The Latest
Just Another Lawless Monday
This is your TPM evening briefing.
04.14.25 | 6:43 pm
Bukele’s Offense Against the American People
04.14.25 | 2:41 pm

Here’s how I look at today’s White House spectacle.

I don’t really care what these two men say. The only next step I’m focused on is the one that now faces the Supreme Court. The White House is now brazenly ignoring the crystal clear import and goal of the Court’s order which is not to facilitate merely the return of Mr. Abrego Garcia, but his “release from custody in El Salvador.” The Court will now rapidly have to decide whether to knuckle under to this institutional humiliation or stand its ground. I don’t know which course it will choose. But I am very eager to find out.

Nayib Bukele is actively and publicly conspiring not only to violate American domestic law but the orders of American courts. El Salvador is a minor power, essentially a city-state, which even in our current degraded state requires the friendship and almost always the aid of the United States. Bukele is interfering not only in American domestic politics but the American legal and constitutional process. These are grave offenses against the sovereignty of the American people and the American constitutional order.

Trump won’t be in power forever. The next Democratic administration won’t be like the last one. He needs to know that, and the consequences of that, today.

Any Democratic politician who doesn’t understand this and say as much publicly should have no future in elected office.

What Are Universities Supposed to Do? Prime Badge
04.14.25 | 2:19 pm

I’ve heard from a number of you in response to my posts about the fate of universities in the Trump era. I’ve published a couple of these responses below and I’ll post more. They are fascinating and illuminating replies. Most are generally supportive. A few are in the category of “Dude, you have no idea what you’re talking about.” But there are a number which I would put in the category of, “I agree. The universities have to fight. But I’m not sure you get how big a bloodbath we’re talking about.”

I wanted to expand on those earlier posts. And much of this will be meant to address that last category of responses.

I haven’t been directly involved in university life for a couple decades. So there are lots of details I don’t know, and plenty of things I didn’t learn during my time as a grad student and TA. But I think I do get the broad outlines. I know that what we’re talking about is full of risks, probable damage and levels of damage that are existential. So let me expand on what I’ve said by distilling points I’ve made in most of these email exchanges with readers over the last several days. To be clear, this isn’t meant as any sort of manifesto: just a distillation of what I think and some additional detail that expands on those earlier posts.

Most of what I said in these exchanges came down to five points.

Trump, Bukele Condemn Abrego Garcia to Prison On Live TV
The government has admitted that Abrego Garcia was wrongly removed. It's now flouting SCOTUS to keep him imprisoned.
04.14.25 | 2:01 pm
A Slo-Mo Constitutional Clash Is Already Well Underway
INSIDE: Khalil ... Ozturk ... Bondi
04.14.25 | 9:57 am
On the Role of the Universities #2
04.14.25 | 9:25 am

From TPM Reader XX …

Sometimes analogies illuminate but sometimes they don’t.  Docs go into the business knowing the high likelihood of confronting danger-to-oneself at some point over career, if not from a pandemic than from a “routine” infectious agent that takes a virulent turn.  Universities at least in the US are not built and financed in a way to take account of the risk of an authoritarian “burn it down” mood in the national leadership which is prepared to proceed in a lawless, destructive way.  

Read More
On the Role of Universities #1
04.14.25 | 9:23 am

From TPM Reader CA …

Thank you very much for the piece on universities.  The connection you draw between social authority and public goods is exactly right.  Indeed, their status of tax-exempt non-profits depends on a version of this bargain.  But I would add to your analysis a problem that I think exists as a condition of possibility for the war being waged by the Trump administration.  This is the twofold shift that took place c. 1980, regarding who pays for education and who benefits from research.

Read More
About Those Law Firm Deals
04.14.25 | 12:11 am

From TPM Reader AK …

Just read your posts about this. I realize that law is quaint right now, and I haven’t researched the details. Maybe I’m missing something basic, or alternatively maybe it’s just so obvious that nobody is bothering to say it. But if Trump is extorting millions of dollars of value in his *personal* capacity in consideration for taking or desisting from taking official government action, that seems like a textbook definition of bribery or some other form of criminal misconduct, presumably with no official immunity. 

Read More
Gov’s Mansion Firebombing
04.13.25 | 10:26 pm

You probably saw the reports that there was an arson attempt of some sort at the Pennsylvania governor’s mansion last night on the first night of Passover. The original reports, at least the ones I saw, did not capture the gravity of what happened. “Firebombing” would be the only accurate way to describe the photos released this afternoon by the governor’s office. It’s possible that the original accounts provided to local media themselves didn’t capture the scale of the incident. A late afternoon press conference described it in more detail and released video and photographs. You can see the full collection of photos here. I’m republishing four of them below.

Read More