Judge Calls Out Von Spakovsky For Hypocritical Voter Fraud Definition

Full committee hearing on the nomination Hans von Spakovsky to be a commissioner of the Federal Election Commission. (CQ Roll Call via AP Images)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

KANSAS CITY, KANSAS — Before the ACLU had a chance to cross-examine Hans von Spakovsky, a witness for Kris Kobach in his voter proof-of-citizenship case, Judge Julie Robinson intervened to zero in on what appeared to be a contradiction in von Spakovsky’s definition of voter fraud.

In doing so, Judge Robinson appeared to undermine a central tenet of the claim, made by von Spakovsky and Kobach among others, that strict voting laws are needed to combat voter fraud.

Earlier, Kansas Secretary of State Kobach had asked von Spakovsky what his definition of voter fraud was. Lorraine Minnite, an expert witness for the ACLU, had in previous testimony defined voter fraud as the “intentional corruption” of the electoral process by voters.

Von Spakovsky denied that intention or knowledge was necessary to consider an instance of illegal voting or registration fraud. He said that, regardless of their intention, whenever a non-citizen registers or votes “they are defrauding citizens” of a legitimate election.

That assessment caught Judge Julie Robinson’s attention. Between Kobach’s questioning and ACLU cross-examination, she asked about that definition, and brought up the thousands of citizens qualified to vote who are denied the ability to vote, alluding to restrictive laws.

“Would that not also be defrauding the electoral process?” asked Robinson, an appointee of President George W. Bush.

Von Spakovsky said no, and brought up voter ID laws and the case law around them. Von Spakovsky has been a staunch supporter of restrictive voting laws.

“As long as you have an open process to allow the potential voter to obtain the ID to vote,” that’s neither discriminatory nor unconstitutional, then the system is not being defrauded, he said.

Robinson said she was taking from that answer that von Spakovsky wanted to consider the context around burdens in this case. But, conversely, in non-citizen voting — whether that person made a mistake or there was an administrative error — context shouldn’t be considered, she said, describing von Spakovsky’s apparent view.

Why should you only look at it contextually when talking about citizens? Robinson asked.

Von Spakovsky tried to avoid the contradiction again, and said that context should be considered in prosecutions.

“I am not asking about prosecution,” Robinson said. She was asking him how he characterized voter fraud, she said.

Again, von Spakovsky brought up the distinctions he saw between prosecutions and the effect of when a non-citizen casts a ballot.

But Robinson appeared unconvinced. For thousands who are actual citizens, Robinson said, “that’s not diluting the vote? And that’s not impairing the integrity of the electoral process, I take it?”

Latest Kobach Voting Rights Trial

Notable Replies

  1. good going judge - burn that nazi to the ground!!!

    HVS has been a flaming POS in our society for far too long.

  2. Actually found some live footage of the judge during her questioning:

    Kobach is the guy backing away from the glass like “ewwww”…

  3. Avatar for zd123 zd123 says:

    This brings up a really good point. How many cases of people who are eligible to vote are turned away, because of mistakes made in the voter lists, ill-informed poll workers (almost happened to me), too few ballots printed, being directed to the wrong polling place or being turned away. It sure as hell is a lot more than 5. How many people associated with those offenses have been prosecuted?

  4. Very sharp Judge — she, like everyone, knows this is really about vote suppression.

  5. Hans von Spakovsky is a Kobach witness on voter fraud? That’s funny, since all this dude understands is voter suppression.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

95 more replies

Participants

Avatar for valgalky23 Avatar for heysailor Avatar for xpurg8d Avatar for littlegirlblue Avatar for old_curmudgeon Avatar for ncsteve Avatar for headhunter212 Avatar for george_spiggott Avatar for losamigos Avatar for sniffit Avatar for sickneffintired Avatar for borisjimbo Avatar for lastroth Avatar for ronbyers Avatar for mrf Avatar for rod Avatar for rptwiz Avatar for cologirl Avatar for jsrtheta Avatar for thinski Avatar for touchdownjesus Avatar for checkmate2016 Avatar for kenga Avatar for atldrew

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: