Congress Throws More Money at Removing Immigrants than Most Countries Spend on Their Armies

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement's (ICE) special agent preparing to arrest alleged immigration violators at Fresh Mark, Salem, June 19, 2018. Image courtesy ICE ICE / U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. (... US Immigration and Customs Enforcement's (ICE) special agent preparing to arrest alleged immigration violators at Fresh Mark, Salem, June 19, 2018. Image courtesy ICE ICE / U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. (Photo by Smith Collection/Gado/Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

It’s hard to convey just how big the new budget makes the country’s immigration enforcement infrastructure.

The Bureau of Prisons? Bigger than that. The FBI? Bigger. The Marine Corps? Bigger even than that, by some estimates.

All in all, the bill directs around $170 billion through 2029 to various forms of immigration enforcement, according to an analysis by the American Immigration Council and TPM’s own read of the legislation. ICE, responsible for enforcement, detentions, and removals, will oversee much of the spending.

The picture is not so much of an expanded immigration enforcement system, but of an entirely new one.

“It’s going to get really scary,” Adriel Orozco, senior policy counsel for the American Immigration Council, told TPM. “I do think that we are in a place where the Trump administration is centering a lot of the law enforcement authority of the federal government into the Department of Homeland Security.”

Take this example of how the legislation ranks which parts of the immigration system are important.

The bill gives ICE $29.8 billion to hire new staff and conduct deportations. That will lead to a hiring spurt of deportation officers; an additional $4.1 billion bump goes to Customs and Border Protection for new personnel.

For immigration detention, also overseen by ICE, the bill allocates a whopping $45 billion.

If that’s not enough, there’s more: Remember the wall? It was Trump’s big immigration-related promise during the 2016 campaign. It didn’t get built during his first term (and Mexico never paid for it, as Trump promised). Congress allocated $46.5 billion for its construction in this legislation. (A Senate source tells TPM that this, too, was drafted in such a way as to be fungible, so it could be used for building detention facilities as well.)

It’s a headspinning increase from ICE’s 2024 funding, that, per a recent CRS report, stood at $9.9 billion.

At the same time, the bill adds only a modest number of immigration judges, capping the number at 800 starting in November 2028 — an increase from the current approximately 700.

Tom Homan, Trump’s border czar, cast the funding surge last week in the administration’s favored light: a means of evicting criminal aliens from the country. The operation that the numbers envision goes far beyond that; Homan complained that, at current funding levels, the country only has between five and six thousand deportation officers.

“More agents means more bad guys arrested, taken off the streets of this country every single day,” he said of the new funding. “Every day we arrest a public safety threat or national security threat, that makes this country much safer. Who the hell would be against that?”

To Homan, the Trump administration, and its allies in the right-wing media, every undocumented immigrant apprehended and removed is a criminal alien. It’s how they cast the Alien Enemies Act removals, even though a 60 Minutes analysis found that around three-quarters of those removed had no documented criminal background.

The point is mostly to justify the massive scale of the resources now being marshaled to detain and eject immigrants. This is all new money to be added on top of that which Congress has already marked for immigration enforcement. Under this legislation, ICE will receive a budget for detention alone that’s more than two-thirds larger than that of the federal prison system. The bill also makes a $10 billion slush fund available to the Secretary of Homeland Security, currently Kristi Noem, for reimbursing “costs incurred in undertaking activities in support of the Department of Homeland Security’s mission to safeguard the borders of the United States.”

Absent the constant claim, expressed by Homan and others, that undocumented immigrants present a criminal threat beyond the administrative violation of crossing the border, there’s little argument for this level of spending.

Orozco, the Immigration Council attorney, said that more than half of those currently in immigration detention had no criminal record.

“It’s a lie that they’re trying to use these resources just for folks with, with serious criminal histories,” he said.

For the past five months, immigration enforcement has been the focus of the Trump administration’s most egregious abuses of civil liberties. Removing people to El Salvador’s CECOT without a hearing; using the military to intimidate anti-ICE protests in Los Angeles. It’s the tipping point of the spear for much of the current administration’s authoritarian impulses.

Because of this, that’s about to get a lot bigger.

Latest News
118
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. With the bill being into law, the U.S. is now fully a police state. While kicking out undocumented migrants are the first target, we are next. They seek to fill the concentration camps with “denaturalized” Americans and native born citizens who dissent from the Trump regime.

    On a personal note, I am a dual citizen of Greece. I did it because I saw during Trump 1.0 what is coming. My wife and adult children are applying for Greek citizenship as soon as the paperwork are in order. My grandparents came to America and it’s possible if it becomes bad enough here for me to spend my retirement years in a country my family left in the early 20th century. My children and their spouses could live anywhere in the E.U. as Greek citizens and their families. It’s a reverse migration.

    I never thought this could happen until recently.

  2. Today’s Heather. Paul’s taking the 4th off.

    Moved our son into Toronto last night. Canadian border personnel could not have been more warmly respectful. Mortifyingly embarrased to be an American by what our government has become and is doing.

    Will we live up to our era’s attack on our founding principles? Washington trusted in Providence to establish those principles in the despairing, darkest days of defeat in NY in 1776. Lincoln called on our “better angels” to deliver a just victory for those principles in 1865. Now it’s our turn. We dare not despair if we hope to rise to the challenge. Police states have been defeated. We must smash ours with solidarity.

  3. I hope Canada joins the European Union— which could happen if the U.S. descent into fascism continues. Then my family can just move to Canada like your son has (intelligently) done.

  4. I can’t help but think that while all the federal government’s time, resources, and money are being overwhelming directed towards terrorizing immigrants, that America’s homegrown criminals (who have always outnumber undocumented immigrant criminals) are going to feel emboldened to go about their merry way.

  5. Russia used to have a problem with immigrants from Central Asia, but the attraction for migrants has faded since it included the possibility of being hustled off to the Ukraine front. And as for problematic oligarchs and business execs? High buildings and gravity do the job.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

112 more replies

Participants

Avatar for mondfledermaus Avatar for eggrollian Avatar for left_in_washington_state Avatar for califdemdreamer Avatar for fiftygigs Avatar for darrtown Avatar for thunderclapnewman Avatar for southerndem Avatar for jtx Avatar for susanintheoc Avatar for charlie6 Avatar for birdford Avatar for giveitathink Avatar for tmulcaire Avatar for brian512 Avatar for coimmigrant Avatar for kelaine Avatar for counterlife Avatar for bcgister Avatar for zenicetus Avatar for garrybee Avatar for Fire_Joni_Ernst Avatar for john_adams Avatar for Muse

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Deputy Editor for News:
Deputy Editor for Audience and Strategy:
Editor-at-Large:
Contributing Editor:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher & Digital Producer:
Senior Developer:
Senior Designer: