Judge Dismisses Ohio Lawsuit Seeking To Rush Out Census Data For Redistricting

A 2020 census letter mailed to a U.S. resident, is shown in Detroit, Sunday, April 5, 2020. The Census Bureau is required by federal statute to send the president the counts that will be used to carve up congressional districts — known as apportionment — and draw state legislative districts by Dec. 31. The new coronavirus COVID-19 spread forced the U.S. Census Bureau to suspend field operations (AP Photo/Paul Sancya)
This April 5, 2020, photo shows a 2020 census letter mailed to a U.S. resident in Detroit. The U.S. Census Bureau needs more time to wrap up the once-a-decade count because of the coronavirus, opening the possibility... This April 5, 2020, photo shows a 2020 census letter mailed to a U.S. resident in Detroit. The U.S. Census Bureau needs more time to wrap up the once-a-decade count because of the coronavirus, opening the possibility of delays in drawing new legislative districts that could help determine what political party is in power, what laws pass or fail and whether communities of color get a voice in their states. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya) MORE LESS

Ohio’s lawsuit challenging the Census Bureau’s delays in releasing the 2020 survey data was dismissed by a federal judge Wednesday.

U.S. District Judge Thomas Rose in Dayton said that the lawsuit, brought by Ohio Attorney General David Yost, had failed to clear various procedural thresholds that would warrant a court’s intervention.

Ohio has already indicated it will appeal the decision. The case is just one front among several battles over how the Census Bureau is planning to roll out the survey’s data and what impact those decisions will have on states’ ability to draw their legislative maps for the next decade

Ohio was seeking an order that the Census Bureau meet its pre-pandemic timeline of releasing redistricting data by March 31, a deadline also set by statute. Last month, the bureau announced that because of pandemic-related issues in the survey, it would need until September to produce the numbers.

In seeking that the bureau release the numbers more quickly, Ohio pointed to a recent amendment to its constitution that lays out a timeline for redistricting that will be impossible to meet with the new delays.

The amendment, as Rose noted, does give the state the option to use other types of data, if the preferred census data is unavailable.

“Ohio will be able to follow its state constitutional procedures and conduct its redistricting regardless of when the Census Bureau delivers its data because the state constitution explicitly contemplates that census data might be ‘unavailable’—and provides a mechanism for that contingency,” he said. He also pushed back at Ohio’s claim that the bureau’s delays would undermine public’s confidence in Ohio’s redistricting process.

“Accuracy would seem to be the foundation of confidence, and Ohio’s redistricting plan foresees the possibility of delays in providing number,” the judge said. “It would seem that the remedy Ohio seeks is more likely to reduce public confidence.”

The Census Bureau’s delays in releasing the numbers are causing real logistical headaches for states with set redistricting deadlines. Alabama has also filed a lawsuit challenging the current September data release date.

But those headaches were exacerbated by the Trump administration flip-flopping on giving the bureau more time to complete the count. Before Trump reversed on giving the bureau four extra months, the bureau was working with individual states whose redistricting timelines were jeopardized by the delays. Two of those states, New Jersey and California, took proactive actions to push back their own redistricting calendars.

“These States gathered information from the Census Bureau and found a way to remedy their own redistricting issues,” the judge said.

Read the order below:

Latest News
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: