Manafort Previews His Defense: It’s Rick Gates’ Fault

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

ALEXANDRIA, VA —Delivering his opening statement at the Virginia trial of former Trump campaign chair Paul Manafort, his defense attorney targeted Manafort’s longtime business deputy Rick Gates for allegedly “abusing” Manafort’s trust and accused him of embezzling millions of dollars from his former employer.

“Rick Gates violated one of life’s most basic rules: when you’re in a hole, stop digging,” attorney Thomas Zehnle said.

His 30-minute opening statement painted Manafort as a successful but busy global consultant who trusted Gates and other outside professionals to handle the day-to-day operations of his business, including its finances.

“Unfortunately for Paul Manafort, his trust in Rick Gates was misplaced,” Zehnle told the jury.

Manafort is facing charges of bank fraud and tax fraud. He has pleaded not guilty. In his opening statement, prosecutor Uzo Asonye: “All of these charges boil down to one simple issue: Did Paul Manafort lie?”

Gates was originally a co-defendant in the case, until reaching a plea deal with special counsel Robert Mueller in February. He is expected to testify against Manafort in the trial.

Zehnle accused Gates of having an “evolving” story about his dealings with Manafort, and pointed out that as part of his plea agreement, he pleaded guilty to making a false statement to the prosecutors during plea negotiations.

“The foundation of the special counsel’s case rests squarely on this witness,” Zehnle said.

In Zehnle’s retelling it was Gates who was the point person for Manafort’s book-keepers and tax preparers.

“Little did Paul know that Rick was lining his own pockets,” Zehnle said.

Gates misled the outside accountants, Zehnle said, because “he had his hands in the cookie jar,” and couldn’t let anyone know.

Among the government’s allegations is that Manafort failed to disclose to the government foreign bank accounts, through which flowed money Manafort made doing lucrative consulting in Ukraine work. Zehnle said Manafort was not responsible for how or why those foreign bank accounts were set up, but was required by the Ukrainian backers paying his consulting bills that he be paid this way.

Of Manafort’s Ukraine endeavors, where he advised the pro-Russian Party of Regions and ex-President Victor Yanukovych, Zehnle said the “focus” of Manafort and his associates efforts “was to bring the country closer to western democracy.”

As for Mueller’s bank fraud allegations, Zehnle said that Manafort was “open” with the outside professionals who helped to facilitate loans, about why he was seeking the money and what he planned to spend it on. He said that Manafort was in the process of paying back the loans, before Mueller brought charges against him and his assets were seized.

Latest Muckraker

Notable Replies

  1. ’NO, U’ does not seem to me to be a particularly robust legal defense, but I guess you go to court with the arguments you have, not the arguments you wish you had.

    At least it’s simple in description.

  2. Um… that’s not going to work. Does Manafort have a plan B? If not… well, I guess he’s probably used to jail by now, which is where he’ll be staying for a very long time.

  3. Avatar for zsak zsak says:

    Based on his pretrial motion success … GUILTY

  4. That isn’t a bad defense. Gates is the star witness. Paint him as the real bad guy who cut a deal to save his own skin. I don’t think it survives given the rest of the evidence, but it is the best defense they could come up with.

  5. You dropped this:

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

72 more replies

Participants

Avatar for jootjoint Avatar for cervantes Avatar for dave48 Avatar for becca656 Avatar for sniffit Avatar for ralph_vonholst Avatar for longtimeobserver Avatar for loretta Avatar for greylady Avatar for dave_mb Avatar for benthere Avatar for spencersmom Avatar for gusfabriani Avatar for jacksonhts Avatar for noonm Avatar for asturcot Avatar for alana Avatar for erik_t Avatar for justruss Avatar for karlwlewis Avatar for atldrew Avatar for romarco Avatar for rascal_crone Avatar for omegalimit

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: