Fox Columnist: Bergdahl Trade Is Like Releasing ‘Nazi Germany’s Top Leaders’

This undated image provided by the U.S. Army shows Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl. The nearly five-year effort to free the only American soldier held captive in Afghanistan is scattered among numerous federal agencies with a loo... This undated image provided by the U.S. Army shows Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl. The nearly five-year effort to free the only American soldier held captive in Afghanistan is scattered among numerous federal agencies with a loosely organized group of people working on it mostly part time, according to two members of Congress and military officials involved in the effort. An ever-shrinking U.S. military presence in Afghanistan has re-focused attention on efforts to bring home Bergdahl, who has been held by the Taliban since June 30, 2009. (AP Photo/U.S. Army) MORE LESS

A former Pentagon spokesman joined the chorus of conservatives who criticized the prisoner exchange that secured the release of Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, calling it the “most shocking military decision” he’s ever seen and asserting that Franklin D. Roosevelt never would released top Nazi leaders during World War II.

In a column Monday for FoxNews.com, J.D. Gordon was extremely critical of the Obama administration’s decision to release five senior Taliban figures held at Guantanamo Bay in exchange for Bergdahl.

“In 1943, could anyone imagine FDR releasing five of Nazi Germany’s top leaders for a disgruntled soldier? Though it’s good news that Bergdahl has been freed, I believe this grossly uneven prisoner exchange will encourage Al Qaeda and Taliban terrorists to seek out other U.S. military hostages,” Gordon wrote. “After Saturday’s swap, they are literally worth more than their weight in gold while in enemy hands.”

He repeated the point during an appearance Monday afternoon on Fox.

“I think our military is very upset and ashamed,” Gordon said. “They realize that there’s a bullseye on their back right now because al Qaeda, the Taliban see if they can capture a U.S. troop or even if a troop walks off-base, whatever the circumstances are, they’re going to be worth their weight in gold because the Taliban can now say, ‘OK, we want Guantanamo closed.’ Al Qaeda could say, ‘We want Khalid Sheikh Mohammed back.’ This this most shocking military decision I ever recall seeing.”

50
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. “This this most shocking military decision I ever recall seeing.”

    Aiding and abetting torture isn’t shocking enough? The NSA which is under military rule isn’t shocking enough?

    But a prisoner swap, which has been going on since the dawn of war, is somehow shocking?

    Pathetic.

  2. “I think our military is very upset and ashamed,” Gordon said. “They realize that there’s a bullseye on their back right now because al Qaeda, the Taliban see if they can capture a U.S. troop or even if a troop walks off-base, whatever the circumstances are, they’re going to be worth their weight in gold because the Taliban can now say, ‘OK, we want Guantanamo closed.’ Al Qaeda could say, ‘We want Khalid Sheikh Mohammed back.’ This this most shocking military decision I ever recall seeing.”

    So instead of killing him, they will take him prisoner and use this to negotiate the release of other prisoners. Shocking!

  3. Keep it up with the continuous Nazi analogies, it means very little to most people now.

  4. Everything this administration does is the worstest thing ever that anyone can recall, ever, by anyone, ever. Why?

    Osama Bin Laden is dead.

    ACA is working very well.

    The GOP won’t sniff the White House for a generation.

  5. Yes. We would have traded with the Nazis if at the conclusion of hostilities they had some of our POWs.

    By changing the taliban from an enemy we respect, to an “illegal” enemy, we lost the opportunity to treat their prisoners as POWs, which, let’s face it, they are. Exchanging POWs is normal.

    I get so angry at these people.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

44 more replies

Participants

Avatar for lestatdelc Avatar for austin_dave Avatar for ealleniii Avatar for srfromgr Avatar for sooner Avatar for brooklyndweller Avatar for jloomis3 Avatar for jep07 Avatar for deckbose Avatar for manhattan123 Avatar for enon Avatar for jtgeomom Avatar for sylhines Avatar for orthostice Avatar for arc_of_the_universe Avatar for hilpalny Avatar for maxaroo Avatar for Scan Avatar for jimgroom Avatar for khaaannn Avatar for darrtown Avatar for shorebreeze Avatar for ElderDavid Avatar for lcelsie

Continue Discussion