Republic, which shares the Caribbean island of Hispaniola with Haiti. Officials have said nearly 290,000 people had enrolled in the immigration registration program, but only about 10,000 provided the required documents.

Many people had expected authorities to immediately start deporting people after the deadline passed, but the government said it would be a slow, developing process.

The repatriations are not going to be “a witch hunt,” Interior Minister Ramon Fadul said. “It will be a gradual process, as it should be, without any sudden surprises.”

But Dominican officials also warned that people should start carrying documents to prove they are legal residents, to avoid deportation in case authorities stop them.

Advocates for the migrants have criticized the registration plan as discriminatory regardless of the pace of deportations.

Dominican military officials and immigration agents have consistently raided communities with a high concentration of Haitians and detained people based on the way they look, said Wade McMullen, managing attorney for the Robert F. Kennedy Center for Justice and Human Rights in Washington.

“The Dominican Republic is shooting themselves in the foot, and it seems to be for short-term political gain,” he said in a phone interview. “Over the long term, they’re going to realize that there’s not only going to be a significant economic impact, but that the human toll is going to be even greater.”

One of those worrying about what will happen is 27-year-old Julio Mato, a moto-taxi driver who says he was born in the Dominican Republic to a Haitian mother and a Dominican father.

During an interview by phone, Mato said many people he knows are fearful of being deported, and added that he doesn’t understand why the Dominican Republic wants to chase off Haitians, who mainly work in low-wage jobs, often in construction and agriculture and as maids and gardeners.

“We live off the Haitians and the Haitians live off us,” he said.

Fadul expressed surprise at the number of people who sought to obtain legal residency, with dozens complaining they were turned away when the deadline expired at midnight Wednesday after standing in line for more than 24 hours.

“I don’t know why in recent days thousands of people have come,” he said, noting that the registration for legal residency began a year ago. “Who has brought them? Why didn’t they come before?”

On Friday, a community in the capital of Santo Domingo known as “Little Haiti” where hundreds of Haitian migrants buy and sell items was emptier than usual.

“Those who don’t have documents already left,” said Angela Marte, a Haitian migrant who said she was able to enroll in the registration program.

Even some of those who did register in the program have already been repatriated, according to Hilda Pena, coordinator of the human rights group Jano Sikse Border Network.

Authorities have “ripped up their papers and rounded them up,” she said.

The registration program began last June after legal challenges delayed its original launch in 2004. Non-citizens can qualify for legal residency if they can prove they have been in the Dominican Republic since before October 2011.

Souverin said he has lived in the Dominican Republic for nearly two decades and obtained an official document two years ago with help from a nonprofit organization only to have it seized at the border when he returned from a quick trip to Haiti.

He also accused school officials of seizing the papers of his Dominican-born children, forcing them to quit school, echoing a common complaint among migrants.

“I don’t like this one bit,” he said. “Why do they treat me this way?”

The government implemented the registration program amid international criticism of a 2013 decision by the Dominican Supreme Court that people born in the Dominican Republic to non-citizens did not qualify for citizenship under the constitution unless they had at least one parent who was a citizen or legal resident. The ruling rendered thousands effectively stateless. Officials said they will grant citizenship to some 50,000 people in this category.

Souverin is now one of nearly 50 deported migrants staying at the shelter in Haiti, including women who are breastfeeding their babies.

He said he doesn’t know what he is going to do or how he will provide for his family.

“I don’t have a house,” Souverin said. “I lost all my resources.”

___

Associated Press writer Evens Sanon reported this story in Fonbaya, Haiti, and Danica Coto reported from San Juan, Puerto Rico. AP writers Ezequiel Abiu Lopez in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, and Pierre Richard Luxama in Fonbaya contributed to this report.

Latest World News

Notable Replies

  1. Haitians Booted From Dominican Republic Face Uncertain Future

    Um, yeah, but the reason this is a problem is that a more accurate headline would be “Dominicans Booted From Dominican Republic Face Uncertain Future.”

    They have Haitian ancestry, but as you say, they were presumptively Dominican citizens by birth until all of a sudden they weren’t. The AP article here is fine, but the TPM headline could use some work.

  2. It’s seems Haitians can’t catch a break, from their independence to Papa Doc to the earthquake to now this. Having said that… they are by far the most resilient people ever.

  3. You know that this is true? The US is one of the few places that allows for anchor babies. The DR does not. Citizenship does not happen in civilized countries because you show up and try to get on the dole, like in the US.

  4. Haiti has one problem that the DR does not have - overpopulation. The ability of the Haitian government to provide policies and products to allow citizens to control their own fertility is absent. This means that Haiti is in a horrible mess due to overpopulation. The Catholic Church is partially to blame. The DR is catholic as well. Haiti should make IMMEDIATE steps to allow all persons to have birth control methods.

  5. Sorry I could only like this once!
    You heard about the passing of Regnad Kcin?

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

1 more reply

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for nickdanger Avatar for semiotix Avatar for notborneveryminute Avatar for canadian

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: