Jonah Goldberg: Carson May Be ‘More Authentically African-American’ Than Obama

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Jonah Goldberg, a senior editor at the National Review, suggested in a Friday column that retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson is “more authentically African-American” than President Obama.

The conservative author lamented that the media never mentions that Carson is black before launching into his argument that Carson is “more” black than the president. Read Goldberg’s comparison between Carson and Obama”

But what’s remarkable is that at no point in this conversation did anyone call attention to the fact that Carson is an African-American. Indeed, most analysis of Carson’s popularity from pundits focuses on his likable personality and his sincere Christian faith. But it’s intriguingly rare to hear people talk about the fact that he’s black.

One could argue that he’s even more authentically African-American than Barack Obama, given that Obama’s mother was white and he was raised in part by his white grandparents. In his autobiography, Obama writes at length about how he grew up outside the traditional African-American experience — in Hawaii and Indonesia — and how he consciously chose to adopt a black identity when he was in college.

Meanwhile, Carson grew up in Detroit, the son of a very poor, very hard-working single mother. His tale of rising from poverty to become the head of pediatric neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital is one of the most inspiring rags-to-riches stories of the last half-century. (Cuba Gooding Jr. played Carson in the movie about his life.) He was a towering figure in the black community in Baltimore and nationally — at least, until he became a Republican politician.

And that probably explains why his race seems to be such a non-issue for the media. The New York Times is even reluctant to refer to him as a doctor. The Federalist reports that Jill Biden, who has a doctorate in education, is three times more likely to be referred to as “Dr.” in the Times as brain surgeon Carson. If the Times did that to a black Democrat, charges of racism would be thick in the air.

Goldberg’s comments are reminiscent of tweets published by Rupert Murdoch earlier in October suggesting that Obama is not a “real black president.”

Murdoch later apologized.

H/t Media Matters

Latest Livewire

Notable Replies

  1. I love how white republicans feel compelled to tell black folks which ones are blacker.

  2. Well, who is better to judge the matter - ¿Qui es mui negro? - than Jonah Goldberg?

  3. What the hell is the last part about? The media refuses to refer to him as a Dr.? That’s pretty much how I always see him introduced/referred to.

  4. WTF?

    “And that probably explains why his race seems to be such a non-issue for the media.”

    Seriously, what? For the last seven years you guys have screamed pretty regularly that race should not be an issue – not even a token issue. Also, assholes, please remember that Carson is running for president – Barack Obama has already been there, done that. You are not competing with Obama, so why keep invoking the man and his mother? Oh, that’s right – it’s because you sincerely can’t stand President Obama’s accomplishments and wish to tarnish him as much as possible to make you guys appear shinier. Sorry. Not working.

  5. Avatar for mantan mantan says:

    An imagination is a terrible thing to waste…

Continue the discussion at

172 more replies


Avatar for charliee Avatar for jloomis3 Avatar for leftflank Avatar for humpback Avatar for fargo116 Avatar for teenlaqueefa Avatar for boscobrown Avatar for inversion Avatar for mantan Avatar for sniffit Avatar for mikethebookie Avatar for richardnixonhuberthumphrey Avatar for ottnott Avatar for sangsue Avatar for jeffrey Avatar for jeffyjm Avatar for khaaannn Avatar for fiftygigs Avatar for darrtown Avatar for emilianoelmexicano Avatar for jonney_5 Avatar for clauscph Avatar for pmaroneyb Avatar for lkeitherz

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: