The Justice Department announced this week that it will soon start investigating violent threats against school teachers and school board members around the country — a concerning trend that escalated in recent months as students returned to the classroom amid a lingering pandemic and GOP-instigated culture wars violently boiled over during school board meetings across the U.S.
Continue reading “Where Things Stand: DOJ Will Probe Violent Threats Against Teachers, School Board Members”The Jan. 6 Select Committee & Disinformation: Start Pre-bunking The Lies Now
This article is part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis.
The U.S. House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol is likely to run headlong into the same kinds of high-volume, toxic disinformation that fueled the insurrection itself. Because fact-finding takes considerable time and resources, and lies are fast and cheap, the Select Committee’s work risks being submerged by a tidal flood of BS, jeopardizing any institutional impact its findings might hold, not to mention accountability for the insurrection’s ultimate ringleaders.
If the Select Committee is unable to get ahead of those lies, or fails to find its own voice, its work faces the worst fate of all: being ignored. Fortunately, the Select Committee has a ripe slice of history to learn from.
While the 9/11 Commission, Ken Starr’s independent counsel probe into the Clinton administration, and Robert Mueller’s special counsel investigation examined different problems in different administrations, each holds lessons for breaking through the noise and BS with an accurate and official narrative of events. The Select Committee on January 6th can look to its investigative predecessors as it works to understand and explain what led to that violent moment in our history and how we can avoid its repeat — all while leaning on the recent work of disinformation researchers studying how best to tackle lies aimed at our democracy.
Comprehensive fact-finding and truth-telling are essential steps towards preventing a recurrence of political violence. Attempts to derail this vital work by those scared of the truth, or trapped in wells of disinformation, will arguably pose the most corrosive challenge to this exercise in accountability. That’s why it’s so important for the Select Committee to immediately begin “pre-bunking,” or proactively framing its work against a predictable pipeline of lies. As any disinformation expert can tell you, waiting to debunk lies until after they’re told gives the falsehoods time to take root, making it far harder for the truth to prevail.
Pre-bunking will require that the select committee transparently and powerfully tell the story of its work. This in turn suggests a need to proactively translate fact-finding for the public. The 9/11 Commission, tasked with investigating al Qaeda’s coordinated attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, smartly hired a writer to help it make its work legible to all Americans. As a result, the commission’s report “won the respect of the American public as much for its literary qualities as for the findings of the 9/11 commissioners,” wrote Craig A. Warren, author of “It Reads Like a Novel: The “9/11 Commission Report” and the American Reading Public. The report proved to be a national bestseller.
Despite the body count of January 6th, and an absolute dearth of evidence that fraud marred the 2020 election, proponents of the Big Lie continue to lay siege to our democracy. From former president Donald Trump on down, the Big Lie is now a central feature of some Republicans’ political identities. This is evident in the discredited election “audit” in Maricopa County, Arizona, the efforts by a handful of states to hamstring nonpartisan elections administrators, and the ongoing comments by members of Congress like Rep. Madison Cawthorn, the North Carolina Republican who has threatened “bloodshed” around future elections. Others, like Rep. Andrew Clyde, a Republican from Georgia, compared the rioting on Jan. 6 to a “normal tourist visit” in a bald attempt to diminish its importance — or sweep it into the memory hole.
With the nation’s leading disinformers flooding airwaves with lies, it is not enough that the select committee conduct a thorough investigation and hope that it is well-received; it must make the results of its investigative work as accessible to the public as possible. In addition to hiring professional communicators to translate one of the most complex congressional investigations in recent history for easy public consumption, the committee should press forward with this translation work in real-time, not just after the conclusion of its efforts.
Which brings us to the Ken Starr investigation.
While then-Independent Counsel Ken Starr was hammered for running an investigation into President Bill Clinton that meandered around various allegations for years, and absorbed near daily criticism from partisans aligned with the Clintons, he also made considerable efforts to prevent others from characterizing his investigation. Starr held press conferences and regularly answered questions about the direction of his investigation, sometimes from the foot of his driveway. While he was criticized for self-aggrandizement, his communication efforts offer lessons for the Select Committee. It can take the good from Starr’s example (steady flow of information to the public) without the bad (making itself rather than its investigation the star of the story). In other words, in addition to scheduled public hearings, the Select Committee should prioritize regular news conferences to help the American public follow along with what it is learning, prevent disinformation from dictating the coverage of its investigation, and keep the focus on the events and causes of January 6th.
Failure to translate findings proactively and on an ongoing basis will put at risk the results of the investigation itself. The Mueller Report offers a forewarning.
In 2017, former FBI Director Robert Mueller was named a special counsel to investigate Russian interference in the 2016 election, and potential links between the Trump campaign and Russian officials. Some two years later, Mueller’s report was released. In the intervening time Mueller and his team avoided speaking about their work, and made little effort to counter disinformation.
Their silence, in effect, gave others the opportunity to mischaracterize their investigation, including a steady stream of detractors on cable news and, most destructively, then-Attorney General William Barr, who misrepresented the report before its public release and muted its devastating findings, including multiple efforts to obstruct justice.
In truth’s battle against lies, silence is disinformation’s best ally.
Jon Steinman is a communicator at Protect Democracy, a nonpartisan nonprofit working to prevent American democracy from declining into a more authoritarian form of government.
5 Points On The Newly Released Testimony Of Rudy! Sidney! And The Big Lie Gang
A mass of documents gathered in the course of a defamation lawsuit against the proponents of the Big Lie is out, providing depositions with those who led the fight to overturn last year’s election and records that shed new light on the effort.
Continue reading “5 Points On The Newly Released Testimony Of Rudy! Sidney! And The Big Lie Gang”Police Killings In The US Have Been Undercounted By More Than Half In Official Statistics
This article is part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis. It first appeared at The Conversation.
The number of people killed by police officers in the U.S. has been massively underreported in official statistics over the past four decades, with an additional 17,000 deaths over that period, according to our new research.
Continue reading “Police Killings In The US Have Been Undercounted By More Than Half In Official Statistics”Don’t Be Surprised About Facebook and Teen Girls. That’s What Facebook Is.
You’ve probably seen the latest controversy about Facebook/Instagram leading vulnerable teenagers to anorexia, fat-shaming content that seems almost designed to send teenage girls and some boys into spirals of self-loathing and unsafe behaviors. What jumps out to me about this latest controversy is that most people still don’t grasp that things like this are close to inevitable because of what Facebook is. It’s foundational to the product. It is not surprising.
Let me explain. First, set aside all morality. Let’s say we have a 16 year old girl who’s been doing searches about average weights, whether boys care if a girl is overweight and maybe some diets. She’s also spent some time on a site called AmIFat.com. Now I set you this task. You’re on the other side of the Facebook screen and I want you to get her to click on as many things as possible and spend as much time clicking or reading as possible. Are you going to show her movie reviews? Funny cat videos? Homework tips? Of course, not. If you’re really trying to grab her attention you’re going to show her content about really thin girls, how their thinness has gotten them the attention of boys who turn out to really love them, and more diets. If you’re clever you probably wouldn’t start with content that’s going to make this 16 year old feel super bad about herself because that might just get her to log off. You’ll inspire or provoke enough negative feelings to get clicks and engagement without going too far.
Continue reading “Don’t Be Surprised About Facebook and Teen Girls. That’s What Facebook Is.”Trump DOJ’er Jeffrey Clark Should Face Probe For Role In Election Theft Attempt, Lawyers Say
A group of high-profile lawyers on Tuesday called for the Washington, D.C. Court of Appeals to investigate Jeffrey Clark, a former Department of Justice official, for his efforts to have the DOJ declare the 2020 election results unreliable.
Continue reading “Trump DOJ’er Jeffrey Clark Should Face Probe For Role In Election Theft Attempt, Lawyers Say”Are We Heading to a Debt Default Filibuster Carve-out?
I’m starting to think this latest bout of debt limit hostage taking will end with a filibuster carve out. On its face that seems highly improbable given the resistance through the year from Manchin and Sinema. And I think Manchin has said no way to this specifically. So it seems really improbable. But we’re down to very improbable outcomes and this is starting to seem like the least improbable one.
Let’s walk through the scenarios.
Continue reading “Are We Heading to a Debt Default Filibuster Carve-out?”The Work Continues After Progressives Rescue Two-Track Infrastructure Plan
Negotiations over the $3.5 trillion reconciliation bill for President Joe Biden’s Build Back Better plan are back on after House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) ultimately declined to bring the bipartisan infrastructure bill (BIF) to a vote last week due to progressives’ threat to sink it if it were put to a vote before the reconciliation package is ready.
The White House and Democratic leaders are working to hammer out a deal with Sens. Joe Manchin (D-WV) and Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ), who both complain that the price for reconciliation — $3.5 trillion — is too high. Manchin’s put his top line at $1.5 trillion, and Sinema has yet to say publicly what she wants.
Pelosi told her Democratic colleagues on Saturday that she wants to pass BIF before October 31.
Follow our live coverage below:
Bar Complaint Filed Against Coup-Planning Lawyer John Eastman In California
Disbarment For Couping?
A nonpartisan election integrity group is demanding an investigation into whether John Eastman, the conservative legal scholar who mapped out a potential plan for then-Vice President Mike Pence to steal the 2020 election for Trump, engaged in professional misconduct.
- The States United Democracy Center sent a letter to the California bar association on Monday requesting that the state bar examine whether Eastman “violated his ethical obligations as an attorney by filing frivolous claims, making false statements and engaging in deceptive conduct.”
- The letter’s signatories included two former California Supreme Court justices plus an ex-GOP governor and an Obama official.
- “Is it now a disbarrable offense to engage in political speech, First Amendment protected?” Eastman asked in response to the group’s complaint while hinting that he might fire back with a defamation suit.
- The bar complaint comes as other Trumpland lawyers, including Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell, face bar investigations for misusing the courts to overturn the election.
Garland Defends DOJ’s Handling Of Jan. 6 Insurrectionist Cases
Attorney General Merrick Garland is on the defensive after observers (including a judge) criticized what they see as prosecutors’ kid glove treatment of the people who stormed the Capitol on Jan. 6.
- The prosecutors are “making determinations in every case about what charge fits the offense, what charge fits the law,” Garland argued during a discussion at The New Yorker Festival on Monday.
- The criticism is “part of the territory for any prosecutor in any case,” the attorney general added.
Sinema Gets Confronted By Activists Again
Protesters greeted Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport yesterday after she returned from a trip to her home state for a medical appointment (according to her office) and a fundraiser in Phoenix:
During Sinema’s flight, a woman claiming to be a DACA recipient tried to talk to the senator about using the reconciliation bill to build a pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants.
- The activist asks Sinema to commit to including immigration reform in the legislation. The senator largely ignored her.
- New York Times opinion writer Michelle Goldberg’s latest column has an incredible anecdote about Sinema organizing a protest against then-Sen. Joe Lieberman (D-CT) in 2003, whom she called “a shame to Democrats.”
- “I don’t even know why he’s running,” Sinema said at the time. “He seems to want to get Republicans voting for him — what kind of strategy is that?”
Top State Official Blasts Biden’s Trumpian Treatment Of Haitian Migrants
Harold Koh, a political appointee at the State Department who is leaving his position as a senior legal adviser, has circulated a memo internally blasting the Biden administration’s “inhumane” expulsions of Haitian migrants at the border via Trump’s Title 42 policy.
- Koh pointed to Biden’s declaration that the shocking images of Border Patrol agents charging at migrants on horseback were “not who we are.”
- “The same could be said of current illegal and inhumane policy of Title 42 expulsions,” Koh wrote. “It simply is not worthy of this Administration that I so strongly support.”
- Koh’s internal memo came less than two weeks after the U.S. special envoy to Haiti, Daniel Foote, resigned in protest over the Biden administration’s “deeply flawed” policies on Haitian refugees.
- “I will not be associated with the United States inhumane, counterproductive decision to deport thousands of Haitian refugees and illegal immigrants to Haiti, a country where American officials are confined to secure compounds because of the danger posed by armed gangs to daily life,” Foote wrote in a particularly blistering letter to Secretary of State Antony Blinken.
Facebook Goes Kaput
Facebook, along with its other services (Instagram, WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger), went down for more than five hours yesterday, a tragic day for COVID-19 vaccine truthers:
- More seriously, this New York Times article lays out the disturbing extent to which the global population depends on Facebook and its apps, particularly WhatsApp.
- The crash came the day before Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen’s scheduled Senate hearing today to testify on how Facebook and its products “harm children,” “stoke division” and “weaken our democracy” by amplifying misinformation and extremism, according to her opening statement.
- Haugen gave a blockbuster interview on “60 Minutes” where she explained how Facebook failed to prevent the spread of the extremism that led to the Jan. 6 Capitol insurrection.
Desantis’ Wife Is Diagnosed With Cancer
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) announced yesterday that his wife, Casey, has been diagnosed with breast cancer.
Curiosities Across The Pond
Can our British readers please explain what Boris Johnson’s trying to do here?
Do you like Morning Memo? Let us know!
Where Things Stand: An Insider Account Of Facebook In The Days Before The Insurrection
Facebook, Instagram and other applications owned by the social media giant are all down today. The company is describing the outage as “networking issues,” while tech sleuths and new reports suggest the problem might be bigger than that.
I won’t speculate on technology as I know nothing about technology. But the outage comes just one day after a previously anonymous former Facebook executive and whistleblower went on “60 Minutes” to make new allegations concerning the company’s apathy about the dangerous spread of far-right disinformation on the platform.
Continue reading “Where Things Stand: An Insider Account Of Facebook In The Days Before The Insurrection”