Conservatives Grudgingly Give Clinton The Edge Or Call It A Draw In First Debate

Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton laughs with Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump following their presidential debate at Hofstra University in Hempstead, N.Y., Monday, Sept. 26, 2016. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Conservative pundits criticized the performance of both Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton in the first presidential debate, but many grudgingly gave the edge to the former secretary of state.

The consensus Monday night seemed to hold that Trump performed well in the first half of the debate, but stumbled as the 90-minute event dragged on. The real estate mogul was pressed to explain his changing record on the Iraq War, his recently-renounced belief that President Barack Obama may not have been born in the United States, and his past derogatory remarks about women.

Several commentators insisted that whatever the results, moderator and NBC News anchor Lester Holt gave Hillary Clinton easier questions (Trump himself said Holt did “a great job” and that the questions were “very fair”).

One publication immediately jumped to Trump’s defense. Breitbart News, which has openly supported the billionaire businessman’s campaign and whose chairman, Steve Bannon, is currently serving as Trump’s campaign CEO, pushed a story at the conclusion of the debate that accused Holt of ripping questions “straight from the Clinton campaign’s talking points.”

Read reactions from other conservative writers and strategists below:

Conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt in a debate wrap interview on MSNBC:

“I think Donald Trump won the first—I clocked it at 29 minutes when birtherism came up. He blew that badly, terribly, and it turned the debate around. She then delivered a knockout blow on speaking to our strategic allies.”

Daily Caller writer Jamie Weinstein:

Commentary editor Noah Rothman:

Conservative blogger Erick Erickson:

John Podhoretz, former Ronald Reagan speech writer and Commentary editor:

Daily Wire editor Ben Shapiro:

Conservative writer and former Breitbart editor John Nolte wrote that the debate was “biased” in Clinton’s favor, but knocked Trump’s performance:

CNN commentator and former Ted Cruz spokeswoman Amanda Carpenter:

Conservative blogger AGConservative:

Fox News host Greg Gutfeld:

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for bdtex bdtex says:

    He did ok for the first 22 mins,not 29. The only way he could improve would be to study bigly on the issues and be better informed.

  2. Avatar for agio agio says:

    Breitbart is just a bunch of whiny ass titty babies. They can dish out the lumps but they sure can’t take them.

  3. Avatar for agio agio says:

    Lay of the blow next time, perhaps.

  4. Avatar for mrf mrf says:

    Campaign manager Conway over the weekend was calling Trump the Babe Ruth of debaters. A little league player or member of the high school debate team would be more cogent and knowledgable. How did the man do at military academy or Wharton?

  5. I thought she did really well. I’m greatly relieved. I hope this swings the momentum of the campaign beyond his ability to recover. Time will tell.

Continue the discussion at

93 more replies


Avatar for mmurdoch Avatar for agio Avatar for clunkertruck Avatar for cwazycajun Avatar for randyabraham Avatar for wanderer Avatar for inversion Avatar for noparty Avatar for daveyjones64 Avatar for sherlock1 Avatar for mildly_subversive Avatar for magical_panda Avatar for candacetx Avatar for captaincommonsense Avatar for careysub Avatar for mrf Avatar for darrtown Avatar for shorebreeze Avatar for zang Avatar for georgemilquetoast Avatar for meta Avatar for clauscph Avatar for bodie1 Avatar for coprophagoussmile

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: