Ex-GOP Rep. Taylor Ramps Up Defamation Suit Threats After Staffer Indicted

UNITED STATES - NOVEMBER 16: Rep. Scott Taylor, R-Va., sits on the House steps to do a selfie video about his vote on tax reform on Thursday, Nov. 16, 2017. (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

After a special prosecutor announced Monday that he’d brought two indictments against a staffer on former Rep. Scott Taylor’s (R-VA) unsuccessful 2018 re-election campaign, Taylor took the opportunity to engage in a favorite pastime: threatening defamation lawsuits.

Lauren Creekmore was indicted for election fraud in a scheme intended to boost Taylor’s electoral prospects. But Taylor himself hasn’t been charged with any wrongdoing.

So the Virginia Republican is focusing in on just one sentence from special prosecutor Don Caldwell’s press release — that “based upon information currently available, there does not appear to have been a directive or an expectation that these petitions [later found to contain forged signatures] would be circulated in violation of Virginia law.”

“Threshold for defamation against a public figure is disseminating info you knew was false, with malicious intent,” Taylor wrote on Twitter, tagging the Virginia Democratic Party and the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee. He added later, responding to a statement from the DCCC: “we are exploring our legal options to make them accountable for their disgustingly defamatory ways.” Democrats, he wrote, “spent millions maliciously defaming to win election.”

(In statements, both groups have pointed out that Caldwell’s ongoing investigation has already discovered multiple alleged violations of state law by Taylor’s campaign staff, and may still present more.)

It’s the latest sign that President Trump may have popularized the art of may have lawsuit-threat-as-political-messaging on the right. TPM’s Nicole Lafond has faithfully detailed every absurd twist and turn in California Rep. Devin Nunes’ (R-CA) effort to pursue legal action against a Twitter troll pretending to be his cow, while others, from the family of Covington Catholic High School student Nick Sandmann to conspiracy theorist Jerome Corsi, have filed defamation suits of their own against perceived libelers.

Taylor, for his part, has yet to follow through on any of the defamation suit threats that have come fast and furious since his election scandal first emerged last summer. Several of his staffers turned in forged signatures in an attempt to get an independent candidate on the ballot and, the plan went, peel voters away from Taylor’s Democratic opponent. The plan failed.

As local Democratic volunteer Lindsey Terry, who first flagged the forgeries on her Facebook page, revealed to TPM last year, Taylor called her in a “frantic” state about the posts, pressuring her to take them down.

Taylor was “trying to play the good guy,” Terry recalled, saying he didn’t “want to see any lawsuits happening,” while insinuating that a staffer on his campaign accused of signature forgery “was going to sue me — threatening a lawsuit on her behalf, in that sense.”

Around the same time, according to a screenshot of a since-deleted tweet Terry shared with TPM, Taylor again hinted that the Democratic activist could face legal action for her allegations.

A few days later, as word of the signature forgeries spread, Taylor published a Facebook video, which he later deleted.

Referring to one of his staffers accused of forging signatures, Taylor said “she should sue them. They defamed her publicly. I hope she does sue them.”

The scandal raged on. Taylor, despite his promise to fire anyone on his campaign who “did anything that was wrong,” failed to do so. He lost his reelection campaign.

But he continued to publicly float defamation lawsuits, and cheer on others’, like those filed by Sandmann, the Covington student.

The former congressman didn’t respond to TPM’s Tuesday request for comment. Caldwell noted in his press release that his probe was “continuing.”

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Has Cernovich approved Taylor’s ensemble? Brown shoes with a blue suit, and those socks, is this how a hardened Navy Seal dresses?

  2. Full Trump playbook: loudly proclaim that you’ve been completely exonerated even though no such thing has actually happened, and threaten to go after those nasty political opponents and those media wretches who dared to challenge your royal person.

  3. Avatar for patl patl says:

    Onerous? Some people should not try to show off their vocabularies.

  4. He’s a whiny little bitch who loves to threaten lawsuits in hopes of intimidating people into submitting to his will.

    In other words, the quintessential Rethugliklan.

  5. Avatar for pshah pshah says:

    “Threshold for defamation against a public figure is disseminating info you knew was false, with malicious intent,” Taylor wrote on Twitter, tagging the Virginia Democratic Party and the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.

    You know he’s serious because he put it right out there on Twitter. That’s the vehicle the best legal minds in the country use when they’re delivering a subpoena or issuing some other formal communication.

    I can’t wait to see Dems write up Impeachment charges on Twitter and tag Trump to officially deliver notice.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

20 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for paulw Avatar for slbinva Avatar for sysprog Avatar for globalguy Avatar for sparrowhawk Avatar for lastroth Avatar for midnight_rambler Avatar for ignoreland Avatar for jeffrey Avatar for twowolves Avatar for pshah Avatar for texastwostep Avatar for misterneutron Avatar for nobiru Avatar for patl Avatar for noonm Avatar for tiowally Avatar for clairer Avatar for brian512 Avatar for georgial1beral Avatar for surge Avatar for drtv

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: