Why This GOP Foreign Policy Expert Is ‘Horrified’ By A Trump White House

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Max Boot might not seem the most likely cameo in a pro-Hillary Clinton video, but there the conservative foreign policy expert was, a lifelong Republican decrying Trump as someone not fit to handle the nuclear codes, appearing just before the Fox News commentator Charles Krauthammer.

Boot didn’t know the Democratic National Convention was using a clip of him in its programming Wednesday night, but he told TPM in an email conversation on Thursday that he didn’t object to its strongly anti-Trump message.

A senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, Boot has advised Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) and Mitt Romney on foreign policy. He’s written glowing op-eds about American imperialism, long advocated for military intervention in Syria and Libya, and once wrote the U.S. needed to make a “long-term commitment in Iraq – for 100 years if need be.”

But when Trump launched his candidacy by calling Mexican immigrants “rapists” and drug dealers and, shortly after, attacked Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) for his years spent as a prisoner of war, Boot, a former foreign policy adviser to McCain, said he “hit the roof.”

“I’ve been alarmed and horrified ever since. His rhetoric has gotten even more deranged over the past year,” Boot wrote.

He first described Trump as a “fascist” on Twitter last November and came under fire from fellow conservatives for telling the New York Times in March he would “sooner vote for Josef Stalin” than Trump. Since then Trump’s rhetoric has continued to pitch upward, with the GOP nominee this week “inviting a Russian cyber attack,” as Boot put it.

“I feel it’s my duty as a citizen to speak out against the dangers facing the Republic – and there is no greater danger right now than Donald Trump,” Boot wrote. “I may have lost a few friends along the way; I certainly have strained relationships with the few Trump supporters I know.”

Boot went on to say the “vast majority of thoughtful conservatives” he knows, particularly foreign policy experts, agree a Trump presidency would be disastrous.

So why aren’t they speaking out?

“Some people who know better are too cowed to speak the truth in public,” Boot wrote.

He wrote it also comes down to political opportunism and “exaggerated fear and loathing of Hillary – a lot of conservatives have convinced themselves (wrongly) that Trump, as bad as he is, is better than Clinton.”

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. When you own party calls you a god damn fascist…well, your a fascist.

  2. When you find yourself agreeing with Max Boot …
    Isn’t “thoughtful conservatives” an oxymoron?

  3. You look great in this picture, omahhum.

  4. Not necessarily(there used to be quite a few of them!), but thoughtful ***neo***conservative certainly is! That’s Max’s niche. Never saw a problem more bombing couldn’t solve…

  5. …once wrote the U.S. needed to make a “long-term commitment in Iraq – for 100 years if need be.”

    I’ll have to take a look at that piece. I told some of my neocon friends during the leadup to the Iraq invasion, when Donald Rumsfeld was insisting that it would be a matter of weeks and not months, that if we invaded, we’d be lucky to be out of there in less than 25 years. They thought I was crazy, but it looks like I have come a lot closer to the truth than the Bush Administration “experts” did.

    Donald Trump says it’s not necessary for him to know much, that he can hire “smart people” to guide him. I think recent history will show that a lot of the worst foreign policy disasters were planned by the “smart people.” A president needs to have the knowledge, the judgement, and the temperament to be able to tell the smart people when to go jump in a lake.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

52 more replies


Avatar for system1 Avatar for kendyzdad Avatar for littlegirlblue Avatar for theaney Avatar for randyabraham Avatar for mcbain Avatar for mantan Avatar for sherlock1 Avatar for sonsofares Avatar for jkrogman Avatar for hquain Avatar for stradivarius50t3 Avatar for jeffrey Avatar for pbolo Avatar for wagonmound Avatar for tena Avatar for map2 Avatar for vladomatic Avatar for albesure Avatar for dons2ndunk Avatar for canadachris Avatar for burdyblue Avatar for planetx Avatar for maximus

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: