Appeals Court Reinstates Florida’s Ex-Felon ‘Poll Tax’ Law While It Hears Case

ORLANDO, UNITED STATES-JANUARY 08: Desmond Meade, right, is accompanied by his daughter, Xcellence Meade, center, and his wife, Sheena Meade, inside the Orange County Supervisor of Elections office as he registers to... ORLANDO, UNITED STATES-JANUARY 08: Desmond Meade, right, is accompanied by his daughter, Xcellence Meade, center, and his wife, Sheena Meade, inside the Orange County Supervisor of Elections office as he registers to vote after ex-felons regained their voting rights in the state Tuesday, Jan. 8, 2019, in Orlando, Florida. (Photo by Phelan M. Ebenhack for The Washington Post via Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

A federal judge’s ruling striking down Florida’s ex-felon “poll tax” law was put on hold Wednesday, after the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit voted to hear the case.

Florida had used an uncommon procedural move to get the case in front of the full circuit court — which was recently flipped to a majority GOP-appointed court — while skipping the usual step of having the case first heard by a three-judge panel from the appeals court.

The 11th Circuit said Wednesday that it would follow up with an order laying out a briefing schedule. At stake are the voting rights of hundreds of thousands of ex-felons in the swing state who still owe court fines and fees. The trial court judge had ruled that Florida could not block ex-felons from voting if they could not afford to pay off those fees.

Florida voters approved in 2018 a constitutional amendment restoring the franchise of more than 1 million ex-felons in the states. The Republican legislature passed a law in 2019 requiring the repayment of all court fees before an ex-felon can register. It was immediately met by a legal challenge from individual ex-felons and from voting rights groups, who have argued that the regime amounted to an unconstitutional poll tax.

The state suffered a series of legal defeats in its defense of the law, culminating in the ruling in May by U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle concluding that the law was unconstitutional.

The spring 2020 trial made clear that election officials had not worked out a process for keeping track of which ex-felons who still faced financial obligations that made them ineligible to vote under the 2019 law.  An expert for the challengers testified that nearly 80 percent of the 1 million-plus ex-felons covered by the 2018 ballot initiative owed $500 or more in court fees.

Hinkle’s order set up a system for determining if an ex-felon seeking to register to vote was unable to pay pending court fees.

The 11th Circuit granted the state’s request to put that order on hold while it hears the case. Of the ten appellate judges who are considering the case, six are GOP appointees. Five of those GOP appointee were put on the circuit court by President Trump.

Latest News
79
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. What BS! That is all.

  2. Some positive news re-access to voting:

    Rachel Maddow MSNBC Retweeted




    Ari Berman
    @AriBerman

    ·

    1h

    This is really awesome: Detroit Pistons will use their practice facility as huge polling location, where voters can also register on Election Day A few days ago Atlanta Hawks announced their arena would be largest polling place in Fulton County GA

    Quote Tweet

    Detroit Pistons

    @DetroitPistons

    · 1h

    We are partnering with @michsos office and City Clerk of Detroit’s Office on a series of initiatives to drive voter awareness and participation.
    The @HenryFordNews Detroit Pistons Performance Center will serve as a voting center for the November 3 election.

  3. The result?

    GOP chicanery at its best…

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

73 more replies

Participants

Avatar for playitagainrowlf Avatar for old_curmudgeon Avatar for globalguy Avatar for theod Avatar for krusher Avatar for steviedee111 Avatar for turdburgler Avatar for mickeyg Avatar for kenstarr Avatar for sniffit Avatar for sickneffintired Avatar for lastroth Avatar for harry_r_sohl Avatar for deere_john Avatar for pshah Avatar for tribalogical Avatar for tena Avatar for isepick Avatar for birdford Avatar for burningquestions Avatar for qwerty23 Avatar for occamscoin Avatar for bunnyvelour Avatar for emiliano4

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: