Maricopa County Recorder Sues Kari Lake For Big Lie-Related Defamation

The lawsuit pulls back the curtain on the hell of being cast as a MAGA universe villain.
PHOENIX, ARIZONA - NOVEMBER 07: Stephen Richer, Maricopa Country Recorder, speaks at a press conference on the midterm elections on November 07, 2022 in Phoenix, Arizona. Maricopa officials spoke about election secur... PHOENIX, ARIZONA - NOVEMBER 07: Stephen Richer, Maricopa Country Recorder, speaks at a press conference on the midterm elections on November 07, 2022 in Phoenix, Arizona. Maricopa officials spoke about election security and false and misleading information. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Maricopa County Recorder Stephen Richer details the way his life has changed since unsuccessful Arizona gubernatorial candidate Kari Lake chose him as a primary antagonist in her Big Lie fantasies: police patrols, spending thousands on home security upgrades, watching his political career prospects diminish.

In a new lawsuit, Richer is suing Lake, her campaign and a Lake fundraising outfit for defamation after Lake repeatedly accused the election official of stealing the 2022 election away from her by tampering with ballot printers and injecting fake ballots into the stream. He also published an op-ed in The Arizona Republic Thursday, detailing his suffering.

Lake channeled those accusations into legal challenges — alongside fundraising bids — and has now lost repeatedly at various Arizona state courts. An Arizona judge rejected her final lawsuit late last month, again affirming that Gov. Katie Hobbs (D) rightfully won the election. 

At times, Richer’s exasperation — also on display when he was called to testify during Lake’s cases — breaks through as his lawyers lay out his case. 

“The early vote ballots dropped off on Election Day — the ones the Defendants claim were injected in order to sway the election away from Lake — actually broke in her favor,” the lawsuit says.

The suit lists dozens of times Lake reiterated these accusations, including on such MAGA-friendly platforms as Donald Trump Jr.’s podcast. 

It also captures many disturbing comments left below Lake’s various media appearances, most of which call for violence. 

“If that’s proven then someone needs to be dismembered,” one reads. 

“The only way this changes is by going after the Republicans that are blocking we the people,” another says. “We need to find and crucify each one.”

Richer is a registered Republican. 

The lawsuit points out that the Department of Justice has charged at least one man for allegedly threatening Richer’s life. 

Richer’s lawyers also write that “several” people filed bar complaints against Richer after Lake and her campaign’s Twitter retweeted guidance from far-right conspiracy theorist Laura Loomer on how to do so. 

The lawsuit details that many of Lake’s claims came alongside fundraising asks, as the MAGA celebrity has continued to milk her Big Lie claims many months after she lost her election.

Richer is seeking nominal damages, compensatory damages, punitive damages, attorney fees and an injunction to compel Lake and the two other related entities to remove the “false and defamatory portions of the statements about Richer” from websites and social media accounts they control.

Lake responded to the lawsuit on Twitter Friday.

“I’m exposing the massive corruption in our elections and this jackass is suing me,” she wrote. “He wants to silence US. Trump won in a landslide & so did I. Everyone knows it.”

The missive ended with a link for supporters to donate.

Read the lawsuit here, via 12 News:

Latest News
50
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. I’m sure Lake will turn this into a fundraising boon for her coffers.

  2. I’m confused why Richer thinks his political career is diminishing because of this. He could just become a Democrat. I mean, it’s not as if the Republicans are a functioning political party anyway. I’m astonished that someone like Richer who wants to do his job thinks that the only way to do it is by being a Republican. If his goal is good government and doing his job right, then he should join the party that will allow him to do that. On the other hand, if his goal is advancing the very specific agenda of the right, then maybe he really needs to do some soul-searching about what that agenda really is and why it matters so much to him.

  3. I can only hope that Mr. Richer prevails and takes this idiot to the cleaners. Ms. Lake ain’t playing with a full deck.

  4. “I’m exposing the massive corruption in our elections and this jackass is suing me,” she wrote. “He wants to silence US. Trump won in a landslide & so did I. Everyone knows it.”

    “Everyone knows it.” New mantra of MAGA.

  5. I too hope that Mr. Richer prevails, but Ms. Lake ain’t no fool. She knows what she’s doing. This all about keeping her name in the public and her grievance grift going.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

44 more replies

Participants

Avatar for runfastandwin Avatar for richardinjax Avatar for epicurus Avatar for trnc Avatar for steviedee111 Avatar for m3man Avatar for sonsofares Avatar for lastroth Avatar for tao Avatar for dangoodbar Avatar for darrtown Avatar for wintermoon Avatar for edhedh Avatar for birdford Avatar for cgrutherford Avatar for texastoast Avatar for kenga Avatar for jhoskinson Avatar for ProgressPoint Avatar for iafixture Avatar for timbomov Avatar for xcopy Avatar for john_adams Avatar for doncoolidge

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: