The Legend of the Mudville Muckrakers, TPM’s Short-Lived Softball Team

Upon entering TPM’s New York City Global Headquarters, you won’t be greeted by a smiling receptionist, but rather a curious, and perhaps ominous, well-worn, black metallic softball bat.

“What’s with the bat?” is a common and justifiable-enough question. Sports aren’t very high on the cultural affinity list at TPM. Just recently, the company had an all-hands meeting to explain how a “tournament bracket” works.

But there’s a story behind that softball bat, one that is somewhat lost to time. And while the memories have dimmed, the legend has only grown. This is the story of the TPM Muckrakers. No, not the investigative journalism unit. The barnstormin’ company softball team, active circa 2011-2012.

 


 

The Muckrakers appear to have been the brainchild of Eric Lach, a swift-footed pitcher and raker of muck whose softball career in some ways mirrors his journalism career. A veteran of both the formidable New Yorker and The Nation softball teams, he brought his front-office skills to TPM. Having played for the New Yorker squad, he was aware of the primary challenges a media softball team faces in the Big City.

“The tricky thing with New York media softball is that field permits take forever to get, so if you’re a start-up club you have to find legacy outlets with their legacy permits to challenge to games,” said Lach, currently a staff writer back at The New Yorker.

Maybe it’s the nature of The Journalist or maybe TPMers are very into records requests and this was a quasi-record request, but nearly everyone your faithful correspondents spoke with mentioned field permits. To contextualize this, nobody was even quite sure how many games had been played or even how many seasons The Muckrakers played. But they were all familiar with the field-permit situation.

Permission to play ball acquired, the Muckrakers would hit the field in snazzy red unis complete with nicknames — despite the fact that they weren’t actually part of the formal media softball league and primarily served as an alternate squad to fill in when needed. Anyone familiar with the dress code at TPM World HQ would be forgiven for being caught off guard by the apparent “It’s not whather you win or lose, but how you dress for the game” approach. But, all things considered, probably the best approach. The uniforms are unequivocally fabulous, and if your correspondents has his way, will be revived in the merch store soon.

But we digress…

Contemporaneous documents point to an early win, which hopefully the Muckrackers savored because there weren’t many more to come. Not for lack of effort, surely. But eye-witnesses suggest TPM was fighting an uphill battle in the strategy and tactics departments.

Alum Chris O’Driscoll remembers they played two games in 2012 — one against The Nation1 and one more against their rivals at the New Yorker.

“What I remember about the games I played in 2012 was that it was a lot of fun but we definitely lost. Hard,” O’Driscoll said.

“I think one of our only runs in the game against The New Yorker came from Michael Lester, who kept asking how similar baseball was to cricket. I think that’s a pretty good indicator of our skill level at the time.”

David Taintor, who has the unique perspective of having played on the softball team and now being back at TPM, remembers the New Yorker cartoonists as especially good.

When asked if any of the Muckrakers athletic or physical prowess stands out in his memory, Taintor said, “hmm … nobody comes to mind.”

As with all quasi-mythical origin stories, contemporaneous accounts of this franchise are often contradictory, fantastical, and wonderous. And given that neither of us are Muckrakers in either the softball or journalistic sense, our fact-finding attempts often left us stranded on first. That is until an email arrived in our inbox written by Lach, a founding member of the team and its former pitcher. The email contained a recap he had written of a game between the newly minted TPM Muckrakers and the storied New Yorker Small Fries. It takes us back to a summer evening in 2011 and gives an unvarnished look at what the young and nervy TPM squad was made of. Lach had delivered:

Dated: June 22, 2011

It is a little-known fact that Mudville, that famed baseball town, was once a Manhattan neighborhood. It’s true. Those who still whisper about such things blame overzealous real estate agents, who changed the name to Flatiron in the 1950s. It is further speculated that the Mudville nine’s field itself stood on the spot where Eataly stands today. The prosciutto stand was once home plate. The wine bar, a pitcher’s mound.

Whether they knew it or not, it was this legacy that the TPM Muckrakers carried with them as they crowded into an uptown F train last night, headed for their first softball game. At the sight of so many bright red jerseys, cowed onlookers were heard to exclaim “excuse me” and “watch it” and “stop blocking the doorway, asshole.” 

The anxiety and anticipation was palpable. Some asked how many innings the game would go (7). Others wanted to know if stealing bases was allowed (no). Still others brought guitars (rock on). But no one was lost on the journey up to Central Park, and that would prove to be the first of the evening’s many small victories. 

The Muckrakers’ opponents, The New Yorker Small Fries, were a seasoned bunch, and the game would need almost every minute of good sunlight left in the longest day of the year. Things got off to a good start in the top of the 1st inning, when Erik “Hard” Hinton tripled to lead off the game. He then scored on a sacrifice fly from Jon “Terbo” Terbush. Josh “Mogul!” Marshall, a player-owner of the old school, then singled, but was stranded on base. The bottom of the 1st saw some solid defense, proving the Muckrakers were up to preserving a lead — at least for a little while — and the inning ended with a nice 6-3 put out from Marshall and Hinton. 

After only being able to muster a single from Bruce “Dunphy” Ellerstein in the top of the 2nd inning, the bottom of the inning saw the Small Fries score 3, handing the Muckrakers their first ever deficit. Neither team scored in the 3rd inning, and the Muckraker pitcher, pending free agent Eric “IIBNOI” Lach, bounced back nicely from the previous inning’s shellacking, catching a comebacker at the mound and retiring the side after just three batters.

In the 4th inning, the Muckrakers’ bats fell silent, and the Small Fries squeaked in a run. The Muckrakers’ bats were quiet through the 6th, when the Small Fries scored again, extending their lead to 5-1. (These innings were not totally lost: singles were managed by Versha “Bonk!” Sharma and Zoe “Zslice” Schlanger.)

Then came the 7th. It is here that we may again recall Mudville, tragic Mudville. Eric “Cool.” Buth singled, and then Lach, despite taking around a dozen pitches, fouled out for the second out of the inning. But Michael “Orange Freeze” Corjulo hit a double, and then mighty, mighty Megan “Onion” Reback stepped up and singled, scoring Buth. Hinton followed with a double, and then scored on a single from Terbush — tying the game. The bench cheered. A major chord was strummed. Could Mudville be avenged?

The Muckrakers preserved the lead in the bottom of the 7th. Lach made a diving catch at the mound, and Reback handled a pop up to finish off the inning. 

It is best not to dwell on what happened during extra innings — especially for the pitcher. Singles from Paul “PW” Werdel and David “DT” Taintor fell in the top of the inning, but no runs crossed the plate. In the bottom of the inning, well, the Small Fries scored. Enough said.

There is a victory hidden in this defeat. For today joy has returned to Mudville. The Muckrakers proved that they are made of tough stuff, and that is something. Surely, an early season stumble is nothing for a team so loaded with talent. Your correspondent, for one, pities the TPM’s next opponent. 

Final Score: 

TPM Muckrakers 5, The New Yorker Small Fries 6 

MVP:

Megan “Onion” Reback

Guitar of the game:

Eric Kleefeld

1 Games notes written by E.L. Villard McWilliams of the Nation and acquired by TPM describe a 15-6 win for the Nats over the Muckrakers. McWilliams credits the Muckrakers with a never-give-up attitude and gives nods for “providing their own musical accompaniment of a strolling guitar playing minstrel” and “great esprit de corps at the Paris Café post game.” The kindness stops there, however, for McWilliams headlined his writeup: NATIONals TP ‘em.

US Strikes Deal With Pfizer To Secure Additional 100 Million COVID Vaccine Doses

WASHINGTON (AP) — Pfizer and BioNTech will supply the U.S. with an additional 100 million doses of their COVID-19 vaccine under a second agreement.

The drugmakers said Wednesday that they expect to deliver all the doses by July 31.

Pfizer already has a contract to supply the government with 100 million doses of its vaccine, which requires two doses per patient.

Continue reading “US Strikes Deal With Pfizer To Secure Additional 100 Million COVID Vaccine Doses”

Trump Attacks ‘Mitch’s Boy’ Sen. Thune For Pooh-Poohing Electoral College Challenge

President Donald Trump on Tuesday continued to attack members of his own party, calling Senate Majority Whip John Thune (R-SD) a “RINO” after the senator suggested that any effort by a fledgling group of Trump loyalists to object to Electoral College votes reaffirming the win of President-elect Joe Biden during a joint session next month will be immediately shot down.

Continue reading “Trump Attacks ‘Mitch’s Boy’ Sen. Thune For Pooh-Poohing Electoral College Challenge”

The True Toll

This is the ultimate measure of the COVID pandemic in the United States: at least 400,000 more Americans died in 2020 than died in 2019. The total is about 3.2 million, the first time it’s ever been more than 3 million. Not all of those deaths were due to COVID infections. The official COVID death toll is currently around 320,000. But virtually all are due to the pandemic – both COVID infections and collateral impact, which can range from acute stress (grief, economic dislocation) to degraded quality of medical care and myriad impacts of everything that has happened this last year.

If we transport ourselves back to those first weeks in January and February, when COVID was a thing happening in China that over time seemed more and more likely to end up in the US, this is what we could have known: that the impact would mean more than 400,000 people in the US would end up dying who wouldn’t otherwise have died in 2020.

US Deaths In 2020 Top 3 Million, Far Exceeding Most Ever Counted

NEW YORK (AP) — This is the deadliest year in U.S. history, with deaths expected to top 3 million for the first time — due mainly to the coronavirus pandemic.

Final mortality data for this year will not be available for months. But preliminary numbers suggest that the United States is on track to see more than 3.2 million deaths this year, or at least 400,000 more than in 2019.

U.S. deaths increase most years, so some annual rise in fatalities is expected. But the 2020 numbers amount to a jump of about 15%, and could go higher once all the deaths from this month are counted.

That would mark the largest single-year percentage leap since 1918, when tens of thousands of U.S. soldiers died in World War I and hundreds of thousands of Americans died in a flu pandemic. Deaths rose 46% that year, compared with 1917.

COVID-19 has killed more than 318,000 Americans and counting. Before it came along, there was reason to be hopeful about U.S. death trends.

The nation’s overall mortality rate fell a bit in 2019, due to reductions in heart disease and cancer deaths. And life expectancy inched up — by several weeks — for the second straight year, according to death certificate data released Tuesday by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

But life expectancy for 2020 could end up dropping as much as three full years, said Robert Anderson of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

The CDC counted 2,854,838 U.S. deaths last year, or nearly 16,000 more than 2018. That’s fairly good news: Deaths usually rise by about 20,000 to 50,000 each year, mainly due to the nation’s aging, and growing, population.

Indeed, the age-adjusted death rate dropped about 1% in 2019, and life expectancy rose by about six weeks to 78.8 years, the CDC reported.

“It was actually a pretty good year for mortality, as things go,” said Anderson, who oversees CDC death statistics.

The U.S. coronavirus epidemic has been a big driver of deaths this year, both directly and indirectly.

The virus was first identified in China last year, and the first U.S. cases were reported this year. But it has become the third leading cause of death, behind only heart disease and cancer. For certain periods this year, COVID-19 was the No. 1 killer.

But some other types of deaths also have increased.

A burst of pneumonia cases early this year may have been COVID-19 deaths that simply weren’t recognized as such early in the epidemic. But there also have been an unexpected number of deaths from certain types of heart and circulatory diseases, diabetes and dementia, Anderson said.

Many of those, too, may be related to COVID. The virus could have weakened patients already struggling with those conditions, or could have diminished the care they were getting, he said.

Early in the epidemic, some were optimistic that car crash deaths would drop as people stopped commuting or driving to social events. Data on that is not yet in, but anecdotal reports suggest there was no such decline.

Suicide deaths dropped in 2019 compared with 2018, but early information suggests they have not continued to drop this year, Anderson and others said.

Drug overdose deaths, meanwhile, got much worse.

Before the coronavirus even arrived, the U.S. was in the midst of the deadliest drug overdose epidemic in its history.

Data for all of 2020 is not yet available. But last week the CDC reported more than 81,000 drug overdose deaths in the 12 months ending in May, making it the highest number ever recorded in a one-year period.

Experts think the pandemic’s disruption to in-person treatment and recovery services may have been a factor. People also are more likely to be taking drugs alone — without the benefit of a friend or family member who can call 911 or administer overdose-reversing medication.

But perhaps a bigger factor are the drugs themselves: COVID-19 caused supply problems for dealers, so they are increasingly mixing cheap and deadly fentanyl into heroin, cocaine and methamphetamine, experts said.

“I don’t suspect there are a bunch of new people who suddenly started using drugs because of COVID. If anything, I think the supply of people who are already using drugs is more contaminated,” said Shannon Monnat, a Syracuse University researcher who studies drug overdose trends.

___

The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

Trump Demands Congress Increase ‘Ridiculously Low’ Stimulus Checks To $2,000

President Donald Trump on Tuesday night demanded that Congress increase the “ridiculously low” stimulus checks to millions of Americans in the COVID relief bill, calling the nearly $900 billion legislation passed by Congress a day before “a disgrace.”

Trump went as far as to suggest he would not immediately sign off on the much-needed aid package that has been stalled for months to deliver relief to millions of Americans, calling on Congress in a video posted to Twitter to increase stimulus checks to Americans from $600 to $2,000. 

Continue reading “Trump Demands Congress Increase ‘Ridiculously Low’ Stimulus Checks To $2,000”

Dominion Worker Sues Trump Campaign, Newsmax, OANN Following Death Threats

NEW YORK (AP) — An election systems worker driven into hiding by death threats has filed a defamation lawsuit against President Donald Trump’s campaign, two of its lawyers and some conservative media figures and outlets.

Eric Coomer, security director at the Colorado-based Dominion Voting Systems, said he wants his life back after being named in false charges as a key actor in “rigging” the election for President-elect Joe Biden. There has been no evidence that the election was rigged.

His lawsuit, filed Tuesday in district court in Denver County, Colorado, names the Trump campaign, lawyers Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell, conservative columnist Michelle Malkin, the website Gateway Pundit, Colorado conservative activist Joseph Oltmann, and conservative media Newsmax and One America News Network.

“I have been thrust into the public spotlight by people with political and financial agendas but, at heart, I am a private person,” Coomer said in a statement.

“While I intend to do everything I can to recapture my prior lifestyle, I have few illusions in this regard,” he said. “And so, today, I put my trust in the legal process, which has already exposed the truth of the 2020 presidential election.”

Dominion, which provided vote-counting equipment to several states, has denied accusations that it switched Trump votes in Biden’s favor, and no evidence has emerged to back those charges up.

Dominion and another voting technology company, Smartmatic, have begun to fight back against being named in baseless conspiracy theories. After legal threats were made, Fox News Channel and Newsmax in recent days have aired retractions of some claims made on their networks.

There was no immediate comment from those named in the lawsuit.

His lawyers said Coomer has become “the face of the false claims.” Coomer’s name first got public exposure in a podcast by Oltmann, who claimed to have heard a strategy call of Antifa activists. When the prospect of a Trump victory was brought up, Oltmann said a man identified as “Eric from Dominion” supposedly said “don’t worry about the election, Trump is not going to win. I made … sure of that,” adding an expletive.

In an opinion piece written for the Denver Post, Coomer wrote that he has no connections to Antifa, was never on any call and the idea that there is some recording of him is “wholly fabricated.”

The fact-checking website Snopes said Oltmann hasn’t cooperated in any attempts to verify his claims.

Oltmann also claimed that Coomer made anti-Trump comments on Facebook. The lawsuit acknowledged that Coomer made comments critical of the president on his private Facebook page; he now says his page is inactive.

Oltmann’s charges spread after he was interviewed by Malkin and Gateway Pundit. Eric Trump tweeted about them. OANN, and its White House correspondent Chanel Rion, reported on them. Powell, misidentifying Coomer as working for Smartmatic, said at a news conference that Coomer’s “social media is filled with hatred” for Trump, and she later repeated her charges in a Newsmax interview.

Giuliani, at a news conference, called Coomer “a vicious, vicious man. He wrote horrible things about the president … He is completely warped,” according to the lawsuit.

Fox News Channel, another network popular with Trump supporters, is not being sued and Coomer actually uses Fox’s Tucker Carlson to buttress his case. The lawsuit notes a scheduled Powell appearance on Carlson’s show did not happen after she could not provide evidence for her charges.

Coomer told The Associated Press earlier this month that right-wing websites posted his photo, home address and details about his family. Death threats began almost immediately.

He said his father, an Army veteran, received a handwritten letter asking, “How does it feel to have a traitor for a son.”

“It’s terrifying,” Coomer said. “I’ve worked in international elections in all sorts of post-conflict countries where election violence is real and people are getting killed over it. And I feel that we’re on the verge of that.”

Trump Goes Whole Hog, Grants Pardons For House Allies And Russia Probe Figures

President Trump went on pardon tear Tuesday night as his presidency wanes, with the White House announcing grants of clemency for key figures in the 2016 Russia investigation and for congressional allies of Trump who were prosecuted during his administration.

Continue reading “Trump Goes Whole Hog, Grants Pardons For House Allies And Russia Probe Figures”

DOJ Sues Walmart Over Role In Opioid Crisis

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department sued Walmart on Tuesday, accusing it of fueling the nation’s opioid crisis by pressuring its pharmacies to fill even potentially suspicious prescriptions for the powerful painkillers.

The civil complaint filed points to the role Walmart’s pharmacies may have played in the crisis by filling opioid prescriptions and Walmart’s own responsibility for the allegedly illegal distribution of controlled substances to the pharmacies at the height of the opioid crisis. Walmart operates more than 5,000 pharmacies in its stores around the country.

The Justice Department alleges Walmart violated federal law by selling thousands of prescriptions for controlled substances that its pharmacists “knew were invalid,” said Jeffrey Clark, the acting assistant attorney general in charge of the Justice Department’s civil division.

Federal law required Walmart to spot suspicious orders for controlled substances and report those to the Drug Enforcement Administration, but prosecutors charge the company didn’t do that.

“Walmart knew that its distribution centers were using an inadequate system for detecting and reporting suspicious orders,” said Jason Dunn, the U.S. attorney in Colorado. “For years, Walmart reported virtually no suspicious orders at all. In other words, Walmart’s pharmacies ordered opioids in a way that went essentially unmonitored and unregulated.”

The 160-page suit alleges that Walmart made it difficult for its pharmacists to follow the rules, putting “enormous pressure” on them to fill a high volume of prescriptions as fast as possible, while at the same time denying them the authority to categorically refuse to fill prescriptions issued by prescribers the pharmacists knew were continually issuing invalid invalid prescriptions.

The suit highlighted alleged problems in Walmart’s compliance department, which oversaw the dispensing nationwide of controlled substance prescriptions. In particular, even after Walmart pharmacists informed the compliance unit about “pill-mill” prescribers whose practices raised egregious red flags, Walmart allegedly continued to fill invalid prescriptions issued by those prescribers, according to the suit. The suit said that only later did Walmart allow pharmacists to do blanket refusals for these suspect practices.

Walmart fought back in an emailed statement to The Associated Press, saying that the Justice Department’s investigation is “tainted by historical ethics violations.” It said the “lawsuit invents a legal theory that unlawfully forces pharmacists to come between patients and their doctors, and is riddled with factual inaccuracies and cherry-picked documents taken out of context.”

Walmart noted it always empowered its pharmacists to refuse to fill problematic opioids prescriptions, and said they refused to fill hundreds of thousands of such prescriptions. Walmart also noted it sent the Drug Enforcement Administration tens of thousands of investigative leads, and it blocked thousands of questionable doctors from having their opioid prescriptions filled at its pharmacies.

In a corporate blog post published late Tuesday, Walmart argued that many health regulators, medical groups, doctors and patients criticize the company for going too far in refusing to fill opioid prescriptions. Some even say Walmart is improperly interfering in the doctor-patient relationship, the company said.

AP reported the news of the lawsuit ahead of the Justice Department’s public announcement, citing a person who could not discuss the matter publicly before the announced move. The person spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity.

Walmart filed its own preemptive suit against the Justice Department, Attorney General William Barr and the Drug Enforcement Administration nearly two months ago.

In its lawsuit, Walmart said the Justice Department’s investigation — launched in 2016 — had identified hundreds of doctors who wrote problematic prescriptions that Walmart’s pharmacists should not have filled. But the lawsuit charged that nearly 70% of the doctors still have active registrations with the DEA.

“Blaming pharmacists for not second-guessing the very doctors the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) approved to prescribe opioids is a transparent attempt to shift blame from DEA’s well-documented failures in keeping bad doctors from prescribing opioids in the first place,” the company said in its statement.

Walmart’s lawsuit alleged the government was blaming it for the lack of regulatory and enforcement policies to stem the crisis. The company is asking a federal judge to declare that the government’s suit has no basis to seek civil damages. That suit remains ongoing.

The initial investigation was the subject of a ProPublica story published in March. ProPublica reported that Joe Brown, then U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Texas office, spent years pursuing a criminal case against Walmart for its opioid prescription practices, only to have it stymied after the retail giant’s lawyers appealed to senior officials in the Justice Department.

Two months later, Brown resigned. He didn’t give a reason for his departure except to say he would be “pursuing opportunities in the private and public sectors.” Brown went into private practice in the Dallas area.

___

D’Innocenzio reported from New York.

Report: Trump Throws Sidney Powell Under The Bus — Again

Sidney Powell has once again found herself down on her luck.

President Trump reportedly informed Powell, who was fired by the Trump campaign following an off-the-rails press conference last month where she peddled bonkers conspiracy theories about the election, on Monday that he isn’t planning to tap her as “special counsel” to probe baseless claims of widespread voter fraud, according to the Daily Beast. Continue reading “Report: Trump Throws Sidney Powell Under The Bus — Again”